Strategy 2020 Hypothetical Trades – Left Field Trade Ideas

Remove this Banner Ad

Jenkins Narkle and Constable for Essendon mid 2nd rd pick

Jenkins gives Bombers a reliable 2nd forward and bridging forward
Narkle can play mid/fwd
Constable gives them another in and under Mid
 
catman2006 said:
Jenkins Narkle and Constable for Essendon mid 2nd rd pick

Jenkins gives Bombers a reliable 2nd forward and bridging forward
Narkle can play mid/fwd
Constable gives them another in and under Mid
Click to expand...
You have a very interesting definition of "hypothetical".
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Possibly left field but more hypothetical than anything.

Daniher and Saad wanting out of Essendon and Essendon wanting first rounders for them from Brisbane and Carlton. Would something like this work*?

*all picks pre compensation and bidding.

Carlton trade out 7+45 and 2021 3rd to Brisbane for 16+17 and 2021 2nd (Thoughts here Brisbane are the buyers for a top 10 pick will have to pay a little more and I can't see any other top 10 pick team trading, maybe Freo maybe Adelaide if {big if} they get 2 [would think 8 could be moved for two in the teens] but Carlton may purely to piss Essendon off on the Saad trade)

Carlton trade out 16+Bris 2021 2nd (maybe their own but I settled with Brisbane's) to Essendon for Saad.

Brisbane trade out 7 to Essendon for Daniher+ 42. (later pick swaps as well possibly).

But this would leave:
Carlton in: Saad, 17
Carlton out: 7, 45, 2021 3rd.

Brisbane in: Daniher, 42, 45 and Carlton 2021 3rd.
Brisbane out: 16, 17, 2021 2nd.

Essendon in: 7, 16 and Brisbane 2021 2nd.
Essendon out: Saad, Daniher, 42
 
Assuming Caldwell would nominate Nth over the Saints and GWS match the Cameron FA offer.

Ben Brown and Norths second to GWS
Cameron to Cats
Caldwell and Geelongs pick 9 to North

Seems a win win win if all agreed.
 
powerrrrrrrrrrrr said:
Assuming Caldwell would nominate Nth over the Saints and GWS match the Cameron FA offer.

Ben Brown to GWS
Cameron to Cats
Caldwell and Geelongs pick 9 to North

Seems a win win win if all agreed. Maybe an extra 2nd in there going to GWS somewhere
Click to expand...
LOL

So GWS basically get Ben Brown for Jeremy Cameron and Jye Caldwell?

GWS getting bent over and reamed with no lube there.

Try again.

Cameron is worth 2 possibly 3 of Geelong's 1st rounders without even bringing the Roos into the discussion
 
Mutineer said:
LOL

So GWS basically get Ben Brown for Jeremy Cameron and Jye Caldwell?

GWS getting bent over and reamed with no lube there.

Try again.

Cameron is worth 2 possibly 3 of Geelong's 1st rounders without even bringing the Roos into the discussion
Click to expand...
Why don't you make it six first rounders while you're at it ?
 
Mutineer said:
LOL

So GWS basically get Ben Brown for Jeremy Cameron and Jye Caldwell?

GWS getting bent over and reamed with no lube there.

Try again.

Cameron is worth 2 possibly 3 of Geelong's 1st rounders without even bringing the Roos into the discussion
Click to expand...

If GWS want another year or two as contenders before their door may close they need another key forward. Brown has kicked just as many goals between 16-19 and excluding this season as Cameron.

North’s second is almost equal to the cats last first rounder. So essentially an equal goal kicking player swap to help them hopefully reach a premiership before it’s too late. Brown will help them achieve that more than draft picks right now
 
powerrrrrrrrrrrr said:
If GWS want another year or two as contenders before their door may close they need another key forward. Brown has kicked just as many goals between 16-19 and excluding this season as Cameron.

North’s second is almost equal to the cats last first rounder. So essentially an equal goal kicking player swap to help them hopefully reach a premiership before it’s too late. Brown will help them achieve that more than draft picks right now
Click to expand...
And what of Caldwell?

You are in Disneyland if you think GWS are giving up Cameron and Caldwell for Ben Brown and a 2nd round pick.
 
Mutineer said:
And what of Caldwell?

You are in Disneyland if you think GWS are giving up Cameron and Caldwell for Ben Brown and a 2nd round pick.
Click to expand...

I guess that’s why it’s called the Hypothetical trade thread and all depends on how much weight the Giants might put into getting a gun forward as a direct replacement over draft picks
 
croweater 41 said:
Possibly left field but more hypothetical than anything.

Daniher and Saad wanting out of Essendon and Essendon wanting first rounders for them from Brisbane and Carlton. Would something like this work*?

*all picks pre compensation and bidding.

Carlton trade out 7+45 and 2021 3rd to Brisbane for 16+17 and 2021 2nd (Thoughts here Brisbane are the buyers for a top 10 pick will have to pay a little more and I can't see any other top 10 pick team trading, maybe Freo maybe Adelaide if {big if} they get 2 [would think 8 could be moved for two in the teens] but Carlton may purely to piss Essendon off on the Saad trade)

Carlton trade out 16+Bris 2021 2nd (maybe their own but I settled with Brisbane's) to Essendon for Saad.

Brisbane trade out 7 to Essendon for Daniher+ 42. (later pick swaps as well possibly).

But this would leave:
Carlton in: Saad, 17
Carlton out: 7, 45, 2021 3rd.

Brisbane in: Daniher, 42, 45 and Carlton 2021 3rd.
Brisbane out: 16, 17, 2021 2nd.

Essendon in: 7, 16 and Brisbane 2021 2nd.
Essendon out: Saad, Daniher, 42
Click to expand...

#16 is more than enough for Saad, no need for Carlton to throw in a 2nd as well
 
Mutineer said:
And what of Caldwell?

You are in Disneyland if you think GWS are giving up Cameron and Caldwell for Ben Brown and a 2nd round pick.
Click to expand...
Personally, I like the trade. Let's get it done.
 
Adel In: Fantasia, Pick 6 (Dons), Future 3rd round (Dogs)
Adel Out: Pick 2

WBD In: Pick 2 (Crows)
WBD Out: Dunkley, Future 3rd

Ess In: Dunkley
Ess Out: Pick 6, Fantasia

-----------------------------------------------------------

Dogs get Logan McDonald and JUH. JUH also moves from a pick 2 big at best to a pick 3 bid at best

Dons recruit his brother Kyle Dunkley along with his brother accepting to come to the club on money and midfield minutes

Everyone's happy
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Keystone agony said:
Adel In: Fantasia, Pick 6 (Dons), Future 3rd round (Dogs)
Adel Out: Pick 2

WBD In: Pick 2 (Crows)
WBD Out: Dunkley, Future 3rd

Ess In: Dunkley
Ess Out: Pick 6, Fantasia

-----------------------------------------------------------

Dogs get Logan McDonald and JUH. JUH also moves from a pick 2 big at best to a pick 3 bid at best

Dons recruit his brother Kyle Dunkley along with his brother accepting to come to the club on money and midfield minutes

Everyone's happy
Click to expand...
What’s in it for Adelaide?
 
Stamos said:
#16 is more than enough for Saad, no need for Carlton to throw in a 2nd as well
Click to expand...
In the big scheme of things it’s your future third and you keep your future second.

I’m aware 16 is probably enough but if you gave up Brisbane’s future second I don’t think you should be to upset by it.
 
Keystone agony said:
Adel In: Fantasia, Pick 6 (Dons), Future 3rd round (Dogs)
Adel Out: Pick 2

WBD In: Pick 2 (Crows)
WBD Out: Dunkley, Future 3rd

Ess In: Dunkley
Ess Out: Pick 6, Fantasia

-----------------------------------------------------------

Dogs get Logan McDonald and JUH. JUH also moves from a pick 2 big at best to a pick 3 bid at best

Dons recruit his brother Kyle Dunkley along with his brother accepting to come to the club on money and midfield minutes

Everyone's happy
Click to expand...
If we're losing Dunkley, we shouldn't have to add the future 3rd to get Pick 2. Also can't imagine we'd want 2 key forwards from the same draft unless we shipped Bruce/Schache off or moved Naughton back.

Can't imagine Adelaide goes for that deal either tbh. Only really works for Essendon
 
Virgin Dog said:
If we're losing Dunkley, we shouldn't have to add the future 3rd to get Pick 2. Also can't imagine we'd want 2 key forwards from the same draft unless we shipped Bruce/Schache off or moved Naughton back.

Can't imagine Adelaide goes for that deal either tbh. Only really works for Essendon
Click to expand...

Dogs have options as you've stated yourself
3 tall forwards
Naughton can go back
Tall kids take time
Bruce not doing alot

Pick 6 potentiallh passing up on guys like Cerra, Rozee, Bailey Smith, Max King, Serong types from the last 2-3 years
 
Keystone agony said:
Dogs have options as you've stated yourself
3 tall forwards
Naughton can go back
Tall kids take time
Bruce not doing alot

Pick 6 potentiallh passing up on guys like Cerra, Rozee, Bailey Smith, Max King, Serong types from the last 2-3 years
Click to expand...
We're in a position that we want to compete soon. We can't rely on two 18 year old KPFs if we want to be serious in finals. I'd rather keep Dunkley
 
Northernsoul74 said:
Even if he wasn’t I’m pretty sure you could grab him without having to move pick 2 to 6.
Click to expand...
I would think you are absolutely correct.

To be honest I’m falling in the basket we won’t be getting pick two as compo so it won’t be happening anyway.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Purple7x08_24
Opinion Hypothetical Mid season Trades
Replies
6
Views
481
go_the_dockers
go_the_dockers
MarcMaverick
Mid-Season Trading and AFL
2 3 4
Replies
75
Views
4K
go_the_dockers
go_the_dockers
MarkJohnson#1
Opinion Trade Week Terminology
2
Replies
35
Views
1K
Rohan25
Rohan25
PMBangers
2023 Hypothetical Trades: Who says no? - Win Prizes!
6 7 8 9 10
Replies
245
Views
16K
Vindicater
Vindicater
Milanista28
Strategy Hypothetical Pick Trade Thread
13 14 15 16 17
Replies
403
Views
20K
liz
L
Mr.X
  • Locked
Speculation George Hewett - maybe offered for a trade
Replies
12
Views
998
Jeremias
Jeremias
DEESNUTSRBIG
  • Poll
Does the AFL need live Draft Day Trading?
Replies
14
Views
1K
Vindicater
Vindicater

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top