List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency talk Pt 3

[Sol23]

To be fair, Shai's gamble has backfired. Holding out on your contract usually works but you need to play well - his last month has done nothing to increase his value.

It hasn't worked, time to sign on and get on with the job Shai.

Hasn’t backfired at all. He’s our number one player so don’t see how holding off to get top dollar hurts him.

 

[beema limapep]

Damn... With all due respect, I'm glad you're not in charge of our list management

Im glad you are glad.

My way is the best way.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

That would put his debut against freo (his dads other old club) so it has a little bit of history for him as well

You got something against MRJ debuting in front of the Richmond faithful?

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Hasn’t backfired at all. He’s our number one player so don’t see how holding off to get top dollar hurts him.

says G'day

 

[Muddiemoose]

You got something against MRJ debuting in front of the Richmond faithful?

Not particularly
Just more about his fitness and who we are up against for the next two rounds

Freo will be an “easier” game to give him his first taste than the lions and especially the cats who have a very good defensive structures atm

The Freo connection is just a happy coincidence

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Not particularly
Just more about his fitness and who we are up against for the next two rounds

Freo will be an “easier” game to give him his first taste than the lions and especially the cats who have a very good defensive structures atm

The Freo connection is just a happy coincidence

Jack Dyer stand would be pulled down if MRJ doesn't debut at the G.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Jack Dyer stand would be pulled down if MRJ doesn't debut at the G.

Round 21 v north?

 

[Frustrated Tiger]

Jack Dyer stand would be pulled down if MRJ doesn't debut at the G.

This week...

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Round 21 v north?

When was the last time we played the roos at the G?

 

[Muddiemoose]

When was the last time we played the roos at the G?

I couldn’t actually tell you
Maybe that final they beat us in around 2015?

 

[Bojangles17]

What rubbish re Green,if Green says I'm out of here,very few clubs would keep especially if kelly pulls that 8x 1 million lever.
Gws being chasing ccj for years,they say we want ccj and a second rounder ,
Done deal,gws better off, Tigers happy

What gives you the impression he would do that , he did sign an extension that always says something

 

[Bojangles17]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

 

[tunksy]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

We gotta try something. Potentially see if we can get darcy foggarty too for a reasonable price

Losing cj but gaining weiderman would be good

 

[Sol23]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

Don’t mind this at all

 

[Oshka]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

He won’t leave Melbourne

 

[tugga]

He won’t leave Melbourne

He will if he keeps getting overlooked

 

[tugga]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

Don’t mind it at all. 20 is too much though.

 

[tiger_tough]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

I beg your pardon?! Sam weideman makes egg look courageous.

6 years in and averages 1 goal a game. Shocking footballer. If we trade for him I'll cancel my membership.

 

[Charlie Pannam]

RCD will come good. He’s not the first player I would look to offload, debut was this year and plenty of time to develop his career. Question would be more on the likes of Castagna and Aarts who are in their prime and stinking it up. RCD might not be a superstar but he’ll be at least a solid contributor in our engine room

That’s a great call, RCD has some flaws but on the flip side he has some real upside. No way you offload him while keeping cloggers like Aarts snd Castagna

 

[Charlie Pannam]

I beg your pardon?! Sam weideman makes egg look courageous.

6 years in and averages 1 goal a game. Shocking footballer. If we trade for him I'll cancel my membership.

Yeah plays with zero physicality. His attack on marking contests reminds me of Jack Watts

 

[fargothegreat]

Sam weiderman would form a great duo with lynch ,and reckon pick 20 something gets it done , would love to get him to Tigerland

Would rather Riccardi if we're going down that path.

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Tonight just reinforced for me what we need to do moving forward.

As it stands we hold picks 7 16 26 29 42 & 44

Right now picks 7 & 16 should be off the table, if Cerra wants to come to us then trade our 2022 first round pick and perhaps one of our 2nd or 3rd round picks if the Dockers aren't happy with that then they can keep him or trade him to another club if he wants to return to Victoria.

Trading a future 1st is an absolute fool's game. Trading it in our present situation is really asking for trouble. Look at Collingwood's currant predicament - I'm certain when they traded their 2021 1st they weren't planning on it being worth in excess of 2000 points, which is looking likely. They were entitled to think they'd be competing for finals this season and would only be handing over Pick 10-12, not potentially Pick 2.

There's nothing to suggest that we'll suddenly rebound and perform better next year - the melts on here if we've had a poor 2022 and won't even get our Pick 3-6 would be cataclysmic, especially if Cerra is underperforming. If we really want the bloke, which is fine by me, then trade for him from what we know we have, our 2021 picks. Let's not gamble at the moment.

 

[_RT_]

Trading a future 1st is an absolute fool's game. Trading it in our present situation is really asking for trouble. Look at Collingwood's currant predicament - I'm certain when they traded their 2021 1st they weren't planning on it being worth in excess of 2000 points, which is looking likely. They were entitled to think they'd be competing for finals this season and would only be handing over Pick 10-12, not potentially Pick 2.

There's nothing to suggest that we'll suddenly rebound and perform better next year - the melts on here if we've had a poor 2022 and won't even get our Pick 3-6 would be cataclysmic, especially if Cerra is underperforming. If we really want the bloke, which is fine by me, then trade for him from what we know we have, our 2021 picks. Let's not gamble at the moment.

Depends what you're trading for.

Pies traded for unknown kids in a compromised draft, I'm talking about trading for an established talent who should be a 10-12 year player and can play from Round 1 2022. This year we know, as it stands, we have a top 10 pick and a secondary top 20 pick, plus a further 2 picks in the top 30. We can add 4 young kids to the list.

Also the Pies current predicament is because they imploded due to piss poor list management and by overpaying for some bog average footballers chasing a flag. We're not in that situation as far as I can tell. We're unlikely to have a forced sale of some good footballers to ease cap pressure and thus ruin the harmony in the team.

 

[Maurice Mitchell]

We need to look around for someone who can play key back. Look at what guys like Josh Walker and James Stewart

17

James Stewart

Age

30

Ht

199cm

Wt

99kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.4

3star

K

6.8

3star

HB

4.7

3star

M

4.1

4star

T

1.9

4star

MG

193.5

3star

No current season stats available

D

12.4

4star

K

7.0

3star

HB

5.4

4star

M

3.8

4star

T

0.8

3star

MG

200.4

4star

are doing. Don't need superstars.

 

[Bojangles17]

Would rather Riccardi if we're going down that path.

No way , looks a vfl forward to me

I beg your pardon?! Sam weideman makes egg look courageous.

6 years in and averages 1 goal a game. Shocking footballer. If we trade for him I'll cancel my membership.

Being outrageous