2016 trade hypotheticals

[bungwahl]

Just no way the Tigers would use 27 in a trade for Nankervis.

I understand your draft values, with picks going back the other way, but most other clubs can't turn 3 or 4 30s/40s picks into pick 3 on draft day. Pretty sure Richmond would rather hold onto a top 30 pick than flip it for a back up ruck and a 50s pick.

Yeah obviously pick upgrades work far better in fantasy land than in reality, but that one doesn't look too far off. Nankervis would be ~35 so 27 + a pick back isn't far off. Obviously the problem is they're also likely using #6 for Prestia. I guess it all depends on what happens with Deledio too.

 

[MotleyLemon]

Yeah obviously pick upgrades work far better in fantasy land than in reality, but that one doesn't look too far off. Nankervis would be ~35 so 27 + a pick back isn't far off. Obviously the problem is they're also likely using #6 for Prestia. I guess it all depends on what happens with Deledio too.

Reckon you might be overvaluing Nankervis a bit mate.

 

[bungwahl]

Reckon you might be overvaluing Nankervis a bit mate.

Originally taken pick 35 by Sydney, 3 years development and now a viable ruck option. Big men don't tend to drop in value when they're following that progression line. He's third in line at Sydney but I'd love to keep him.

 

[MotleyLemon]

Originally taken pick 35 by Sydney, 3 years development and now a viable ruck option. Big men don't tend to drop in value when they're following that progression line. He's third in line at Sydney but I'd love to keep him.

Reckon 45 is more realistic mate.

 

[Jackywats]

There better be more to it! Rockliff? as i cant see hanley being worth a first round and a second....

Wouldn't be a first and second. Would be getting a first and 22, while giving 19 (upgrade on 22) and hanley.

 

[bungwahl]

Reckon 45 is more realistic mate.

If it's 45 I'd move some of the cash from Xavier Richards rejected offer over to Toby and try to keep him. Hard to find that type of ruck who can throw his weight around a bit.

 

[Achy Blakey Heart]

Agree....45 is unders for Tobes in a market devoid of quality rucks. I'd be interested to see who Nankervis would be back up to....Hampson? Maric?.....you have to be kidding...

 

[pinot]

Hey, not my idea!
Just trying to interpret a Carlton supports post... Not easy you know!

Bryce Gibbs + Pick 45 to Port for Pick 9 + Pick 19

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Bryce Gibbs + Pick 45 to Port for Pick 9 + Pick 19

no thanks...

 

[AusTerran]

Bryce Gibbs + Pick 45 to Port for Pick 9 + Pick 19

Go for it!
Although, you'll have to pay his contract as the rumours from Port is they have no cap space lol
Gibbs man-bun will fit quite well at Port

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Go for it!
Although, you'll have to pay his contract as the rumours from Port is they have no cap space lol
Gibbs man-bun will fit quite well at Port

well, we cant do much worse.
we just gave a guy weve been shopping around a 3 year deal

 

[Madness101]

Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia +pick 24 + 44
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27 + Deledio
Geelong lose : Caddy

Sydney Gain: pick 27
Gold Coast gain : Pick 6 + Caddy
Richmond gain : Prestia + Nakervis + Pick 24 + pick 39
Geelong gain : Deledio + Pick 44

Gold Coast get their pick 6 and a ready made midfielder which they claim to want. Only chink I see is if Caddy doesn't want to go to Gold Coast.

 

[AusTerran]

well, we cant do much worse.
we just gave a guy weve been shopping around a 3 year deal

What a great move!
Now you can ask for two 1st round picks as he is now contracted!
Man! I was so wrong about Ports list management!

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

What a great move!
Now you can ask for two 1st round picks as he is now contracted!
Man! I was so wrong about Ports list management!

honestly, i am angry and dumbfounded at what we are doing...
this smells of a man trying to save his job...

our board is a great place to go to to get a laugh!

 

[cotter101]

Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia +pick 24 + 44
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27 + Deledio
Geelong lose : Caddy

Sydney Gain: pick 27
Gold Coast gain : Pick 6 + Caddy
Richmond gain : Prestia + Nakervis + Pick 24 + pick 39
Geelong gain : Deledio + Pick 44

Gold Coast get their pick 6 and a ready made midfielder which they claim to want. Only chink I see is if Caddy doesn't want to go to Gold Coast.

Good luck getting Caddy to move back to QLD to play for GC again.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Port hamstrung by long-term contracts given 1-2 years ago.

What do we do next?

LONG-TERM CONTRACTS FOR ALL!

 

[Madness101]

Good luck getting Caddy to move back to QLD to play for GC again.

Ohh yeah, I didn't calculate that factor in.

 

[Madness101]

Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia + 44
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27
Carlton Lose : Gibbs
Adelaide Lose : Pick 13 + 2017 Second Round Pick


Carlton Gain pick 13 + 39
Sydney Gain: pick 27
Gold Coast gain : pick 6
Richmond gain : Nankervis + Prestia + Adelaids 2017 Second Round Pick ( Say 28- 32 ?)
Adelaide Gain : Gibbs + 44

Seems fairly even ? Carlton Happy with 13 + 39 ?

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia + 44
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27
Carlton Lose : Gibbs
Adelaide Lose : Pick 13 + 2017 Second Round Pick


Carlton Gain pick 13 + 39
Sydney Gain: pick 27
Gold Coast gain : pick 6
Richmond gain : Nankervis + Prestia + Adelaids 2017 Second Round Pick ( Say 28- 32 ?)
Adelaide Gain : Gibbs + 44

Seems fairly even ? Carlton Happy with 13 + 39 ?

Richmond lose 6 + 27
Gain: Prestia, Nankervis and 2017 2nd...

seems fair

 

[Madness101]

Richmond lose 6 + 27
Gain: Prestia, Nankervis and 2017 2nd...

seems fair

I wont lie, I think we get the better of it all. But not by much and it hardly leaves one party not getting something good and fair.

 

[Mitchell54]

Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia + 44
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27
Carlton Lose : Gibbs
Adelaide Lose : Pick 13 + 2017 Second Round Pick


Carlton Gain pick 13 + 39
Sydney Gain: pick 27
Gold Coast gain : pick 6
Richmond gain : Nankervis + Prestia + Adelaids 2017 Second Round Pick ( Say 28- 32 ?)
Adelaide Gain : Gibbs + 44

Seems fairly even ? Carlton Happy with 13 + 39 ?

Basically just added a swap of 3rd rounder between Sydney and Richmond. 52 for 46. Thought Nankervis was worth a bit more and Richmond was getting it pretty good.
Also added GCS 4th rounder to go to Carlton

Changes i would make are
Sydney lose : Nankervis + Pick 39 + 52
Gold Coast Lose : Prestia + 44 + 62
Richmond Lose : Pick 6 + Pick 27 + 46
Carlton Lose : Gibbs
Adelaide Lose : Pick 13 + 2017 Second Round Pick


Carlton Gain pick 13 + 39 + 62
Sydney Gain: pick 27, 46
Gold Coast gain : pick 6
Richmond gain : Nankervis + Prestia + 52 + Adelaids 2017 Second Round Pick ( Say 28- 32 ?)
Adelaide Gain : Gibbs + 44

 

[BomberDee]

James Stewart > Essendon
Pick 59 > GWS

 

[SnowRoo]

Lets try this for North

Deal 1
11+Black to Port (add in B.Mac if needed)
for
19+Hartlett+49
North wear all of Hartletts contract and half of Blacks

Deal 2
49 to Dogs
for
Hrovat
close enough to Blues 45 to get it done

Deal 3
19+Hansen to Bris
for
21+22
Swap Hansen for Thompson if you prefer

Deal 4
33 to GWS
for
WHE
Up the $$ a little to make it more enticing

Deal 5
2017 1st round + 32 to GC
for
Pick 6 (once they get it from tigers)+44
Would prefer pick 4 with the promise of no bid but keeping it real

Deal 6
44+87 to Adel
for
Lyons+Dear

 

[Senor M]

With rumours coming out that Deledio could be heading to GWS for Pick 15, with Richmond playing a chunk of Lid's contract for 2017-- giving the Giants another mature player that may get them their first premiership. If Richmond get pick 15 for Deledio, what about this for a trade??

Gold Coast Give: Prestia & O'Meara
Richmond Give: Pick 6, Pick 15 & Pick 27

 

[philthy05]

Lets try this for North

Deal 1
11+Black to Port (add in B.Mac if needed)
for
19+Hartlett+49
North wear all of Hartletts contract and half of Blacks

Deal 2
49 to Dogs
for
Hrovat
close enough to Blues 45 to get it done

Deal 3
19+Hansen to Bris
for
21+22
Swap Hansen for Thompson if you prefer

Deal 4
33 to GWS
for
WHE
Up the $$ a little to make it more enticing

Deal 5
2017 1st round + 32 to GC
for
Pick 6 (once they get it from tigers)+44
Would prefer pick 4 with the promise of no bid but keeping it real

Deal 6
44+87 to Adel
for
Lyons+Dear

That's ****ing horrible

You have suggested raping almost the entire league

Why waste time writing such crap