Sherman Vs. Deledio

[sherminator]

Brett Deledio- Pick 1 2004 National Draft

• Played 21 games this year.
• Played 43 games in total.

Justin Sherman- Pick 45 2004 National Draft

• 41 Consecutive games since debut.
• 2 30+ Disposal matches in his first full season.

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/compare_players?tid1=102&pid1=2005012&tid2=112&pid2=2005090

 

[lids2004roar]

Sherman will be a good player but Deledio is by far the better of the two.

What's the point of this poll?

Lids is widely recognised as a probable future elite player.

 

[Heisenberg_]

why must Deledio get compared to every young player?

 

[Bentleigh]

why must Deledio get compared to every young player?

'Cause he is the best young player in the league and will be the AFL's #1 player shortly.

 

[mckinale]

sherman by so far it isnt funny

 

[The Zebra]

Chuck the stats out on this one.

No contest.

Anyone who says they would take Sherman is Delediuding themselves.

 

[blues4flag]

Sherman was been super impressive in his this season.

Being a number one draft pick doesn't make Deledio better, and thus far Sherman has proven an absolute bargain. Deledio if I had to choose at the moment, but I would not at all be suprised if Sherman came out better, as it's way too early to tell.

 

[bellzy]

Brett Deledio- Pick 1 2004 National Draft

• Played 21 games this year.
• Played 43 games in total.

Justin Sherman- Pick 45 2004 National Draft

• 41 Consecutive games since debut.
• 2 30+ Disposal matches in his first full season.

http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/compare_players?tid1=102&pid1=2005012&tid2=112&pid2=2005090

Slightly Bias are we?

 

[Grimreepah]

Sherman has better stats, but until recently Deledio has been getting a heavier tag. I think it's pretty even at this stage.

 

[BlueZippy]

Sherman for dream team, Deledio as a footballer.

It's an unfair comparison anyway. 1 player plays without an opponent, racking up cheap stats while the other gets the ******** tagged out of him and earns every single one of his possesions.

 

[parrot]

Hard call at this stage. Deledio is much faster, but Sherman has more footy smarts, and has better decision making under pressure.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Chuck the stats out on this one.

No contest.

Anyone who says they would take Sherman is Delediuding themselves.

Exactly right.

Another Sherman is more likely to come along then another Deledio. Thats not to say Sherman isnt a good player, which he is.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Sherman's a little ********ing hog.

 

[Firrito24]

Deledio by the stretch of Brady Rawlings nose

 

[Yze_13]

That Was A Stupid Poll, Deledio By Far!!!!

 

[MTBTYT]

Hard call at this stage. Deledio is much faster, but Sherman has more footy smarts, and has better decision making under pressure.

Your obsessions showing again parrot.

 

[jonnomc]

sherman by so far it isnt funny

Your Funny you have no idea. Delidio would carve sherman any day.

 

[GoAds]

I'd take sherman for his stupid goal celebrations (even when his side is 10 goals down!) They are priceless!

 

[SunKing]

Poll is quite close at the moment. Take out the multitude of richmond fans and Sherman wins with neutral voters.

A #1 draft pick does not mean he will be great. From what I've seen a smart footballer but a little overrated.

Probably even at the moment but IMO Sherman will develop into the superior footballer.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Poll is quite close at the moment. Take out the multitude of richmond fans and Sherman wins with neutral voters.

A #1 draft pick does not mean he will be great. From what I've seen a smart footballer but a little overrated.

Probably even at the moment but IMO Sherman will develop into the superior footballer.

How do you know, take out the Brisbane fans and Deledio could be winning by a street. Deledio is a better footballer, Sherman is good but doesn't quite have the class of Deledio

 

[lids2004roar]

A #1 draft pick does not mean he will be great.

Rarely!

Try this logic on Bryce Gibbs and see what Parrot says then

Number 1 draft picks in the modern game will turn out to be great players.

Name one dud of the past 5 years!

 

[tigerT]

Im actually surprised deledio is winning a poll on BF, going by all recent polls and comments hes a dud....dont all the carlton, western bulldogs and freo fans have wind of this poll yet?

 

[TigerGlory]

Im actually surprised deledio is winning a poll on BF, going by all recent polls and comments hes a dud....dont all the carlton, western bulldogs and freo fans have wind of this poll yet?

Obviously not. But the Dees and Hawks supporters are being good which is what counts.

No comments about putting McLean or Franklin have popped up yet.

 

[Mofra]

Im actually surprised deledio is winning a poll on BF, going by all recent polls and comments hes a dud....dont all the carlton, western bulldogs and freo fans have wind of this poll yet?

Have I erred in choosing Delideo then (being a Doggies supporter)?

Stats never tell the full story; whilst Sherman has been good I haven't seen him become the focus of the close checking Delideo gets. Delideo on this basis.

 

[micky_11]

I couldnt decide between the two of them, i love to watch them both, i enjoyed deledio in his debut season more than his 2nd, and i enjoyed sherman in both but his 2nd season was far better, i ended up goin for sherman, because he seemed to add a bit more spark this year than deledio, but it was very close