- Jun 6, 2010
- 4,030
- 12,851
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Dillon Panthers
not sure if it goes here but is dayne beams worth more than pick 4?
4 is fair, Beams has missed a lot of games due to "injuries"
2014 non Freo games
- Thread starter Kram
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
4 is fair, Beams has missed a lot of games due to "injuries"
Great, I'll have to skip lunch now.
Yes.not sure if it goes here but is dayne beams worth more than pick 4?
- Jan 14, 2008
- 14,827
- 31,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
So no faith in what we have got.
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #7,255
The point was that sydney had gotten better, my point was that yes they had gotten better... By securing two good tall forwards for no draft damage, one just happened to be the best in the game.
We would need to pull Chad Wingard across as a delisted free agent to compare ourselves to Sydney.
- Jan 14, 2008
- 14,827
- 31,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
So your'e saying we will stagnate and cant improve
Whats the purpose in following a footy side if you think they cant improve.
Hawthorn lost the best so called forward in the game and still came up with the chocolates.
Easily.not sure if it goes here but is dayne beams worth more than pick 4?
Would you rather take Dayne Beams? Or a raw kid who may develop to one day be as good as Dayne Beams if you're lucky.
Taylor
Community Leader
- Moderator
- #7,260
I don't think either Collingwood or Brisbane are in a flag window to justify choosing the established player over the potential better player.
For us we would rather a guy ready to go, I don't really see the value in Beams for Brisbane unless they think they will be top four in three years.
well he is only 24 yo and would fit very nicely while their other young players develop
agree with pick 4 but i am not sure about an extra player to be packaged with pick 4
- Jan 14, 2008
- 14,827
- 31,828
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Great, we are on the same page re improvement .
Personally I think Collingwood & Brisbane should do a player for player swap. Beams is a good midfielder. Brisbane have a few upcoming good midfielders. Leave pick 4 off the table and swap Beams for someone like a Rockliff, Hanley or Aish.
Collingwood are well within their right to demand what they think Beams is worth. How many votes did he poll in the Brownlow this year? This is on a team that has Pendlebury and Swan amongst others. It has absolutely nothing to do with what Beams means to Brisbane, Collingwood shouldn't get less because Brisbane aren't one player away from a flag.
Yep, not a bad call. Rockliff and Hanley wouldn't go anywhere though I reckon.
Anyone else watching the Oakland v Kansas City game on ESPN now? 2 teams with the lowest payrolls in the league, and KC playing it's first postseason in many fans lifetime. Bloody fascinating, and I don't really follow the game much.
Into the 12th inning now.
Into the 12th inning now.
Most of the time i'd agree, but when there's a subtext to any sporting match that's a lot more than the game itself, then that really intrigues me.
Last strike in the 12th innings got it done for KC. Oakland blew a 4 run lead in the 8th.
not sure if it goes here but is dayne beams worth more than pick 4?
Been living under a rock?
I think seeing as Patful wants to leave Brisbane, they should look at something along the lines of..
Collingwood get: Pick 4, Patful
Brisbane get: Beams, 2nd/3rd rounder.
Patful would fit into the backline well down there with the likes of Lamumba, Maxwell etc. leaving.
Collingwood get: Pick 4, Patful
Brisbane get: Beams, 2nd/3rd rounder.
Patful would fit into the backline well down there with the likes of Lamumba, Maxwell etc. leaving.
- Status
