Good Call - Bad Call 2010 Thread

[Optimax]

good call-bad call
Presti's missus is stunning

Delicious Call!

--------------------

Barry Hall will get suspended at least once this year..

LULZ!!

good call, in a match the dogs struggle with a chatty full back on him he'll snap (pardon the pun)

Good call Bad Call as a side we have learnt to bury teams early (dogs, hawks, essendon all beating by quarter time)

 

[jayceontaylor]

Good call Bad Call as a side we have learnt to bury teams early (dogs, hawks, essendon all beating by quarter time)[/quote]

Good call, and if we had kicked straight against the saints we would have been up at half time and had the game won by 3 qtr time imo.

----------------------------------------------------------
rusling will get a game before seasons end

 

[didaka]

LULZ!!

good call, in a match the dogs struggle with a chatty full back on him he'll snap (pardon the pun)

Good call Bad Call as a side we have learnt to bury teams early (dogs, hawks, essendon all beating by quarter time)

Good call. As a side a feel we are more ruthless in 2010 and walk a little taller.

GC/BC - Although Dale Thomas has improved his overall game and by seasons end will be among our best performed players, the fools on bigfooty we still call him a flashy, downhill skiing show pony.

 

[Wooljay]

LULZ!!

good call, in a match the dogs struggle with a chatty full back on him he'll snap (pardon the pun)

Good call Bad Call as a side we have learnt to bury teams early (dogs, hawks, essendon all beating by quarter time)

Very good call, we seem to be avalanching in the first quarter/half of the games we win. It's fantastic.

Uhh...GC/BC - Dawes will kick a bag against Carlton and will cement himself into the side, causing Anthony to fight tooth and nail for his spot.

 

[the mighty T]

Very good call, we seem to be avalanching in the first quarter/half of the games we win. It's fantastic.

Uhh...GC/BC - Dawes will kick a bag against Carlton and will cement himself into the side, causing Anthony to fight tooth and nail for his spot.

good call...with cloke being tagged as the number 1 forward playing deep and with fraser and jolly rotating through, whose gunna stop Dawes ?

GC/BC - Nathan Buckley as coach will deliver us our first premiership since 1990

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Bad call, pessimistic call, write off the season right now call, when there's something strange in your neighbourhood who're you gonna call...

I think we're a bloody good chance to win it this year and then there's still 2011 to have a red hot go at. We should be aiming to win one under Malthouse... and several under Buckley.

GC/BC - Wellingham will make Mike Sheahan's end-of-year top 50.

 

[mattys123]

GC/BC - Nathan Buckley as coach will deliver us our first premiership since 1990

I have to say bad call.

I believe we will win the flag either this year or next, as the players will want to send MM out on a top note, and we also are at a stage where our other contenders seem to be struggling a bit with age and injuries.

GC/BC: Jarryd Blair should be rated ahead of Shane O'Bree as Luke Balls' clearance backup.

 

[Porkaspies09]

Bad call, pessimistic call, write off the season right now call, when there's something strange in your neighbourhood who're you gonna call...

I think we're a bloody good chance to win it this year and then there's still 2011 to have a red hot go at. We should be aiming to win one under Malthouse... and several under Buckley.

GC/BC - Wellingham will make Mike Sheahan's end-of-year top 50.

good call

GC/BC- Will Cloke finally start playing well now

 

[the mighty T]

wasnt a what i actually think call, more of a what do you guys think call

i certainly think MM will win us a premiership in the next 2 years

just clearing that up, lol

 

[the mighty T]

good call

GC/BC- Will Cloke finally start playing well now

Bad call...imo cloke has always played well, just not kicked the goals that CHF's are supposed to kick. However i think he'll take a step up this year.

GC/BC - Shae Mac will play AFL for Collingwood

 

[the_fresh]

Bad call, pessimistic call, write off the season right now call, when there's something strange in your neighbourhood who're you gonna call...

I think we're a bloody good chance to win it this year and then there's still 2011 to have a red hot go at. We should be aiming to win one under Malthouse... and several under Buckley.

GC/BC - Wellingham will make Mike Sheahan's end-of-year top 50.

Bad call - he should but every Collingwood player has a 10% handicap on them by Mike.

GC/BC - This "who do you think you are" crap on channel 9 is a waste of time?

 

[Porkaspies09]

Bad call...imo cloke has always played well, just not kicked the goals that CHF's are supposed to kick. However i think he'll take a step up this year.




GC/BC - Shae Mac will play AFL for Collingwood

ummm this year noo, in a few years maybe, an idk call

 

[the_king_smells]

Bad call...imo cloke has always played well, just not kicked the goals that CHF's are supposed to kick. However i think he'll take a step up this year.

GC/BC - Shae Mac will play AFL for Collingwood

Bad call - he's already 24 years old, will probably never have enough skill.

GC/BC - Crowd for Carlton game will be > 90 000

 

[StillWaiting5689]

Bad call - he's already 24 years old, will probably never have enough skill.

GC/BC - Crowd for Carlton game will be > 90 000

Bad call, MCC members will ruin any chance of that...again.

GC/BC Rusling will be delisted at the end of the season (Alfiiee call from before but it got lost and I'm interested in your thoughts)

 

[Kipz]

Bad Call, will either retire (if he gets seriously injured again) or get into some form in the AFL


GC/BC Wellingham will finish in our top 5 in the BNF this year

 

[the_king_smells]

Bad Call, will either retire (if he gets seriously injured again) or get into some form in the AFL


GC/BC Wellingham will finish in our top 5 in the BNF this year

Good Call - would be top 5 so far, he is so cool under pressure. Liking Sidebottom and Daisy this year too. And Beams.. alot to like hah.

GC/BC - Fraser will find his place in the team as rotating forward/ruck and Wood will not see first team action again.

 

[Mars II]

GC/BC Wellingham will finish in our top 5 in the BNF this year

flipping brilliant call

 

[collingtimber]

Caro will appologise for muck raking Collingwood at every oppertunity.

 

[Smoky]

Rusling delisted at end of year - bad call... doesn't he have another year on his contract? It's fairly obvious they are trying to rebuild him from the bottom up and once he lands himself at FF in a month or so - he will force his way into the team through sheer weight of numbers (of goals)

Jono will be Top 5 in the Copeland this year.

 

[alfiiee]

Good Call - would be top 5 so far, he is so cool under pressure. Liking Sidebottom and Daisy this year too. And Beams.. alot to like hah.

GC/BC - Fraser will find his place in the team as rotating forward/ruck and Wood will not see first team action again.

I hope you're wrong call..
I don't mind Fraser playing forward/ruck, but i am more upset at the thought of not seeing some Wood action..

-------------------------------------
If Nathan Buckley played at FF for the last two years he would have kicked at least 50 goals in each season..?

 

[alfiiee]

Rusling delisted at end of year - bad call... doesn't he have another year on his contract? It's fairly obvious they are trying to rebuild him from the bottom up and once he lands himself at FF in a month or so - he will force his way into the team through sheer weight of numbers (of goals)

Jono will be Top 5 in the Copeland this year.

Sorry, missed it..
Courageous Call..
TOP 5 could be any of Didak, Pendles, Harry, Shaw, Wellingham, Johno, Beams, Swan, Ball?

Not sure there is enough room in the top 5. If he can hold his form however definitely. Can he though?


------------------------------------------

GC/BC - If Nathan Buckley played at FF for the last 2 years, he would have kicked at least 50 goals in each season.

 

[pinky951]

Bad call, he only played 5 games in '07, that would have been a fair effort!!! Although if Malthouse had decided to leave him in the square all year so he could hop round and kick goals Daniel Larusso 'Crane' Style he would have managed.

-------

Ben Johnson - North Smith - winning Collingwood team - if we manage to make it.

 

[robertg22]

Bad call, he only played 5 games in '07, that would have been a fair effort!!! Although if Malthouse had decided to leave him in the square all year so he could hop round and kick goals Daniel Larusso 'Crane' Style he would have managed.

-------

Ben Johnson - North Smith - winning Collingwood team - if we manage to make it.

Bad call, speculative call, he's not in our top few players but still would be nice to see any Pies player win the medal.

Good Call/Bad Call - We will not lose any key players to the GC this off season.

 

[daics_35]

Bad call, speculative call, he's not in our top few players but still would be nice to see any Pies player win the medal.

Good Call/Bad Call - We will not lose any key players to the GC this off season.

Bad Call- every club will lose at list one uncontracted player to GC.


Good Call / Bad Call- We will our next 5 games and become premiership favourites.

 

[TradeDraft]

GC/BC - Luke Ball has been under-rated by the media and fans, and he has been outstanding for the club so far.

Spot On Call - The Media just looks at Balls Stats and don't look at his influence on the Club and he puts in 110% during the Game