Player Watch Fischer McAsey - Steps Away from Football, Not Returning

Do you think Fischer McAsey will be at the AFC in 2022?


  • Total voters
    52
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

If we had those attributes he'd be an AA standard key back.
The rumours about his off field issues must be really difficult.
Clearly he hasn't developed them consistently to the AFL level yet but he still has those ability which made him the best KPD of his draft year and in the first few games of 2020 we saw his one grab contested marking ability.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Three years in, the guy can barely get a touch in the SANFL, has no obvious elite physical traits, and is being comfortably outperformed by a terrible rejected forward and a guy we took as a supplementary rookie

His reading of the ball in the air today was woeful and then he is even worse when the ball hits the ground
 
Mcasey seems to be coming good imo. Might want to wait til end of contract yet.

Butts looked sore today and for the last few so he might get an opportunity up a grade sooner than later if he's in form
 
If Frampton continues his form for the rest of the year, surely we’ll look at trading him on.

Realistically what could we expect in return for him?

Not a lot of point trading him at this stage. We're not going to get anything in return. At this stage the best bet is to just let him play his contract out and hope for a miracle.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Mcasey seems to be coming good imo. Might want to wait til end of contract yet.

Butts looked sore today and for the last few so he might get an opportunity up a grade sooner than later if he's in form
Yeah, he’s been much better lately without being a standout.

It’s not much, but his attitude seems to have improved and he doesn’t seem to be falling over as much.

Unfortunately still behind Murray, Borlase and Worrell though.
 
Have to remember he is a young body still. With another proper preseason he should continue to improve
If Billy Framptons game on the weekend is a testimony for anything, it's that patience with young KPP's is critical. There's no secret formula for fast tracking them, or achieving success.

Some just take time.
 
If Billy Framptons game on the weekend is a testimony for anything, it's that patience with young KPP's is critical. There's no secret formula for fast tracking them, or achieving success.

Some just take time.
Difference is Frampton was a young key position forward who wasn’t good enough to make it up forward, the switch to the easier position of defender has suited him.

McAsey is a defender struggling to be a defender.

Some also just don’t make it.
 
Difference is Frampton was a young key position forward who wasn’t good enough to make it up forward, the switch to the easier position of defender has suited him.

McAsey is a defender struggling to be a defender.

Some also just don’t make it.
If he can play to the weekends level consistently for a month or so he'll be around the mark

Gotta see that before anything
 
If he can play to the weekends level consistently for a month or so he'll be around the mark

Gotta see that before anything
Look don’t get me wrong, I’d be ecstatic if he makes it and has a huge career with us, just as I would be for any Crows player as I want to win flags.

But I’m just not seeing it in him. Let’s hope he does prove me wrong.
 
Look don’t get me wrong, I’d be ecstatic if he makes it and has a huge career with us, just as I would be for any Crows player as I want to win flags.

But I’m just not seeing it in him. Let’s hope he does prove me wrong.
Probably the biggest disappointment so far this season.

Still has time to prove he is an AFL player, but the signs are worrying if he can't be dominant at sanfl level.
 
Probably the biggest disappointment so far this season.

Still has time to prove he is an AFL player, but the signs are worrying if he can't be dominant at sanfl level.
How many key Defenders are dominant at SANFL level just after turning 21? Dominant is a big ask for a KPP and a kid.
 
How many key Defenders are dominant at SANFL level just after turning 21? Dominant is a big ask for a KPP and a kid.
I didn't mean best in sanfl dominant... but he should be regularly in the best players.

Has he ever been in the best players?

Surely you would be expecting more from him...
 
Back
Top