List Mgmt. 2015 Draft, Trades and Retirements Thread Pt 1

[swannyfan]

Should just go hard for hendo or yarran , spend the 450 on one of them and get jamar for one year and end of next yesr get a ruck when ban lifted

I'd take hendo in a heartbeat - like carlisle, backs himself to outmark the opposition. At his best, repels everything. Also very capable up forward should tippo/buddy go down. Unfortunately, thought he was a done deal with Cats?

Would love inclusion of Yarran also, closest like for like with Jetta and be the only player who could regularly hit our forwards through traffic.

Add Jamar (a dominant ruckman few yrs back) for 1yr, and one would feel we'd have the depth/missing links to be right up there again.

 

[Grongey]

I'd target, in order
...Come home Kirky.

Wow that was quick! Good appointment, Kirk is a leader. Bloods spirit.

Brett Kirk returns to Sydney Swans as part of coaching panel - September 27, 2015 - 8:17PM
Champion Sydney Swan Brett Kirk is returning to the AFL club as a member of their coaching panel for 2016...
Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/afl/sydney-sw...hing-panel-20150927-gjw2mt.html#ixzz3myRtwAYL

 

[Grongey]

Yarran would be fun to land. I've posted on that before....

I'd take Bennell before Yarran.

 

[Tuco]

I'd take Bennell before Yarran.

Many would, massive upside to Harley if we landed him for sure.

Looks like his interest is going to push him well north of $500k a year, though.

 

[swansfan51]

Forget upside with Bennell, right now with no further improvement he is one of the most dominant attacking midfielders in the league.

 

[Tuco]

It's simply the upside of pulling his professional life together vs the downside of his indiscipline leading him to the scrap heap.

His talent as a player in unquestionable.

 

[bedford]

Can't understand any love for Yarren

 

[swansfan51]

It's simply the upside of pulling his professional life together vs the downside of his indiscipline leading him to the scrap heap.

His talent as a player in unquestionable.

Again, right now with no improvement in his professional life he is good enough to be one of our best players. If he can do whatever he does in his own time and still pull out a 27 disposal, 6 goal, 3 Brownlow vote game against a top side then that works for me.

 

[tizzay7]

Clarke extends his stay with freo. Phew! Now he isnt an option for us if there was any interest at all. Close call on that one. Do not want.

 

[RW]

Again, right now with no improvement in his professional life he is good enough to be one of our best players. If he can do whatever he does in his own time and still pull out a 27 disposal, 6 goal, 3 Brownlow vote game against a top side then that works for me.

Assuming you were in Kinnear's shoes, what would you give up to get him?

 

[Cadsky]

Ive heard Luey has nominated Freo and swans have now put a deal in frontof Smith from GC. Also St Kilda have offered us Ahmed Saad for Craig Bird. If they pacjaged him with a second or third round pick id take that deal. Saad would be the small forward we desperately need!

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Ive heard Luey has nominated Freo and swans have now put a deal in frontof Smith from GC. Also St Kilda have offered us Ahmed Saad for Craig Bird. If they pacjaged him with a second or third round pick id take that deal. Saad would be the small forward we desperately need!

Serious?

 

[bedford]

I told you about Zac Smith. St. Kilda have offered us nothing ! Bird will go to Brisbane. I don't know who Luey is, we used to call Dale Lewis something like that

 

[GotTheGoodes]

I told you about Zac Smith. St. Kilda have offered us nothing ! Bird will go to Brisbane. I don't know who Luey is, we used to call Dale Lewis something like that

And LRT.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

And LRT.

Did we used to call him Luey? lol cant remember.

 

[BarneyBent]

Did we used to call him Luey? lol cant remember.

Luey Robby-Tommy.

 

[bedford]

Did we used to call him Luey? lol cant remember.

Probably Lewey, but he was one of ours, not someone from another club who has no association with us

 

[RUNVS]

Ive heard Luey has nominated Freo and swans have now put a deal in frontof Smith from GC. Also St Kilda have offered us Ahmed Saad for Craig Bird. If they pacjaged him with a second or third round pick id take that deal. Saad would be the small forward we desperately need!

Saad would not be a bad choice. At least he is a reliable kick at goal and does provide another target up forward.

 

[bedford]

Saad would not be a bad choice. At least he is a reliable kick at goal and does provide another target up forward.

Can't get a kick in one of the worst teams, would still rather Schneider back than that hack

 

[RW]

Can't get a kick in one of the worst teams, would still rather Schneider back than that hack

He can't even get a game with them. Only managed 4 games for the Saints this year.

 

[Punts]

Lol saad

 

[bedford]

He can't even get a game with them. Only managed 4 games for the Saints this year.

WTFDWFT !

 

[RUNVS]

Can't get a kick in one of the worst teams, would still rather Schneider back than that hack

In 2012 though he was averaging 1.8 goals a game. That is pretty good for a small forward, especially in the forward line he was in at the time.

 

[Punts]

10 mil for 6 years the reported offer to danger ( nickname cause I can ) from the dees

 

[SilentHunter_]

10 mil for 6 years the reported offer to danger ( nickname cause I can ) from the dees

Roosy's been busy.