Changes vs Collingwood

[Kane McGoodwin]

B: McLeod, Rutten, Bassett
HB: Massie, Bock, Doughty
C: Knights, van Berlo, Vince
HF: Goodwin, Gill, Stevens
F: Edwards, Tippett, Porplyzia
R: Maric, Thompson, Shirley
I: Moran, Symes, Douglas, Mackay
E: Reilly, Johncock, Otten

In: Moran
Out: Johncock

Need the extra tall option IMO & stiffy least deserving at the moment.

Would like to bting in Reilly, but Douglas, Mackay, Symes, etc done little wrong. Another week for Sturt against Bullies to get him right wouldn't harm.

 

[jenny61_99]

If Reilly is fit, I'd almost be tempted to drop Porps and Johncock and bring in Radar and Moran.

 

[KingsCrow]

Zing. I would say Douglas or Johncock would be the only players on the edge.


I'd swap Moran>Douglas & Rielly>Johncock.


Saying that I would like the team to go unchanged but Craigey is our man and I am sure he will make the right choice.

 

[-CG-]

Porplyzia hopeful of keeping finals dream alive
By Katrina Gill
2:02 PM Wed 03 September, 2008

The classy forward had a brief chat with coach Neil Craig at Wednesday’s training session and said he would know his fate by that afternoon.

“Craigy and I were just discussing our plans for this week and whether we’re going to go ahead [with me playing] and we’re yet to make that decision,” Porplyzia said.

“I’m still planning on going ahead and, at this stage, we’re going ahead.”

More to follow…

Full story

 

[jackster83]

I'd much rather Gill at CHF than Moran as I don't think we can rely on an inexperienced, unnatural forward in the finals. Gill has only played 15 games but has played the game for longer than Moran who scored his 4 goal haul against the might of the Carlton defence.

Reilly in for Mackay who has been quiet in the last 2 weeks.

If Knights or Vince are still struggling with injury then Moran can come in.

 

[SydCrow]

You drop our best player from ,last week. Massie did a real job on Johnson who is a superstar of the comp. Have to disagree with that post.
I don't see how we can make realistic judgements without knowing how fit the guys actually are. Trust the selectors although I'd rest Porps this week. If the weather is dry...in Moran......if wet Rielly.

How long was the superstar on the bench getting his head stitched and bandaged?