got the lotto numbers for me?-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 10
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 9 Winner: philreich
List Mgmt. 2013 Trading & Free Agency
- Thread starter DJ75
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
got the lotto numbers for me?
Sorry mate, fat fingers on the touch pad
Personally I can't see him leaving unless the club was offered something to good to refuse. Loves adelaide and is a perfect replacement for Thompson.
I actually don't mind him, he has a bit of white line fever however he just needs to learn to control his aggression
No doubt that his development has stalled however MFC doesn't exactly have a good record at player development, personally from the outside it seems that week to week he has had different roles, like most young players he would benefit from being settled into a role
Has a booming leg on him that's for sure
- Jul 25, 2010
- 32,674
- 18,767
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Golden State Warriors NBA Champions
IMO - Not bagging him as I think he is a good player but I don't need Tapscott as Sam Kerridge covers that same sort of role.
However, I'm not sure what Vince and Lyons worth would be.
It's not pick 2 but at the sane time, we would feel very disappointed if we only received pick 20 for both. So, I guess if we received 2 picks between 18 and 22 for both, I guess we could learn to live with that.
Happy about that one
wonder what trades will happen tomorrow, might be another dud day.
Polec trade can't be far off - if Kerr says its currently a dead heat then surely it's time to get it done one way or the other.
We arent going to get pick 2.
I dont really believe Roos will part with it unless its an offer to good to refuse, which will be more than anything we'd be willing to do.
Picks around the 20-30 mark is all we can expect IMO. Hopefully Melbournes pick 20 and another sub 30 pick from somewhere else to pass on to Brisbane for Polec. If Melbourne want Vince and Lyons, then its up to them to get us that other pick.
The only other realistic option IMO is Wright to the Lions for Polec, and we keep the 2 picks for the draft.
I dont really believe Roos will part with it unless its an offer to good to refuse, which will be more than anything we'd be willing to do.
Picks around the 20-30 mark is all we can expect IMO. Hopefully Melbournes pick 20 and another sub 30 pick from somewhere else to pass on to Brisbane for Polec. If Melbourne want Vince and Lyons, then its up to them to get us that other pick.
The only other realistic option IMO is Wright to the Lions for Polec, and we keep the 2 picks for the draft.
It's not a matter of thinking you know better, it's identifying errors at selection before the game and stating your opinion. If the selectors then eventually make those changes it fair to say you were right and they were wrong. Example, picking underdone Petrenko and Callinan and then watching them stink and be dropped. Picking Jaensch towards the end of the season when he was stinking and then he was dropped.
Just because they are selectors doesn't make them always correct or do you believe selectors get it right every time? Because they don't, they've admitted mistakes this year.
Melb may have another 2nd rounder after their own for Sylvia compo, so they'll have 2 to trade. If Crows could get both of those for Vince + Lyons and #42 if needed, they could send the higher pick to Brisbane for Polec and keep the other one to draft a player, which means they could keep Henderson too.
I think thats about right, although my guess is Matt Wright is now good to go to Brisvegas. So we use those 2 second rounders for kids unless there is someone else on the boil we know nothing about. Leaves McKernan to get us something for Edwards and Hendo to get us a decent pick or stay
I think they were a disaster this year and made a number of blatantly obvious mistakes. In general, no, in a number of instances this year? Absolutely.
EC said it well as well.
Sounds good to me.
if we end up with pick 2 somehow i would be very happy
The answer was always going to be yes.
Not sure what to make of him to be honest. He showed flashes during the MMC at the beginning of the year then disappeared completely off the radar. Not writing him off but also not holding any great expectations.
KE makes my posting look humble.
I'm wrong about a lot of stuff, frequently, but every now and again, I'm not too far off the mark.
To be fair, they didn't exactly cover themselves in glory and set a high standard this year - it's a pretty low bar
CEY was always a project - finished this year quite strongly.
To be fair, they didn't exactly cover themselves in glory and set a high standard this year - it's a pretty low bar
CEY was always a project - finished this year quite strongly.
I don't pass judgement on a player until I think I have enough information to make an informed decision.
There is plenty of data on Lyons, little of it pointing to success. On the other hand there is little data on CEY and what there is is often conflicted, hence my statement that I am yet to form an opinion on him.
He had a very good last part of the season with the eagles. Could be a surprise addition to our backline next year if Hendo goes.
I don't pass judgement on a player until I think I have enough information to make an informed decision.
There is plenty of data on Lyons, little of it pointing to success. On the other hand there is little data on CEY and what there is is often conflicted, hence my statement that I am yet to form an opinion on him.
- Status
