- Oct 27, 2007
- 11,471
- 13,227
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Along with all the other halfback's? Malceski can't get a game as it is, so I'm sure he wouldn't be impressed!
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Early Trade Week Thread
- Thread starter strauchanie59
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
Along with all the other halfback's? Malceski can't get a game as it is, so I'm sure he wouldn't be impressed!
We have Heath to do that role we don't need that richmond tosser
No we have Mal, and then we also have Sumner (possibly) and C Heath
Maybe reserves watchers can shed more light, but at the backend of the season he was in the bests most of the weeks. bee very unlucky with injuries, would much ather these 3 than Jackson.
Why do you think that Jackson would make a good HBF, what qualilties in his game have you seen that made you think think that
EDIT: beaten by Bedford
We shouldn't be taking anyone unless they're very good footballers, which means it doesn't matter if we have more than enough players for the same position, or unless they can fill a role in our side that isn't currently overflowing with candidates.
Jackson doesn't meet either of those requirements.
Jackson doesn't meet either of those requirements.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
disgruntled goat
Premiership Player
Yeah, but who knows what's going to happen between now and trade week. Why would you assume all our players are safe? How would Dan Currie have felt when we loaded up on rucks two years back?
I'm just saying there might be more to this than other rumours, mainly because I think jackson expressed interest in the Swans a year or two back.
We're just spitballing here, right? It's not the club's list management people talking.
disgruntled goat
Premiership Player
Whatever his faults, he can read the play and has a very strong kick. He's an ordinary shot for goal but I think his general field kicking is pretty good. I just don't think he's as bad as others do, and I also don't think the Sumner issue is really an argument. Does anyone really believe he'll stay with us?
Jackson is an ordinary player from an ordinary side who doesn't fill a need or provide anything tangible that would take us closer to a premiership. He would be a list clogger who would take games off our younger players on the fringe of the senior side.
Have to disagree on his field kicking, he is a poor kick, might be a long kick but if it dies straight back to the opposition then its not that useful. From what i have seen from him, his main strenghts are his clearnace work and he is a decent tagger/ run with player, you have to have decent pace as well to imapct on a contest or run the ball out of defense, he is pretty slow, so i just dont see it with him, and even if we did go for him it would certainly woul dnot be with our 2nd round pick, it would have to be something similar to the pick we used on spangher
With regards to SUmner that swith i wrote possibly, but C Heath has been on our list for 3 or so years has been playing good footy and deserves his chance
disgruntled goat
Premiership Player
Mr Goat i think you are outnumbered lol
We got spangher for pick 70 odd, Jackson they are asking for pick 40ish
Our last two drafts the players we got around that pick were S Reid and L Parker
Anyways read on teh richmond board that jackson said on the b&f night that he is staying at richmond
disgruntled goat
Premiership Player
Aint stopped me before.
disgruntled goat
Premiership Player
There y'go, then. Problem solved.
Jack2Johnston
All Australian
Having seen a lot of Spangher at the Eagles you could count me amongst those posters, and i stand by what I would have said then, Spangher is not an AFL grade defender.
I still don't think he is a natural defender, however his work as a forward has been extremely encouraging and I am happy he is currently in the team and at the club.
Interesting in Spanghers interview before his debut for us he said long term he sees himself as a defender, I wonder if that has changed now.
- Jul 13, 2008
- 5,140
- 5,072
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Thread starter
- #715
Not sure if it's just me but anyone think that we should try and get Adam Schneider back with the departure of Lyon? Could really add something to our forward line and make it complete.
I'll definitely put my hand up and say I thought Spangher was absolute rubbish in his time as a defender for WCE. And I stand by that.
But what he's done for us as a leading forward has been exactly what we need. His inclusion with White, Parker and Rohan (and their consequent work together as the forward line) has been the main factor behind our run over the last month.
All power to him.
But what he's done for us as a leading forward has been exactly what we need. His inclusion with White, Parker and Rohan (and their consequent work together as the forward line) has been the main factor behind our run over the last month.
All power to him.
barry fu
Premiership Player
Not sure on Higgins, a little too Alfa Romeo for my liking.
Connors, not Jackson, though Jackson is not as bad as some might say. Needs to sort his fV<king barnet though.
Spangher has been a bargin, and will do bung knee Buddy if need be. To think he was training with the Dawks prior to the draft and is now playing a key part in our end of season surge.
I salute Spangher, and the man who convinced club BLOODS to bid for the boy.
Connors, not Jackson, though Jackson is not as bad as some might say. Needs to sort his fV<king barnet though.
Spangher has been a bargin, and will do bung knee Buddy if need be. To think he was training with the Dawks prior to the draft and is now playing a key part in our end of season surge.
I salute Spangher, and the man who convinced club BLOODS to bid for the boy.
- Banned
- #718
The only players who we should even consider trading for are the HFF/Wing types who are excellent offensively. Someone like Higgins, Pearce, or any other of those types are exactly what we need to finish of our midfield.
If somehow we could get Hoskin-Elliot from this draft it would be amazing but our hands are tied with the F/S pick.
If somehow we could get Hoskin-Elliot from this draft it would be amazing but our hands are tied with the F/S pick.
We also need to get in a KPF.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Malceski for schneider
Isn't Hurley out of contract or is that just a wet dream......? As for trades, it'd be good to see two of the Jetta's playing together (at Essendon), though I think it'd be more the case of Jetta plus pick #? plus pick #? plus player? to get that done.
TheGoatBaron
Bigfooty’s Head Shake Officer
- Jan 4, 2010
- 28,239
- 21,095
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Other Teams
- Port Melb, Eintracht Frankfurt.
Out of contract at the end of next year i think de gen x.
Anyone wanting Hurley would have to give up two top 10 picks. And even then they would probably say no.
BloodBrother1
Debutant
- Sep 29, 2010
- 115
- 141
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Tony Armstrong
What do you guys think about the Swans going after Tony Armstrong from Adelaide... From what i have seen.... plays a similar role to Kennelly.... And is a decent kick from reports
which is what we need 
Rumours were we were after him last year... but it didn't eventuate....
What is his current situation??? What would we have to give up to get him???
What do you guys think about the Swans going after Tony Armstrong from Adelaide... From what i have seen.... plays a similar role to Kennelly.... And is a decent kick from reports
which is what we need Rumours were we were after him last year... but it didn't eventuate....
What is his current situation??? What would we have to give up to get him???
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
