Walker vs Tambling.

[celtic_pride]

Walker=worst 2nd draft pick in the last 10 years

You know nothing about football.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Josh Fraser - worst no 1 pick in the last 10 years!
A.Walker > Egan,Clokes,Shaws and Billy Morrison!

Egan,Clokes,Shaws and Billy Morrison werent taken at number 2 in the draft.
Josh Fraser>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Carbon Rod>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.Cameron Cloke>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Jason Cloke>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Andrew Walker

 

[itsintheblood]

We have three small forwards on our list.

And they are?????

 

[itsintheblood]

We don't need Tamblimg. We have Betts!

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Another Marty McGrath.

 

[Ipaidmy200in89]

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

Another Marty McGrath.

Tambling is nearly as good as him.....5 goals on debut Tambling did not kick!

 

[Bentleigh]

Tambling is nearly as good as him.....5 goals on debut Tambling did not kick!

Yoda?

 

[FIGJAM]

Rusling.

 

[Bentleigh]

Rusling.

Mick seems to facny Tambling.

"We didnt get a pick untill 7"
We could have had Tambling"

 

[celtic_pride]

Rusling.

Who ????

 

[Silvagnis]

Tambling is nearly as good as him.....5 goals on debut Tambling did not kick!

5 goals on debut, another Justin Murphy!

 

[Choota]

Mick seems to facny Tambling.

"We didnt get a pick untill 7"
We could have had Tambling"

Yeah Mick has a great eye for young talent.

I voted for Tambling though i'm not overly keen on either of them to be honest.

 

[Slander]

Yeah Mick has a great eye for young talent.

I voted for Tambling though i'm not overly keen on either of them to be honest.

True that, I'd be rapt with Jordan Lewis ahead of those two.

Lewis>Tambling,Walker

By a mile.

 

[Statistician]

No offence but anyone who replied in this topic should hang their heads in shame.

FFS give the kids a chance to prove themselves. You cannot judge Tambling yet as he has only played 3-4 games.

Who will be better? Flip a coin. Ask this question in 3-5 years and I could give you a straight answer.

 

[F/D]

Tambling by so much that it aint funny.

 

[Silvagnis]

Mick seems to facny Tambling.

"We didnt get a pick untill 7"
We could have had Tambling"

No, he wouldn't have got Tambling as they traded that pick and would have a stuff up as bad as when Richmond missed on Wells.

True that, I'd be rapt with Jordan Lewis ahead of those two.

Lewis>Tambling,Walker

By a mile.

Denis wouldn't as Walker will win more matches than Lewis and is the allround package.

 

[tigerT]

neither have proved much yet

IMO walker will become a lot more consistent as a footballer and tambiling will be very hit and miss, his best will be top shelf but his worst will be some of the worst.

1st of all i refuse to vote on this poll, premature ejaculation...


Theres a common misconception abt tambling that hes ur classic run of the mill outside player, hes actually very much a win ur own ball type and a criticism of his as a junior was he can be to concious abt winning the ball that he forgets/loses his opponent... in the few games hes played so far this season if anyone has seen, he doesnt shirk the contest, yeah all 70kgs of him... iv seen him get winded in every game thus far trying to break thru a pack knowing he will get hit, hes got courage and isnt soft. Has the ability and speed to do the freaky things but will be a consistant player with good clean skills and not a 'flash in the pan go missing for large interval' type, bookmark it if u want, thats my call

I cant believe walker is getting paid out by some ppl here. Has already shown hes got all the tools, and played some great games, just a matter of time before he puts it together consistently

 

[Bentleigh]

I voted for Tambling though i'm not overly keen on either of them to be honest.

Changed your tune champ.

 

[Bentleigh]

True that, I'd be rapt with Jordan Lewis ahead of those two.

Lewis>Tambling,Walker

By a mile.

More of your Logic.

MElbourne Brown > Richmond Brown eh sunshine?

 

[cs61]

No way

You ask for people to reply their opinion, then disregard it because you disagree. Why bother if you think you know the answer and wont listen to anyone else?

 

[Jeremias]

Bump.

Walker is an absolute mile ahead of Tambling.

 

[Spitz]

Bump.

Walker is an absolute mile ahead of Tambling.

Errr please enlighten me why?

Had a laugh in the car on the weekend when the biased carlton commentators on SEN were talking about Walker saying he was clearly better than Adam Conney, and had shown alot more in this point to their careers

sorry, dont rate walker at all.

 

[Jeremias]

Errr please enlighten me why?

Had a laugh in the car on the weekend when the biased carlton commentators on SEN were talking about Walker saying he was clearly better than Adam Conney, and had shown alot more in this point to their careers

sorry, dont rate walker at all.

Are you being serious?

 

[jonesy86]

IMO they have both been disappointing...but Tambling has been much more disappointing, therefore Walker gets my vote

 

[Silvagnis]

sorry, dont rate walker at all.

The fact you think Swallow is a young Daniel Kerr and Kerr couldn't kick as a young player means your opinion should be ignored.

Alot of people in the know, have told me he is very very similar to a young Daniel Kerr, same problem with kicking early in careers, very similar style/attack on the ball, body shape, speed, footy smarts, work ethic etc

 

[CrazyQ]

The fact you think Swallow is a young Daniel Kerr and Kerr couldn't kick as young player shows you should be ignored.

Has Walker?

Swallow, IIRC, has improved his kicking ten-fold.

Kicking in the 80's now.