Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch SSP (2025) - Josh Lai

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

would he be our first ever player to debut who hasnt played some form of leauge football?

incredible story, he's brother is one to watch as well.
Do you consider U/18's football as some form of league football?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

i only consider league football to be VFL, WAFL, QFL, SANFL and those types of leauges.

u18 is a funny one
I don't consider U18 level league football either, but back when the SANFL and WAFL were very strong comps and their top 4 or 5 teams were regularly competitive against the lower ranked Melbourne clubs there were Victorian commentators (Lou Richards was the major culprit), who when calling a VFL game would describe a 20 plus SA or WA footballer who had played at least 2 or 3 seasons in the `league' team for their original club as playing `their first game of football!' o_O

It was patronising and condescending BS that got up the noses of many non Victorians and probably helped cause `the kick a Vic' type responses of the era, but Richards in particular got away with that crap for years.
 

A little late but a one year extension looming for the kid. Hope once he comes back from his injury and has a few solid weeks getting up to scratch again and pushes his case for an AFL debut.
 
Last edited:
One of the very few against Norwood who played for 4 quarters. Has some serious pace and will drag in a few hangers, loves a leap.

Look forward to seeing him next year.
 
One of the very few against Norwood who played for 4 quarters. Has some serious pace and will drag in a few hangers, loves a leap.

Look forward to seeing him next year.
Not gonna solve the lack of a lockdown small defender but I reckon use Lai in the back and move Sinn to the wing. Lai has more defensive capabilities than Sinn imo.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Like him a lot. Certainly much tougher than Farrell.

Farrell actually has a massive weakness in his contested game. Gets beaten 1on1 every single time be it in a wrestle or for a ground ball. You can set your watch to it. Absolutely horrendous contested player.
 
Like him a lot. Certainly much tougher than Farrell.

Farrell actually has a massive weakness in his contested game. Gets beaten 1on1 every single time be it in a wrestle or for a ground ball. You can set your watch to it. Absolutely horrendous contested player.

I've said it a dozen times.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Like him a lot. Certainly much tougher than Farrell.

Farrell actually has a massive weakness in his contested game. Gets beaten 1on1 every single time be it in a wrestle or for a ground ball. You can set your watch to it. Absolutely horrendous contested player.

We have a fleet of very mediocre small defenders (Farrell, Jones, Sinn) who do just enough to get a game each week and should be seen as eminently replaceable by a decent young prospect like Lai. Hopefully Carr sees this and doesn't just roll out more of the same.
 
We have a fleet of very mediocre small defenders (Farrell, Jones, Sinn) who do just enough to get a game each week and should be seen as eminently replaceable by a decent young prospect like Lai. Hopefully Carr sees this and doesn't just roll out more of the same.

Harsh to call both Jones and Sinn mediocre small defenders. Sinn has had an excellent season as a defender (not yet shown his attacking side, but as a pure defender)

Jones has had a pretty solid season as well, and was right up there with some defensive stats across the comp before he got injured.

Farrell is a mediocre defender, but is in the side for his kicking - which I don't think was particularly special this season to be fair.
 
Harsh to call both Jones and Sinn mediocre small defenders. Sinn has had an excellent season as a defender (not yet shown his attacking side, but as a pure defender)

Jones has had a pretty solid season as well, and was right up there with some defensive stats across the comp before he got injured.

Farrell is a mediocre defender, but is in the side for his kicking - which I don't think was particularly special this season to be fair.

I disagree completely.

I look at guys like Starcevich and Lester at Brisbane and they're streets ahead of Jones and Sinn for dependability.

There's a reason only West Coast, North and Richmond conceded more than us this year and it's not because all of our defenders are amazing. We have to lift our standards across the board and look for players who are going to be able to win premierships not just be not totally terrible.
 
Should get a game next year with Ryan Burton’s departure.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch SSP (2025) - Josh Lai

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top