Autopsy 2016 Brownlow Medal - Winner: P. Dangerfield

[Coaster2012]

Nice try at what? I didn't even qualify it as fact - hence the phrase "I'm guessing"

You tried to guess the right answer.

Hence the phrase "nice try".

What don't you understand?

 

[DangerSloane]

Prove it! I doubt I ever commented on Danger before he joined Geelong.

Yeah ok mate, thats what they all say.

 

[skilts]

Yeah ok mate, thats what they all say.

Not quite. There are those who choose to say nothing at all. I'm guessing few of those post on here.

 

[Sttew]

Yeah ok mate, thats what they all say.

Just because that is your modus operandi doesn't mean everyone is the same

 

[Gavin Excell]

So how did Bartel win it?
Swan?
Judd?
Cousins?

Maybe this year lines up with your analysis but it's pretty hard to make a case that it is a rule of thumb.

When so many exceptions exist the rule becomes questionable

 

[DangerSloane]

Just because that is your modus operandi doesn't mean everyone is the same

Actually no, all the geelong supporters I know didn't rate danger nearly as much as they do now, and still wouldnt if he hadnt joined Geelong.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Actually no, all the geelong supporters I know didn't rate danger nearly as much as they do now, and still wouldnt if he hadnt joined Geelong.

Because he has got even better.

 

[SterlingArcher]

When was the last time a player won every award possible? (of course excluding norm smith, coleman etc)

Ablett 09 the only other one to do the Brownlow-AFLCA MVP-Leigh Matthews Trophy trifecta.

 

[DangerSloane]

Because he has got even better.

Its honestly not that much.
The reason he won the brownlow by so much is lack of midfield depth for Geelong and the fact that the other two best players in the comp were out for the year.

He was the best player this year by a mile, but cats fans were ripping in over the first half of his career.