Nat Fyfe vs Josh Kelly vs Marcus Bontempelli

[Benny78]

If you could have one of these players in your team right now, which one would you choose?

 

[Masqualero]

I'd go the Bont then Kelly.

We need clean ball users.

Ideally Bont as we could have him switching with Cripps between mid and fwd lines, Kelly would be my next preference but I feel Bont has more strings to his bow and has the higher ceiling of the two, also I feel our team would be more dynamic with Bont.

Fyfe is a gun but we already have an elite extractor with average footskills, we need some elite skills.

 

[blitzer]

I said Kelly because there is still question marks over Fyfe returning to his best plus he does tend to get injured for long periods of time.

Nothing wrong with Bontempelli but i'd prefer the other 2.

At their peak Fyfe covers the other 2 pretty comfortably right now but the other 2 are young still.

 

[scaryness]

Bont

 

[Donakebab]

To play for Essendon this season it would be Fyfe in a heartbeat, long term it would be Bont as we need more tall contested mids. However, overall I wouldn't be surprised if Kelly ends up the best of the lot.

 

[Engimal v3]

Kelly would suit North's needs best, but Fyfe is the best player out of the 3.

 

[Juddernaut08]

Fyfe

 

[schmuttt]

Kelly for our needs, Fyfe clearly the best of the 3 right now though.

 

[jackenny]

Fyfe is hands down the best player of the three (on current output), but I would be concerned about injuries - and an older, injury-prone player is the last thing the Suns needs - so would rather Bontempelli, because he brings good vibes and has the potential to become a brownlow medallist in his own right.