Masqualero
Club Legend
- Jul 2, 2015
- 1,658
- 2,231
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Both play similar positions.
Who would you rather have on your team for now and the future?
Who would you rather have on your team for now and the future?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Wingard's career really hasn't kicked on since he made AA rather unexpectedly in the beginning of his career (i forget whether it was his 2nd or 3rd year). He's now just another pretty good smaller forward type - along with so many others.
I agree on this part - a player's game-winning ability is very high on my demands list. Wingard just has that X-factor that Greene doesn't. Over four quarters of footy though I take Greene, which is why I voted for him.Would prefer Wingard. Just get that feeling in a big finals moment Wingard would do something special to win the game, or Greene would do something stupid to lose it.
there is always one in every thread, isn't there?I'd like to have em both at the Hawks thanks.....Though I would still take Robbie Gray ahead of them both.
Greene has a heap of X-factor imo, where he lets himself down is he is a hot-head and you can put him off his game if you get in his head.I agree on this part - a player's game-winning ability is very high on my demands list. Wingard just has that X-factor that Greene doesn't. Over four quarters of footy though I take Greene, which is why I voted for him.
Wingard has struggled with injury to be fair.
Wingards form has dropped, not as damaging as he was.
Well up until 2016 he was playing pretty solid football consistently. In 2016 he was missing sporadic games and was clearly not playing the same kind of footy as he had up until then. This season he was very good in the first 8 rounds playing mostly as a midfielder then I believe he injured his ankle? Didn't spend too long out but was off the pace a little when he returned before finding some really good form in the last 8 rounds including a couple of top class performances.Has he really? He's missed 12 games total in six seasons.
Has he really? He's missed 12 games total in six seasons.
Well, if people actually watched Port Adelaide this year, they'd see that he basically swapped roles with Robbie Gray, and is spending far more time in the midfield than he had prior. Is just as damaging and effective in a playmaking role as he is as a goalkicker.
And I don't quite understand why they did that. To me, Gray is a better midfielder while they're both gun forwards.