Recommitted Lachie Neale [re-signed]

[DCFCFAN84]

So pick 10 and 11 for Neale but hogan is worth pick 3 and 9 ?

If a 178cm contested ball winning beast with average disposal is worth picks 10 and 11 then a young generational key forward is worth three first round picks.

You can't have it both ways freo supporters. Neale can't be worth close to hogan.

If we are offering pick 3 and Neale for Hogan and Neale is worth two first then isn't that the equivalent of 3 firsts for Hogan?

 

[philthy05]

If we are offering pick 3 and Neale for Hogan and Neale is worth two first then isn't that the equivalent of 3 firsts for Hogan?

Would you give up your first, 2017 first , and a first pick you got for Neale for hogan ?


Yeah I thought not.

 

[DCFCFAN84]

If we recieved two firsts for Neale then yes. We wouldnt be able to if we only got 1 first as we wouldnt be able to make the 2 first rounders in a 4 year period requirement.

 

[eth-dog]

Heard today from someone in the know that he will sign for 3 years at Freo.

 

[new breed]

Heard today from someone in the know that he will sign for 3 years at Freo.

Barra on 7Sport reporting the same.... staying on a long term contract plus negotiations starting with Chris Mayne.

 

[philthy05]

Good news for freo.


Hard to see them having the currency to nab hogan even if he requested a trade now. Macarthy would be a welcome addition and gettable.

 

[DCFCFAN84]

Barra on 7Sport reporting the same.... staying on a long term contract plus negotiations starting with Chris Mayne.

Ughhh would rather a second rounder for him to leave and use that to get McCarthy

 

[philthy05]

Ughhh would rather a second rounder for him to leave and use that to get McCarthy

Zero chance you would get that in compensation for Mayne.

 

[Suma Magic]

Zero chance you would get that in compensation for Mayne.

End of second round (band 4) would be right on the money IMO.

Pick 37 wouldn't be enough for McCarthy though. Although his value is very tough to place.

If he was referring to band 3 then I agree that's not likely.

 

[rgauci]

End of second round (band 4) would be right on the money IMO.

Pick 37 wouldn't be enough for McCarthy though. Although his value is very tough to place.

If he was referring to band 3 then I agree that's not likely.

What did Scott Selwood get? Band 3 or 4?

 

[Suma Magic]

What did Scott Selwood get? Band 3 or 4?

Selwood was band 3. Restricted. He got about $1.6m over 4 years I think. About 2.5 years younger than Mayne will be.

Suckling band 4, unrestricted. Think that was about $1.1ish but I'm not sure. Same with Leuey (restricted). Both about a year younger at the time than Mayne will be.

So given age and wage inflation may have to get $1.3-1.6m over 3 years or maybe $1.7-2.1m over 4 years to get band 3.

It's a closed book process so hard to know for sure. But hard to see Mayne commanding a big enough deal to get band 3. He's currently unrestricted.

 

[Theo X]

If we recieved two firsts for Neale then yes. We wouldnt be able to if we only got 1 first as we wouldnt be able to make the 2 first rounders in a 4 year period requirement.

Hahah 2 firsts? The guy can't even handle a tag.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Hahah 2 firsts? The guy can't even handle a tag.

On the back of 1 game. Would still be just about your best mid.

 

[Sully90]

Hahah 2 firsts? The guy can't even handle a tag.

One bad game champ

 

[E Shed]

On the back of 1 game. Would still be just about your best mid.

thats a bit of exaggeration when they have Viney, Tyson, Brayshaw, Petracca and Jones. Some serious talent coming through at the Dees.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

thats a bit of exaggeration when they have Viney, Tyson, Brayshaw, Petracca and Jones. Some serious talent coming through at the Dees.

None are as good as Neale is right now bar maybe Viney. Obciously they may be but right nlw they aren't.

 

[vozzon]

Not bad Vozzon, I think Freo are ok but I think Port come out decent winners at Melbournes expense. I think Neale is worth a good amount more then Port are giving up and Hogan is certainly worth more then Melboure are getting.

Yeah i agree, but was trying to get the main parts of the deal in theory, still think more would be needed to be exchanged to satisfy parties (specifically melbourne).

Also relying on players pushing to leave there respective clubs so it makes the clubs actually come to the trade table.

After the bulldogs game, its clear port need another mid of neale's caliber.

 

[WilloTree]

Yeah i agree, but was trying to get the main parts of the deal in theory, still think more would be needed to be exchanged to satisfy parties (specifically melbourne).

Also relying on players pushing to leave there respective clubs so it makes the clubs actually come to the trade table.

After the bulldogs game, its clear port need another mid of neale's caliber.

All good points. Port lost the clearances 34 - 46 and stoppages 22 - 29. Not panic stations numbers, but would indicate an area they need to address.

 

[eastfreo75]

Good news for freo.


Hard to see them having the currency to nab hogan even if he requested a trade now. Macarthy would be a welcome addition and gettable.

I agree.

 

[Adz2332]

All good points. Port lost the clearances 34 - 46 and stoppages 22 - 29. Not panic stations numbers, but would indicate an area they need to address.

For mine has more to do with having a KPB as a ruckman

 

[Moist Biscuit]

For mine has more to do with having a KPB as a ruckman

Agreed but it's not like Lobbe would be doing any better than Trengove.

 

[Adz2332]

Agreed but it's not like Lobbe would be doing any better than Trengove.

hahah also agree! lol.... but ryder would

 

[JUSTWORK]

For mine has more to do with having a KPB as a ruckman

Ryder Gray Wines and Neale make for an exciting prospect for 2017.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Will sign a 3 year deal in the coming months according to Jon Ralph on Fox Footy.

 

[FD2646]

Perth now website reporting that he has signed a 3 year deal with freo.