2012 'Which rookie do I start on the field?' thread

[Jimmy1992]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Do i go with Magner, Shiel or Wingard on my field?
Leaning towards Magner against the Dogs.

 

[GOAUS!]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Do i go with Magner, Shiel or Wingard on my field?
Leaning towards Magner against the Dogs.

Has to be Magner for mine, 2 good games so far, one downer (still scored 61) so I'm sticking with him over Shiel who has been down and up so far, Wingard has been fairly mediocre too.

 

[Jbomb967]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Do i go with Magner, Shiel or Wingard on my field?
Leaning towards Magner against the Dogs.

Yep, definitely Magner against the dogs...

 

[IDIG]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Looking ok this week, can't really complain with what's happened so far. Ended up going with -
B: Bugg 83, Mohr 74 (Morris*, Ellis)
M: Shiel 69. Magner (JMac 78*, CSmith)
F: Kennedy 40 (DSmith 55*, Hall 54)

As long as Magner can score 60+ wouldn't have lost too many points this week.

 

[MightyMark]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Looking ok this week, can't really complain with what's happened so far. Ended up going with -
B: Bugg 83, Mohr 74 (Morris*, Ellis)
M: Shiel 69. Magner (JMac 78*, CSmith)
F: Kennedy 40 (DSmith 55*, Hall 54)

As long as Magner can score 60+ wouldn't have lost too many points this week.

You should buy a lotto ticket, haha, 62 is cuttuing it fine.

I was pretty disappointed with A. Kennedy, D. Smith and Hall this week. Shouldn’t be too much to ask for rookies to get at least 60.

 

[IDIG]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Yeah im almost at the stage where im gonna fade myself and just go the opposite of what i usually would. Drives me crazy.

 

[MightyMark]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Yeah im almost at the stage where im gonna fade myself and just go the opposite of what i usually would. Drives me crazy.

Yeah, I know the feeling.

I've given up trying to make educated decisions, looking at the fixtures, previous scores and stats, in and outs, etc. All those things that seemed to give the avid SC player a little advantage have been replaced by a coin flip.

And what happens? My best score for the last few weeks. It's depressing, all that time spent researching, when I could have achieved more by flipping a coin.

 

[IDIG]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Yeah, I know the feeling.

I've given up trying to make educated decisions, looking at the fixtures, previous scores and stats, in and outs, etc. All those things that seemed to give the avid SC player a little advantage have been replaced by a coin flip.

And what happens? My best score for the last few weeks. It's depressing, all that time spent researching, when I could have achieved more by flipping a coin.

Haha this. I'll give the coin a shot cos I couldnt do any worse

 

[Seppo]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Who should I leave on the bench as emergency?
MID: Shiel OR Coniglio
FWD: Kennedy OR Trelor OR Smedts

 

[MightyMark]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Who should I leave on the bench as emergency?
MID: Shiel OR Coniglio
FWD: Kennedy OR Trelor OR Smedts

Sheil over Coniglio
Trelor over Smedts (Kennedy isn't playing)

 

[TheBuzz]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Magner or Old Mac for my last midfield spot?

Leaning towards Mac for no good reason.

Can anyone assure me that Magner won't have another tagging job this week?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Magner or Old Mac for my last midfield spot?

Leaning towards Mac for no good reason.

Can anyone assure me that Magner won't have another tagging job this week?

Go the Old Mac!

for me Bugg or Hargrave to start in the backline?

 

[rocker_oz33]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Go the Old Mac!

for me Bugg or Hargrave to start in the backline?

Thats interesting one.Both those players each other will the ball be down the western bulldogs end bugg to get abit of the pill.Or will hargrave get heaps of ball mmm l would go hardgrave.

mitsubishi manger V d shiel? dont know is manger is now/still a tagger?

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Thats interesting one.Both those players each other will the ball be down the western bulldogs end bugg to get abit of the pill.Or will hargrave get heaps of ball mmm l would go hardgrave.

mitsubishi manger V d shiel? dont know is manger is now/still a tagger?

Want to know the exact same thing Rocker so i am not much help unfortunately! Both who to choose out of Magner and Shiel and also what role will Magner more than likely do this coming weekend?

 

[TheBuzz]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Go the Old Mac!

for me Bugg or Hargrave to start in the backline?

Dont know enough about hargrave, but the Bugg has been solid as a rock & have no reason to doubt that will continue.

Will Magner get a tagging job? It seems entirely possible, so I think I'll be benching him this week.

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

i'd go Magner on field over Shiel.

Magner is mature aged and Shiel is still finding his feet at AFL level

 

[Feerits Elf]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Correct me if I'm wrong, but haven't Magner and Shiel played an identical number of AFL games?

 

[Marlowe]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Smith or Trealor? Who'll score more?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Treloar is a gun!

 

[themightybloods]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

I have to play 2 out of d.smith, pfeiffer and smedts

I am also worried due to the possibility that they will be the sub

Any ideas?

 

[IDIG]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Is everyone just starting all their GWS and GC players this week??

I’m running with -
Bugg, Mohr (Morris, Ellis)
Treloar, Horsley (Magner, JMac)
Giles (Renouf)
Kennedy, DSmith (Milera, Hall)

Including Ablett that would make 8!

 

[MightyMark]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Is everyone just starting all their GWS and GC players this week??

I’m running with -
Bugg, Mohr (Morris, Ellis)
Treloar, Horsley (Magner, JMac)
Giles (Renouf)
Kennedy, DSmith (Milera, Hall)

Including Ablett that would make 8!

I'll be playing all but Horsley. Have a feeling he may be the sub. Its out of Horsley and Smith to start over Magner this week, and after last weeks game, I cant see Smith getting subbed.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Mohr struggles in the easy ones. Loves it tight and tough, so not starting for me.

Got Horsley starting with Greene on the bench.

Giles starting ruck

Smith, Treloar, Adams starting in Fwds, with Milera and hall on the bench.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

I'll be playing all but Horsley. Have a feeling he may be the sub. Its out of Horsley and Smith to start over Magner this week, and after last weeks game, I cant see Smith getting subbed.

GC don't do the same sub rotation as GWS. Horsey won't be sub.

 

[IDIG]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

I'll be playing all but Horsley. Have a feeling he may be the sub. Its out of Horsley and Smith to start over Magner this week, and after last weeks game, I cant see Smith getting subbed.

Hmm i did notice that both Horsley and Adams were named last on their respective benches. Scary stuff. Pretty rough on a bloke who;s had so much of the pill the last fortnight to get vested though but stranger things have happened i guess.