He'd be #2 behind Dumesny for me.Duval would be top of my list to replace McQuillan
Yeah, stupid auto correct, Pittard*I assume you mean Pittard?
For me it depends who the mature aged guy is. If it's someone between 21 and 25 and couldn't develop in the AFL for their old side for whatever reason, I'd go after them. I also wouldn't mind getting someone in that age bracket that's a ruckman, whether that be Oliver Eastland, Daniel Fahey-Sparks or whomever.
I'm thinking about 2022. We had the right idea with Crauford (despite whatever reason he decided to go home), knowing that Bellchambers was likely to retire and Phillips won't have much longer left either, get someone in to fast track their development.Yeah, stupid auto correct, Pittard*
I’m ok with going into 2021 with Draper, Phillips and Bryan as rucks on the list.
We have two SPP positions available (Moz to the ‘inactive’ makes it three rookie selections available, correct?) a midfielder and a half back for me please.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
We are extremely shallow for senior depth at the medium defender spot.He'd be #2 behind Dumesny for me.
We're actually not and we're not challenging soon, hence my Dumesny preferenceWe are extremely shallow for senior depth at the medium defender spot.
Duval is AFL ready, Dumesny is a project.
Harlequin Dream can confirm but I thought Duval was more Luke Brown than Jake Lloyd.We're actually not and we're not challenging soon, hence my Dumesny preference
Dumensy way too slowHe'd be #2 behind Dumesny for me.
Because we lost a half back flanker? Probably the worst place to put him
Maybe. We still need at least one half back flanker in the SSP/MSD.Dumensy way too slow
I'm not denying that we need him, I'm saying is that McQuillan's retirement shouldn't be the catalyst for it.Because we have 1 genuine inside mid on the list.
I got the sense it was because it opened up an additional list spot.I'm not denying that we need him, I'm saying is that McQuillan's retirement shouldn't be the catalyst for it.
We do need a good small forward with out Fanta/Townsend/MozzieI agree that we need to have upside in mind given our list position but you need to be prepared to fail fast with these 1 year contracts. Picking players that are 20 to 24 gives a good balance between these aims.
The obvious 2 are Duval and Mansell, however there are others I would look at:
Aemon Wilkinson is a 20 year old small forward who kicked 25.19 over 16 games for South Adelaide. Good, tough goalsneak. I would prefer him to be more of a dead-eye but he is likely to be the best small forward in the SANFL with Rowe gone.
Will Combe is the other one. Was a very good half forward in 2020. Good tough role-player who won the SANFL breakthrough award last year.
No current season stats available
Mansell is training with Richmond over the pre season.1 Mansell please
Has the paper bag era returned at the Blues ?If Carlton's VFL list has Crocker, Wooller, Phillips, North, Stoddart, Parsons and Reynolds they're going to be very strong next year.
Good pointHas the paper bag era returned at the Blues ?![]()