No Oppo Supporters General AFL Discussion #12 - Carlton Posters ONLY!

[lily of laguna]

One rubbed out, one cleared, both correct imo

I agree the Caldwell bump was a contest and unfortunately it resulted in concussion. Shouldn't be a suspension.
But....... I thought the same thing with Plow last year.
Also if it is head high contact that results in concussion I thought it was going to get weeks.
What would I know

Sent from my SM-A115F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[thylacine60]

give it to that caldwell youngster, that actually WAS brave...........fabulous mark and effort............

 

[thylacine60]

bloke on the radio cites racism for pickett getting rubbed out...........

 

[thylacine60]

just summing up footy classified's take on * tonight:

 

[Jatz]

Was there much discussion on us on 360/On the couch/FC?

 

[gadj1976]

If I'm North, I'd be looking at cashing in on JHF this trade period. I think they could score multiple 1st rounders for him. They'll most likely get the number 1 pick, and I would understand if the AFL give them an end of first round priority as well. Imagine going into the draft with 4 first rounders! And be smart and trade a few of the older blokes for a couple 2nd/3rd rounders and try to up trade those.

Yeah it might suck losing JHF, but get the feeling he wasn't going to be a kanga for life anyway and he alone isn't going to bring you back from the depths of despair.

I like your thinking. I think his stocks have gone up rather than down/plateaud so maybe 2 first rounders, plus pick 1 or 2 would make for an interesting 'new' beginning. Possibility of moving on Goldy as well for a second or third rounder and all of a sudden, the makings of a new team.

 

[Bletch]

If I'm North, I'd be looking at cashing in on JHF this trade period. I think they could score multiple 1st rounders for him. They'll most likely get the number 1 pick, and I would understand if the AFL give them an end of first round priority as well. Imagine going into the draft with 4 first rounders! And be smart and trade a few of the older blokes for a couple 2nd/3rd rounders and try to up trade those.

Yeah it might suck losing JHF, but get the feeling he wasn't going to be a kanga for life anyway and he alone isn't going to bring you back from the depths of despair.

I like your thinking. I think his stocks have gone up rather than down/plateaud so maybe 2 first rounders, plus pick 1 or 2 would make for an interesting 'new' beginning. Possibility of moving on Goldy as well for a second or third rounder and all of a sudden, the makings of a new team.

Seems unlikely... or at least would be damning on their stance from last year:

"...North Melbourne rebuffed interest from Adelaide and Richmond in its first-ever top choice. The Crows had offered pick No.4 and two first-rounders next year in exchange for pick one and a future second-round pick, with the Kangaroos not considering a move (a revised version, with likely a future third coming back instead, was also declined). Richmond also threw its hat in the ring, packaging picks No.7, 15, 26 and Callum Coleman-Jones for No.1, but the Roos didn't budge."

Think... They could have had Rachele (a Vic) instead of JHF, plus two extra first round picks this year!

If JHF ups and leaves now, it will be humiliating for Norf. And while he'll command a fair compensation, I'd doubt it will be as good as the deal from last year.

 

[Blue__Balls]

Seems unlikely... or at least would be damning on their stance from last year:

"...North Melbourne rebuffed interest from Adelaide and Richmond in its first-ever top choice. The Crows had offered pick No.4 and two first-rounders next year in exchange for pick one and a future second-round pick, with the Kangaroos not considering a move (a revised version, with likely a future third coming back instead, was also declined). Richmond also threw its hat in the ring, packaging picks No.7, 15, 26 and Callum Coleman-Jones for No.1, but the Roos didn't budge."

Think... They could have had Rachele (a Vic) instead of JHF, plus two extra first round picks this year!

If JHF ups and leaves now, it will be humiliating for Norf. And while he'll command a fair compensation, I'd doubt it will be as good as the deal from last year.

Perhaps. But you may also see Port Adelaide come to the party with a pretty tempting offer too. They've got plenty of flashy young kids, so a bull like JHF would probably suit them to a tee. Assuming Amon gets the big money offer from St Kilda or Hawthorn that's being spoken about, it could be enough for Band 1 compo. Two mid first rounders, or a mid first and end of first - packaged up with a future pick or mature player.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

bloke on the radio cites racism for pickett getting rubbed out...........

Heard that, bloody joke

 

[ferrisb]

The Pies board has taken on an old Carlton BF tradition.

It's May and this is their top two threads...

 

[ferrisb]

* at least are focused enough to be thinking about round 10. After that though....

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Sounds Like Dusty is flying the coop to me

 

[Elmer_Judd]

* at least are focused enough to be thinking about round 10. After that though....

View attachment 1402208

TD's thoughts is my favourite thread there.

I have subscribed

 

[Bletch]

Sounds Like Dusty is flying the coop to me

4th rounder should do it for us, yes?

 

[Blue Reaper]

* Hird. Should never be allowed to coach again.

 

[forever blue 1]

I really like David King’s views and thoughts on footy. I know it would never happen but I think he would would be a really good coach.

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Firey start to Footy Crucified tonight...

All about whether the grand final will stay during the day or twilight

 

[ferrisb]

From Footy Crucified

 

[gadj1976]

* at least are focused enough to be thinking about round 10. After that though....

View attachment 1402208

Looks familiar.

In previous years on here, by Rd 10 we were looking to the draft and who was in the coaching market to take us to the promised land next season.

 

[gadj1976]

Seems unlikely... or at least would be damning on their stance from last year:

"...North Melbourne rebuffed interest from Adelaide and Richmond in its first-ever top choice. The Crows had offered pick No.4 and two first-rounders next year in exchange for pick one and a future second-round pick, with the Kangaroos not considering a move (a revised version, with likely a future third coming back instead, was also declined). Richmond also threw its hat in the ring, packaging picks No.7, 15, 26 and Callum Coleman-Jones for No.1, but the Roos didn't budge."

Think... They could have had Rachele (a Vic) instead of JHF, plus two extra first round picks this year!

If JHF ups and leaves now, it will be humiliating for Norf. And while he'll command a fair compensation, I'd doubt it will be as good as the deal from last year.

I agree. It wont happen but still, the "list manager" in us all would love to see it happen.

 

[JoeyPBLUES]

From Footy Crucified

View attachment 1403383

Those stats are magnificent. Shows how great a coach Truck is. They should back him in & extend his contract now

 

[RPCB]

bloke on the radio cites racism for pickett getting rubbed out...........

What was the response from the hosts?

 

[TD2010]

* are well and truly Trucked...

Somehow our rebuild seems complete with their collapse

Sent from my Pixel 6 using Tapatalk

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Those stats are magnificent. Shows how great a coach Truck is. They should back him in & extend his contract now

I wouldn't be surprised if they do. They extended Xavier Campbell last week

 

[JoeyPBLUES]

I wouldn't be surprised if they do. They extended Xavier Campbell last week

Yes they did and I hope they re-sign him again after this tenure's up