Guna throw one out there.

[B-Rock]

A trade that has been discussed on the North board.

Leigh Brown for James Kelly? Would you guys consider it?

What about if we threw in say.. Harding?

Brown is a versatile KPP, could settle into your forward line.

 

[DBAH0]

No.

I'd want Essendon's 2nd round pick (17 or 18) as a MINIMUM for Kelly.

If Cressa is our coach next season, I doubt Kelly will be going anywhere anyways.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

I actually thought Brown was good last year

I think you are stuck with him now. Probably the only bad player Fremantle have ever traded.

 

[B-Rock]

Hes only 24 and played almost 150 games already..

 

[cobba]

i think its a fair trade, lets do it!!

 

[B-Rock]

I actually thought Brown was good last year

Im sure many people felt the same way about Kelly.

 

[Rosella]

You can have Kelly but we don't want Brown or Harding

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Hes only 24 and played almost 150 games already

Swap you for King, then.

Only 26, played almost 200 games, AA ruckman, leader of men.

 

[cattalist]

if you take steve j off our hands we'll throw in an old mattress, some mothballs and a six pack.
deal?

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Im sure many people felt the same way about Kelly.

Brown has been classed as a write off by two clubs now though.

Like DBAHO said Kelly has only been bad this season and it's still possible he could turn it around under a coach with a clue.

 

[RoyalBlue]

This is crazy talk, we are holding onto Brown.


Colingwood is getting him for Tarrant.

 

[catempire]

^
|
|
|
|
|
|

How about... Kelly for Corey Jones?

 

[Rosella]

This is crazy talk, we are holding onto Brown.


Colingwood is getting him for Tarrant.

That's a lose/lose situation for both of you.

 

[JUBJUB]

Brown is a versatile KPP, could settle into your forward line.

No thanks.We already have McCarthy and Lonergan that are settled in our forward line.

 

[RoyalBlue]

How about... Kelly for Corey Jones?

The guy who is going close to top three in our B+F?

nahhhh.....

 

[Scarlett30]

if you take steve j off our hands we'll throw in an old mattress, some mothballs and a six pack.
deal?

dont watch much football?

 

[Stoney]

You can have Kelly but we don't want Brown or Harding

lol

Personally, on a serious note i wouldnt do Kelly for Brown, Brown has failed to prove himself at 2 clubs - I still hold hope for Kels.

 

[cattalist]

dont watch much football?

so he had an good game today, kicked goals... wheres the consistency? what about all the half arsed games playing for the glory and doing nothing for the team?

 

[catempire]

The guy who is going close to top three in our B+F?

nahhhh.....

A few good games equals top 3 in B&F?

A month or two back there was a thread on your board about whether or not to trade him. That's the only reason I threw it up there.

 

[Scarlett30]

so he had an good game today, kicked goals... wheres the consistency? what about all the half arsed games playing for the glory and doing nothing for the team?

Does this quote remind you of anything......perhaps the clubs whole season? There have been less than 5 players who have consistently performed this year. You can't sack 40 guys and keep 5.

 

[cattalist]

no I agree, but hey you have to admit that he is inconsistent. Thats why I generally cringe when he gets the ball - he's either going to do something amazing, or screw it up....

 

[RoyalBlue]

A few good games equals top 3 in B&F?

A month or two back there was a thread on your board about whether or not to trade him. That's the only reason I threw it up there.

2 or 3? He'll go top five in out the B&F, and depending on how out committee votes might go higher.

There's a few north fans who suggest he might have trade value because he's one of the few of our players who have any trade value.

Would you prefer Troy Makepeace instead?

 

[catempire]

2 or 3? He'll go top five in out the B&F, and depending on how out committee votes might go higher.

There's a few north fans who suggest he might have trade value because he's one of the few of our players who have any trade value.

Would you prefer Troy Makepeace instead?

You'd know better than I. I was simply going by the thread on your board.

We'd need a quality player or a first round pick for JK. Otherwise, he's worth more to us by keeping him. He could still come good.

Troy Makepeace