Autopsy Joy in Longmire 300th Swans by 2 over the Dogs.

[monopoly19]

Apparently McNeil suffered delayed concussion.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

I'm asking you what he actually did. He has to actually have done a specific action for it to be worthy of a suspension...

It’s a behind the play hit that has caused high contact. Ask Rampe why he was was doing behind the ball hits, was it high not sure but I’m sure they have vision where it is and if it’s whiplash it’s still high.

 

[caesar88]

It’s a behind the play hit that has caused high contact. Ask Rampe why he was was doing behind the ball hits, was it high not sure but I’m sure they have vision where it is and if it’s whiplash it’s still high.

But how did he hit him? Was it a raised elbow? Open fist? Closed fist? A headbutt?

They need to actually know what they're charging him with, otherwise they're just charging a player for simply making contact with another player.

 

[ErrolisGoldun]

Apparently McNeil suffered delayed concussion.

Of course he did

 

[sataris]

Rampe should just say he's sorry.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

But how did he hit him? Was it a raised elbow? Open fist? Closed fist? A headbutt?

They need to actually know what they're charging him with, otherwise they're just charging a player for simply making contact with another player.

He has caused him delayed concussion now these things happened every game years ago but the game has changed. You go behind the play you need to ensure no head contact/whiplash. This is all on Rampe.

 

[ErrolisGoldun]

He has caused him delayed concussion now these things happened every game years ago but the game has changed. You go behind the play you need to ensure no head contact/whiplash. This is all on Rampe.

Ok, I don’t know that Rampe knew too much about it to be fair, weird position you have taken on this.

I assume you also feel that Wicks should be suspended for O’Donnell running in to his arm

 

[Deccas]

He has caused him delayed concussion now these things happened every game years ago but the game has changed. You go behind the play you need to ensure no head contact/whiplash. This is all on Rampe.

There's no way known that this contact is what caused this concussion. Like it plausibly did sure, but you can't see what's happened and say he definitely hit him in the head, or caused whiplash, or anything.

 

[TheMase]

Based on that footage it’s a free for too far off the ball.

Can’t see anything else?

 

[DeathlyAccurate]

Just as we get a sniff we lose a player. Same thing with Parker just before the Saints game.

I hate this league sometimes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[The King!]

Rampe has been giving an additional 3 weeks for striking J Longmire after the game to the head.

 

[stevie26]

You mean Parker then daylight

Parker is reliable and has more goal scoring opportunities. Not disagreeing with that but I reckon Florent would be better with the same opportunities. In terms of accuracy Florent disected the goals each shot he has had.

 

[zyzzbruh]

He has caused him delayed concussion now these things happened every game years ago but the game has changed. You go behind the play you need to ensure no head contact/whiplash. This is all on Rampe.

How on earth does someone get diagnosed with delayed concussion? What are the parameters? The main symptom of a concussion is immediate disorientation for a minute or so followed by headache. There's no way he would've randomly felt disorientated a day later, so chances are he's had a headache which has been flippantly put down to concussion. Headaches can literally be caused by a million things and sometimes even nothing. Number one cause of a headache is dehydration and muscle strain which is hardly rare for an AFL player. The game has lost the plot. 1 you can't just throw delayed concussion diagnosis willy nilly and 2 you can't suspend a player without adequately describing the crime they committed.

Same thing for heeneys so called delayed concussion after a broken nose. A broken nose gives you a headache for a week straight it's not a concussion ffs. Don't care if you are a concussion professor you can't diagnose a concussion well after the fact when initially there were no symptoms. It's a fallacy. Even if they're so sure it is delayed concussion, with that logic how can they be sure which incident it arose from? it could be from incident a year ago for all we know, or a knock at training last week. how can you unequivocally put it down to a specific incident..

 

[DeathlyAccurate]

Based on that footage it’s a free for too far off the ball.

Can’t see anything else?

Please tell me the two weeks aren’t based on some footage recorded on a Nokia 5210?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[sataris]

Please tell me the two weeks aren’t based on some footage recorded on a Nokia 5210?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Are you talking s**t about the 5210?

 

[the hypnotoad]

I've hit the toilet harder with a dump than Rampe hit the dogs player

oh geez ... there goes all the goodwill

 

[MR0808]

Are you talking s**t about the 5210?

It was unbreakable!

 

[caesar88]

It was unbreakable!

Yep, I have one. I can throw it against a brick wall and still be able to type a comment afterwar

 

[MR0808]

Yep, I have one. I can throw it against a brick wall and still be able to type a comment afterwar

I remember throwing my old 5110 through a plaster wall and it worked perfectly still. And the battery lasted a week!

 

[caesar88]

I remember throwing my old 5110 through a plaster wall and it worked perfectly still. And the battery lasted a week!

Perfect phone for watching Swans games on then

 

[Dubai Quacker]

I remember throwing my old 5110 through a plaster wall and it worked perfectly still. And the battery lasted a week!

You evidently had the Rocket Eade version.

 

[MR0808]

You evidently had the Rocket Eade version.

This was during the Rocket Eade period of coaching us

 

[Wolftone]

We've had big injury concerns all year, you still need to have some sort of experience on the field. You're backing in those guys to do a role, especially a premier small forward. It's easy to say in hindsight it hasn't worked but we don't operate on hindsight. Is it worthwhile playing youngsters (you've said the likes of rankin isn't ready previously) then getting smashed by 60+pts?

I don't think we'll make finals but it's still worthwhile being competitive & having balance in experience on the field. If we kicked straight against a few teams we would've had a couple of more wins resulting in us entrenched in the 8. A lot of these banged up players helped us get ahead in a majority of games at 3/4 time.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing...

We lost those games anyway. What was the point of playing him. No tall backs. We were never going to win so why not put him in ice to get better. Same Heens.

On CPH2471 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Ticky009]

Need a volunteer for Freo game all

Toast - PREVIEW THREAD NOMINATIONS 2023

Right then, lets kick this off with some appreciation of the great previews we had last year, which spanned the length and depth of variety and reached its height in Banyo Bloods brilliant comic preview for our Norf game:hearteyes: Some little quirks in this draw overall: Us playing the Magpies...

www.bigfooty.com

 

[Mister B]

How brave was Bontempelli nearly "winning it for his team" by himself? With other top 10 players of the comp in English and Liberatore also dominating, how did Bontempelli cope!!!

So brave. Brave, brave Bont. So very, very brave.