One Player

[Lockyer24]

Is 3 years of Voss worth more than 10 years of Riewoldt though?

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Originally posted by Lockyer24
Is 3 years of Voss worth more than 10 years of Riewoldt though?

Harsh to say Voss only has three more years left, the guy is only 27.

It's a fair question though, but for my club, 4-5 years of Voss would be infinitely more valuable then 10 from Saint Nick.

 

[Stone Cold]

Originally posted by phatandphreaky
Harsh to say Voss only has three more years left, the guy is only 27.

It's a fair question though, but for my club, 4-5 years of Voss would be infinitely more valuable then 10 from Saint Nick.

Only problem is, Vossy has already stated that he won't go on any longer than 3 more after this!!!!!

 

[funky_monk]

Voss is the best leader in footy at the moment but if you were starting a team a younger player that will e a around for a while would be better.

Riewoldt is an awesome player but I would go for Tredrea or Pavlich over him. Simply because they are better leaders. They have more presence and are more than just good players. There is no doubt that Pav would be captain of Freo atm if Bell wasn't also such a good leader. Tredrea has the kind of physical presence I like in a leader too.

 

[Stone Cold]

Originally posted by funky_monk
Voss is the best leader in footy at the moment but if you were starting a team a younger player that will e a around for a while would be better.

Riewoldt is an awesome player but I would go for Tredrea or Pavlich over him. Simply because they are better leaders. They have more presence and are more than just good players. There is no doubt that Pav would be captain of Freo atm if Bell wasn't also such a good leader. Tredrea has the kind of physical presence I like in a leader too.

So, your saying Nick is not a good leader and has little presence and is a "Good Player" are you?????

Firstly Must State : I don't have a problem with your selections, just your statement of Nick!!!!!


Know for Fact: Nick has more presence than Santa and his leadership skills are first class!!!!!

Makes your 2 boys pretty damn good.....[

 

[pazza]

Voss currently, Riewoldt long term (across the competition).

Essendon have started their efforts with Matthew Lloyd (has at least 8 years left).

 

[legendary]

Josh Fraser - will be best big man in the comp in 2 years. Very versatile, excellent skills and very good at ground level for his size.

 

[ClintEastwood]

 

[autologic]

Gardiner....

The ball starts at the centre bounce so a quality ruckman seems the best place to start to build a team around.


Champion midfielders are less damaging when they don't have a decent ruckman to feed them the ball.

 

[Port1978]

Tredders

 

[MG77B]

Has to be currently Nathan Buckley. The most consistent footballer over the last 10 years and watch him make a run for this years Brownlow.

 

[funky_monk]

Originally posted by Stone Cold

Makes your 2 boys pretty damn good.....[

Yep. Thats right. Not saying that Nick isn't/won't be a good leader just that IMHO Pav and Tredrea are better.

 

[noodle]

Riewoldt or Pavlich both can play on the half forward/back lines and both are going to have a big future.