Side against Saints?

[summerthebat]

In: Dodd, Headland

Out: Foster, Murphy

Will M.Carr come straight back in? If so, for whom? I don't think Crowley deserves to be dropped and we all know McManus won't be axed.

 

[dugrene]

In: Dodd, Headland

Out: Foster, Murphy

Will M.Carr come straight back in? If so, for whom? I don't think Crowley deserves to be dropped and we all know McManus won't be axed.

I know MCarr hasn't had great year but He is big, he's played a lot of footy and he can shut players down. I reckon we missed him big time in Darwin after he got laid out. Like you though I can't fit him in.

With Dodd, Headland and Carr in we would look a completely different side.

Out... Foster, Murphy
in ..... Dodd Headland.

Carr will be circling though.

 

[DOCKER MAN]

M Carr has a double hernia he shouldn't play this year, it is unfair on Foster, Cook, Webster and Even brown who have been good in the wafl.

In: Dodd, Headland (but i would like him to have one week in the wafl for confidence)
Out: Murphy (he didn't look like he was trying, there was a few times when his effort was sub standard), Macca/Shammer

I am sick of players debuting then getting dropped it kills their confidence, after collard was dropped he lost all of his form and was dropped to the reserves. If i were Harvey i would be playing foster

 

[Roundhouse]

M Carr has a double hernia he shouldn't play this year, it is unfair on Foster, Cook, Webster and Even brown who have been good in the wafl.

In: Dodd, Headland (but i would like him to have one week in the wafl for confidence)
Out: Murphy (he didn't look like he was trying, there was a few times when his effort was sub standard), Macca/Shammer

I am sick of players debuting then getting dropped it kills their confidence, after collard was dropped he lost all of his form and was dropped to the reserves. If i were Harvey i would be playing foster

Regardless of his alledged double hernia, if he can play like he did in the derby on injections (and is not risking long term injury) then he must be considered.

 

[Brumbies]

In - Dodd, Headland
Out - McManus, For a guy of his experience he does to many head high tackles and disposal is below par.
Thornton, Bit unlucky but his only attribute is his run, his def skills arnt that good and if Dodd comes in there isnt room there for him in def also he tends to turn the ball over abit with his handpass's as it looks like he panics when the pressure is on.

Dont drop Murphy as he stratches opponents defences and he is playing a different roll than usuall, more as a decoy and with him there they cant really double Pav or Tarrant. On the weekend Bombers were forced to man on man as they were strecthed same thing could happen against Saints. Might see Kossy have to go down back which would be a win for us.

 

[longsuffreosupp]

Crucial game. Go with experience.

 

[Kenny_01]

If MCarr cannot play,

IN: Headland, Dodd, Webster
OUT: McManus, Murphy, Foster

I'm undecided whether Webster should be given a game against the big bodied Saints in a pressure cooker game, or giving Foster another run. Since this is a do or die game, I think I might go with Webster.

 

[pistol17]

Must win game against the Saints I think the time has come for Harvey to make the big decision. McManus should be left out.

Out: McManus
In: Dodd

Foster will make way for Headland if fit.

 

[summerthebat]

If MCarr cannot play,

IN: Headland, Dodd, Webster
OUT: McManus, Murphy, Foster

I'm undecided whether Webster should be given a game against the big bodied Saints in a pressure cooker game, or giving Foster another run. Since this is a do or die game, I think I might go with Webster.

I very much agree with those in's. McManus getting dropped has made sense to me for this entire season, I don't see why after all this time sticking with him, why they would drop him now. I really struggle seeing why he is considered above dropping by the selection panel.

 

[prattsta]

I very much agree with those in's. McManus getting dropped has made sense to me for this entire season, I don't see why after all this time sticking with him, why they would drop him now. I really struggle seeing why he is considered above dropping by the selection panel.

I couldnt agree more.

 

[summerthebat]

I couldnt agree more.

His 'worst' performances this year have been much 'worse' than Luke Websters , yet it seems he can never be dropped.

 

[FootyEater]

i was impressed with foster, why drop him if he has done nothing wrong. i honestly dont think headland will be fit to play anyway, and matt carr has a double hernia. so that to me only leaves Dodd in and Mcmanus out

 

[Milky]

B: hayden mcpharlin grover
HB:black johnson dodd
C: mundy j.carr m.carr
HF: solomon pavlich headland
FF: farmer tarrant murphy
R: warnock, bell, haselby
I: gilmore shammer foster peake

thornton's form is ok but he is the weakest defender so he must make way for dodd

mcmanus is a legend but he is past histime and now looking worse everytime he plays he goes and headland comes back

foster was impressive and i think deserves anouther go before being dropped, plus adds more run if not crowley will be there

matt carr comes in for crowley, shammer is returning to some form so he will stay

 

[Jetau]

I would drop Murphy. He has done NOTHING in two games.

Foster was OK, but the finals are alive if we win this one. If we lose, he should come back in Round 21.

Bring back Dodd and Headland. We will need bigger bodies on the smaller TD surface, against a mature-bodied St Kilda side. There won't be half as much space as the Bombers gave us.



Out: Murphy, Foster
In: Dodd, Headland