Remove this Banner Ad

Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood?

Banter threads are not to be taken too seriously. Have fun. Let others have fun.

Who will be better in 2024?


  • Total voters
    512

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Y produce a nonsense outlier scenario?

Charlie kicks plenty of goals, he is a great player.

The point is he gets awarded more technical frees than other key forwards. Which is exactly what the table showed.

TomaHawk, Lynch, Mihocek - insert any key forward name - doesnt get the technical "aka soft frees" that Charlie does.

Walshy provided the actual stats, Charlie has kicked the most goals from frees.
No, the table does not show that Charlie gets more "technical" free kicks than other forwards at all. The only way you can prove this is by going through incident-by-incident and looking at Charlie vs every other forward.
 
Remind me when arguing with posters on a Bigfooty forum correlated to direct bullying of a player who probably doesn't even know Bigfooty exists?
You really need to be informed that anything that is posted on-line is immediately in the public forum, and can be seen by the person whom the comment is about and/or their family members?
 
No, the table does not show that Charlie gets more "technical" free kicks than other forwards at all. The only way you can prove this is by going through incident-by-incident and looking at Charlie vs every other forward.
Which is how 'everyone' has come to the conclusion that Charlie gets more than his fair share if free kicks, in comparison to other forwards in the competition.

But as I have previously stated, those free kicks dry up when it matters most.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Oh look, another poster trying to denigrate a third year AFL player in an effort to feel better about themselves.
LOL must be embarrassing pushing a half stepper as a GOAT...hope you don't feel too bad?
 
No, the table does not show that Charlie gets more "technical" free kicks than other forwards at all. The only way you can prove this is by going through incident-by-incident and looking at Charlie vs every other forward.
You are correct, the table shows Charlie has kicked the most goals from free kicks.

Not surprising as in 2023 he was given 39 free kicks, the most of any key forward.
 
Which is how 'everyone' has come to the conclusion that Charlie gets more than his fair share if free kicks, in comparison to other forwards in the competition.

But as I have previously stated, those free kicks dry up when it matters most.
because 'everyone' who doesn't have this kid playing for them might be envious? - Just a guess.
 
You are correct, the table shows Charlie has kicked the most goals from free kicks.

Not surprising as in 2023 he was given 39 free kicks, the most of any key forward.
Hard to not give 10% of the frees he should be getting Charlie is a true superstar of the game and every defender trying to stop dirties their undies and goes the scrag - everyone knows this - just ask.
 
Which is how 'everyone' has come to the conclusion that Charlie gets more than his fair share if free kicks, in comparison to other forwards in the competition.

But as I have previously stated, those free kicks dry up when it matters most.
Most things you say come back to bite you on the backside and this will as well.
 
You really need to be informed that anything that is posted on-line is immediately in the public forum, and can be seen by the person whom the comment is about and/or their family members?
Oh sort of like you're continual antagonizing regarding Cripps and Walsh never playing finals before last year despite their best efforts? I'm sure their friends and family would have loved reading over the years about how they play for a basket case and would be better off going elsewhere?

Forgive us Nick! We shouldn't have added an 'i' to your name! Please let us pay for your therapy bills 😭
 
Oh sort of like you're continual antagonizing regarding Cripps and Walsh never playing finals before last year despite their best efforts? I'm sure their friends and family would have loved reading over the years about how they play for a basket case and would be better off going elsewhere?

Forgive us Nick! We shouldn't have added an 'i' to your name! Please let us pay for your therapy bills 😭
As I have said, I have never denigrated individual players as it is akin to on-line bullying.
 
We are indeed envious of the preferential treatment he gets from umpires.

Collingwood supporters are generally envious about everything Carlton - so no surprises - you keep fudging your abacus though I hear playing with beads is a comforting pastime.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Which is how 'everyone' has come to the conclusion that Charlie gets more than his fair share if free kicks, in comparison to other forwards in the competition.

But as I have previously stated, those free kicks dry up when it matters most.
Ah yes by everyone I assume all those "neutral" supporters
 
You are correct, the table shows Charlie has kicked the most goals from free kicks.

Not surprising as in 2023 he was given 39 free kicks, the most of any key forward.
It shows that Curnow does not rely on free kicks to score his goals given that he has the most goals since 2022 when you take away those from free kicks.
 
Collingwood supporters are generally envious about everything Carlton - so no surprises - you keep fudging your abacus though I hear playing with beads is a comforting pastime.
Yeah, of course we are, starting with Carlton's solo Preliminary Final appearance in the past two decades, and ending with your envious Adelaide Oval streak that will likely continue this weekend.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Using Fadges logic - If the Carlton supporters all resoundingly think Fadge is a denigrating troll then he must be... Thats how it work right?
I think you will find it isnt just Carlton supporters who know he is a troll .... only have to read the kidGOAT thread to see he is universally recognised as a stirrer
 
Using Fadges logic - If the Carlton supporters all resoundingly think Fadge is a denigrating troll then he must be... Thats how it work right?
FudgeyWudgey makeyuppy is teh technical term for the condition.
 
Yeah, of course we are, starting with Carlton's solo Preliminary Final appearance in the past two decades, and ending with your envious Adelaide Oval streak that will likely continue this weekend.
Oh dear Carlton might lose a game this week ...the world will come to an end!!!

Still - I guess the "possibility" is some comfort to Juan ...any port in a storm.
 
Yeah, of course we are, starting with Carlton's solo Preliminary Final appearance in the past two decades, and ending with your envious Adelaide Oval streak that will likely continue this weekend.
Oops back to the past

Somewhat not surprising that you rather talk about past events rather than 2024, as basing your predictions on the past have failed you countless times
 
Oops back to the past

Somewhat not surprising that you rather talk about past events rather than 2024, as basing your predictions on the past have failed you countless times
Would be a massive thread starter on teh Main Board: " All the predictions that Fudgey has got wrong" - would go on and on for pages and pages- just the FACTS - mind you no need for embellishment fudgyewudgeystyle - but I guess holding people to account is against Board rules?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top