Pearce vs Hassan

[Markthirtytwo]

Are they of similar build?
I know of Hassan's speed and courage, but nothing of Pearce's.
Who IYO who would make the best future player?

 

[sog35]

Hassan is slower, more ball winning. Slightly older so has a mature, stronger body. Pearce is lightening quick, but is light on. Would take longer to be ready but maybe better in the long run, whereas Hassan doesn't have that scope but I'm confident he could contribute.

 

[CaptainDangerfield]

Hassan is slower, more ball winning. Slightly older so has a mature, stronger body. Pearce is lightening quick, but is light on. Would take longer to be ready but maybe better in the long run, whereas Hassan doesn't have that scope but I'm confident he could contribute.

Were you surprised Hassan got delisted? I really like his game, hard at it.

 

[macca23]

Pearce for me every time. A ton more upside as he could develop into a very handy quick mid-fielder, and there's a real shortage of those.

I hope we take him in the rookie draft because I do think he will make it. Exquisite skills.

 

[redandblack]

Hassan never came off the line of the ball.

 

[sog35]

Were you surprised Hassan got delisted? I really like his game, hard at it.

Not surprised but a little disappointed. Good for Westies that he had the chance to develop further in the AFL system.

Would have liked a chance to see him play at AFL level.

 

[No 1 Draft Pick]

Pearce for me every time. A ton more upside as he could develop into a very handy quick mid-fielder, and there's a real shortage of those.

I hope we take him in the rookie draft because I do think he will make it. Exquisite skills.

I would take Pearce also. But we need to acknowledge the risk he might not be there when pick 5 comes in the rookie draft

He could end up being like Aaron Davey last year - not picked up in ND but making a big impact due his speed and skills

 

[Damien_R1]

I would take Pearce also. But we need to acknowledge the risk he might not be there when pick 5 comes in the rookie draft

He could end up being like Aaron Davey last year - not picked up in ND but making a big impact due his speed and skills

If Stevo doesn't come up, that gives us a real good crack at him in the PSD.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Pearce for me because he does have greater upside. I wish though that Pearce is as courageous as Hassan. I will never forget that mark he took against the eagles in one of the finals a couple of years ago. Crickey that was one of the most courageous marks I have seen considering how small Hassan is.

I think sog35 put it beautifully

I get the feeling that we will miss out of Pearce, especially if Schoefild leaves Port and gives them a pre-season pick

 

[macca23]

Pearce for me because he does have greater upside. I wish though that Pearce is as courageous as Hassan. I will never forget that mark he took against the eagles in one of the finals a couple of years ago. Crickey that was one of the most courageous marks I have seen considering how small Hassan is.

I think sog35 put it beautifully

I get the feeling that we will miss out of Pearce, especially if Schoefild leaves Port and gives them a pre-season pick

If we did have a pick in the PSD who would you take Stiffy?? Grundy or Pearce?? I oscillate back and forth, but I think it just might be Pearce ..... or is it Grundy??

 

[Stiffy_18]

If we did have a pick in the PSD who would you take Stiffy?? Grundy or Pearce?? I oscillate back and forth, but I think it just might be Pearce ..... or is it Grundy??

I have also changed my mind a few times. A KPP or a lightning quick midfielder.

I have decided on Pearce but if we do pick him up I would rookie list a KPP.

So really if for arguments sake Stevo doesn't come up we should pick Pearce and place 2 midfielders and a KPP on the rookie list. If we pick up Grundy in the PSD then I would place 3 midfielders on the rookie list.

Pearce for me but my mind will probably change by the time the draft comes around

 

[macca23]

I have also changed my mind a few times. A KPP or a lightning quick midfielder.

I have decided on Pearce but if we do pick him up I would rookie list a KPP.

So really if for arguments sake Stevo doesn't come up we should pick Pearce and place 2 midfielders and a KPP on the rookie list. If we pick up Grundy in the PSD then I would place 3 midfielders on the rookie list.

Pearce for me but my mind will probably change by the time the draft comes around

I think you've got the mix of players spot on, and today I also think we should take Pearce in the PSD if we end up having a pick.

Who knows which one I'll fancy tomorrow.

 

[Stiffy_18]

I think you've got the mix of players spot on, and today I also think we should take Pearce in the PSD if we end up having a pick.

Who knows which one I'll fancy tomorrow.

I am sure I will be the same

 

[sog35]

I'm just not convinced about Pearce for some reason.

Given that I'm not, I'm sure Port will pick him up. He's a relation of the Burgoynes.

 

[jack did it]

why would we want hassan after port delisted him?? bit stiff to be dropped though, however was never going to make it in the port midfield