Good Call - Bad Call 2010 Thread

[TradeDraft]

Remember we did this last season and it was fun so someone makes a Call and someone gives it bad or good call and add there own call.

My Call:

Blight will debut next month?

 

[Frankie23]

Bad call TD, jumping the gun call, (In Caro's voice) he will be a good player but it will be hard for him to break into this team the way we are playing!

 

[TradeDraft]

Bad call TD, jumping the gun call, (In Caro's voice) he will be a good player but it will be hard for him to break into this team the way we are playing!

Well I have heard Different on Nicks.

He be better then Good

 

[mike_]

Good Call/Bad Call.

Brent Macaffer will make it as a consistent defensive run with/shutdown type similar to a Daniel Cross/Brett Kirk rather than a half forward flanker.

 

[TradeDraft]

Good Call/Bad Call.

Brent Macaffer will make it as a consistent defensive run with/shutdown type similar to a Daniel Cross/Brett Kirk rather than a half forward flanker.

Bad Call... To Early Call to say Brent will be that Good as Cross or Kirk. Could become a Tagger but not seen him play That.


Good Call/Bad Call

Dawes will not get dropped again this year

 

[YouIdiot]

Hope so call, premature though call, even Josh Fraser looked good forward on the weekend call.


-----

Collingwood will finish top 4 without a single player finishing in the top 15 of the brownlow?

 

[Mars II]

Hope so call, premature though call, even Josh Fraser looked good forward on the weekend call.


-----

Collingwood will finish top 4 without a single player finishing in the top 15 of the brownlow?

Good call.

gc/bc - dicky will jump back into the side after one match in the vfl.

 

[Wooljay]

Good call.

gc/bc - dicky will jump back into the side after one match in the vfl.

Bad call, you'd think he'd need more than one game to get match fitness back having not played since September. Personally I want to see him back asap however

gc/bc - Half of our backline gets AA honours this season.

 

[Mars II]

Bad call, you'd think he'd need more than one game to get match fitness back having not played since September. Personally I want to see him back asap however

gc/bc - Half of our backline gets AA honours this season.

GOOD CALL
HarryO Maxy Heater Presti(unllikley as the selectors look at disposals).

GC/BC - Collingwoods awesome.

 

[didaka]

GOOD CALL
HarryO Maxy Heater Presti(unllikley as the selectors look at disposals).

GC/BC - Collingwoods awesome.

Bad call - underrating us call.

GC/BC - This thread will be forgotten within 24 hours.

 

[StillWaiting5689]

GOOD CALL
HarryO Maxy Heater Presti(unllikley as the selectors look at disposals).

GC/BC - Collingwoods awesome.

Good call, obvious call

GC/BC - Travis Cloke will kick more goals then behinds this year

 

[Jabso]

Good call stillwaitng as he'll either miss entirely or they'll go straight through.

GC/BC - Caro, as Hutchy often suggests is "easily seduced".

 

[half_back_flank]

Good call stillwaitng as he'll either miss entirely or they'll go straight through.

GC/BC - Caro, as Hutchy often suggests is "easily seduced".

Bad call, it put images in my mind that i hope to never see ever again. EVER!


Now to get back to happier subjects....
GC/BC - Tyson Goldsack will be in the firsts by round 9 and will play the rest of the year.

 

[Wooljay]

Bad call, it put images in my mind that i hope to never see ever again. EVER!


Now to get back to happier subjects....
GC/BC - Tyson Goldsack will be in the firsts by round 9 and will play the rest of the year.

Bad call - who does he replace? No doubt will get games, but won't play rounds 9 to 22.

GC/BC - Anthony, Dawes and Travis Cloke will never line up on the park together.

 

[Axl the great]

GC/BC - Anthony, Dawes and Travis Cloke will never line up on the park together.[/quote]

Good Call, we have enough medium amd small options 3 talls is too many.

GC/BC By mid year Wellingham will start to get the oppositions no1 tagger?

 

[Swanny36]

GC/BC By mid year Wellingham will start to get the oppositions no1 tagger?

Good Call, our most dangerous and lively mid so far this season call.


GC/BC - Luke Ball has been under-rated by the media and fans, and he has been outstanding for the club so far.

 

[the mighty T]

Good Call, our most dangerous and lively mid so far this season call.


GC/BC - Luke Ball has been under-rated by the media and fans, and he has been outstanding for the club so far.

Half half call, theres been a lot of pressure on luke to produce and a lot of expectation which in most media eyes hasnt been lived upto. I think he will be outstanding for the club

GC/BC - Presti is being managed through this year so that he will play on throughout 2012 for MM's last crack at the flag.

 

[Looney]

Bad call - who does he replace? No doubt will get games, but won't play rounds 9 to 22.

GC/BC - Anthony, Dawes and Travis Cloke will never line up on the park together.

Bad call. All three have lined up together before, and will probably line up together again in the future.

GC/BC - Collingwood is better off keeping Malthouse as coach than trading him in for Bucks.

 

[Swanny36]

Half half call, theres been a lot of pressure on luke to produce and a lot of expectation which in most media eyes hasnt been lived upto. I think he will be outstanding for the club

GC/BC - Presti is being managed through this year so that he will play on throughout 2012 for MM's last crack at the flag.

hmmmm, good call, speculative call..

GC/BC - Simon Buckley will break into the senior side before season 2010 is over.

 

[alfiiee]

hmmmm, good call, speculative call..

GC/BC - Simon Buckley will break into the senior side before season 2010 is over.

Good call, coaching staff have said that we drafted him to play football in 2010.. If the injuries mount he'll be there..


-------------------------------------------

Rusling will be delisted at the end of the year.

 

[jayceontaylor]

GC/BC - Simon Buckley will break into the senior side before season 2010 is over.[/quote]

Baddd call - I believe he is not up to AFL level and there are many players ahead of him.

GC/BC - Collingwood will be on top of the ladder at round 11 this season.

 

[mattys123]

GC/BC - Collingwood will be on top of the ladder at round 11 this season.

Sorry, bad call, our draw is at it's hardest over the next 6-8 weeks IMO.
After Carlton, we have North, which if we win both, will probably put us on top, but then we will lose a few. Freo, Geelong, Brisbane and the Dogs all by round 11, the top side will only have 2 losses at most, as we will most likely have 3.

I don't think we will finish top, but we may be able to finish 2nd or 3rd if we don't drop games we "should win".

GC/BC: Heath Shaw is now our most important player.

 

[SpaceCow]

GC/BC - Collingwood will be on top of the ladder at round 11 this season.

Hmmmm, so-so call, some tough games coming up for the Pies, will be close though.

Sorry but had to sneak this in,

GC/BC- Paul Medhurst will go back to his 08 form and should remain in my Supercoach team. Also Jolly will come good and should be considered as a good ruck choice now that he has dropped price.

 

[Porkaspies09]

good call-bad call
Presti's missus is stunning

 

[alfiiee]

good call-bad call
Presti's missus is stunning

Delicious Call!

--------------------

Barry Hall will get suspended at least once this year..