List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

[kangaanth]

Melbourne	Daniel Harris	160 (149)	46	28
2001		North Melbourne	Ashley Watson	7	1	0
2002		Melbourne	Daniel Bell	66	1	3
2003		Adelaide	Fergus Watts	6 (5)	3	0
2004		Essendon	Angus Monfries	211 (150)	248	14
2005		Hawthorn	Grant Birchall	264 (248)	34	22	AA: 2012; AA40: 2011; Prem: 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015
2006		Adelaide	James Sellar	44 (21)	14	0
2007		Melbourne	Jack Grimes	100	11	9
2008	FS	Western Bulldogs	Ayce Cordy	27	15	0
2009		Sydney	Lewis Jetta	202 (127)	116	8	AA40: 2012; Prem: 2012, 2018
2010		Adelaide	Brodie Smith	183	62	16	AA: 2014
2011		GWS	Devon Smith	154 (109)	127	18	B&F: 2018; AA40: 2018
2012	Comp	GWS	Aidan Corr	98	2	0
2013		GWS	Cameron McCarthy	70 (21)	99	4
2014		Adelaide	Jake Lever	92 (56)	3	2	AA40: 2017
2015	Qld Zone	Brisbane	Eric Hipwood	94	137	15
2016	NSW Zone	GWS	Harry Perryman	52	15	4
2017		Sydney	Matt Ling	3	0	0
2018		GWS	Jackson Hately	13	2	0
2019		Port Adelaide	Miles Bergman

 

[kangaanth]

Last 20 pick 14’s. I’d rather the 3 second rounders.

 

[Hatchy1992]

draft in Tackleberry for some midfield pressure or is he too similar to Zurhaar? Hightower as a rookie ruckman??

Hightower might take a few years to develop but well worth the investment.

 

[Star]

yes. unreservedly. they love their club the same way we love ours and i don't want to see any more clubs thrown on the bonfire of capitalist expansion.

Thats very magnanimous.

I won’t have sympathy if the reckless actions of a few cowboys inside that club ultimately result in their demise.

 

[koshari]

If our off-season consists of

+ Stephenson, Young, Corr, #2, #11, #14, and whichever of Cameron/Caldwell/whoever else doesn't get done in the PSD at #2
- Higgins, Brown, delistees

...huge wins IMO

Could we possibly win trade week? :sternlook

 

[Boro]

The Stephenson trade looks like a typical North bashing set up to me, with the added bonus of him being a Pies player to generate clicks.

He'll stay...and the media can have another go at us for missing a big fish...this time tomorrow we would have offered him 750x6 to come and Damo and co can have a good laugh at our expense...paranoid? me? No way

 

[koshari]

Too soon?

View attachment 1008921

Never to soon to use the giff

 

[NewNorth]

Stephenson has talent, but also comes with issues, which I reckon we (the public) know very little about. We cannot overpay for him, Collingwood are pushing him out the door, so we shouldn't be looking to offer anything of real value for him. I am thinking a minor pick upgrade for Collingwood should suffice. Something similar to the Dan Hannerbry trade from a few years ago.
In terms of the contract, lets not give him something long term on big money, would put others offside, particularly the likes of Jed (who still hasn't signed, any updates???) and the young guys coming out of contract in the near future.

He may be a bust, he could also be a steal, thus we should pay and compensate Collingwood accordingly. Remember, we are still in a rebuild!!!!

 

[king rising]

Disaster written all over it

 

[Snake_Baker]

The Stephenson trade looks like a typical North bashing set up to me, with the added bonus of him being a Pies player to generate clicks.

He'll stay...and the media can have another go at us for missing a big fish...this time tomorrow we would have offered him 750x6 to come and Damo and co can have a good laugh at our expense...paranoid? me? No way

He might not end up at North, but I don't reckon he's staying.

The Pies are in a desperate situation, and their management is behaving appallingly.

 

[shinboner magic]

Montagna said on fox footy trade wrap - that Stephenson might be the most talented player out of 2017 top ten draft.

LDU , cerra and Clark say hi

 

[DrZaius]

Could we possibly win trade week? :sternlook

Nah mate pick 8 for Saad!! The media will somehow split it that * & Carlton are both the winners :sternlook

 

[1975]

$850k for 3 and trigger for 4 but he wanted 4 years straight

 

[Moti]

Montagna said on fox footy trade wrap - that Stephenson might be the most talented player out of 2017 top ten draft.

LDU , cerra and Clark say hi

I can’t believe anyone chose Montagna to be on television


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Rod Stroker]

As does a former meteorologist

He's still a meteorologist

 

[barnrokn]

No he's a wingmen. We'd be only looking to get Pick 2.

 

[Star]

He's still a meteorologist

True.

And he still dislikes it.

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Second round pick for Stephenson

I love the reporter scoffing at a club like North picking Stephenson up for a second rounder and insisting that the pies deserve better.

 

[The acurate one]

Not to quote myself , but I suggest Higgins is gone and two posts later - he out!! No wonder I'm " the acurate one". Just sayin.

 

[giantroo]

Essendon will consider potential pick swaps with Collingwood and Geelong in a bid to help unlock deals for Western Bulldogs’ midfielder Josh Dunkley and GWS Giants Jye Caldwell before the trade deadline.

The Bombers have picks No. 6, No. 7 and No. 8 and have discussed swapping one of them for Collingwood’s pick 16 and the Magpies’ future first-round selection.

The deal would mean Essendon would have pick No. 16 to trade to Greater Western Sydney for Caldwell and then multiple first-round picks in this year’s draft and next year’s draft in the talks for Dunkley.


Collingwood star Adam Treloar is also weighing up a move to the kennel but the Bulldogs are yet to commit to the onball jet.

Magpie Jaidyn Stephenson is considering a move to North Melbourne but Tom Phillips is likely to stay put.

The Bulldogs have remained coy about whether they want linebreaker Treloar, 27, and are adamant the Dunkley deal is completely separate despite the likelihood of a straight midfield swap.

The Bulldogs want two first-round picks in exchange for Dunkley, 23, but former Carlton list boss Stephen Silvagni warned that was too much to pay for the clearance winner.

“I’m not too sure they’re going to get two first-round picks for Dunkley,” Silvagni said on Trade Radio on Wednesday.


“I think they will get a really good first-round pick. Whether that is pick No. 6, No. 7 or No. 8, and whether the Bombers are going to have to give up something else as well.”

 

[Harris 10]

I can’t believe anyone chose Montagna to be on television


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Not sure about his Stephenson comment, but I rate Montagna higher than just about all of them on Fox.

He’s a good operator.

 

[The acurate one]

Bye Higgo. Enjoy Geelong!

man I work with Geelong types , I'm their manager and I'll say they are all flat earthers and paranoid. Have a chip on their shoulder and are poor mans South Australians!! Yep I went there.

 

[G0ther00s]

A Collingwood poster

‘Can we include our 2021 first round pick and Curtis Taylor?’

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Stephenson has talent, but also comes with issues, which I reckon we (the public) know very little about. We cannot overpay for him, Collingwood are pushing him out the door, so we shouldn't be looking to offer anything of real value for him. I am thinking a minor pick upgrade for Collingwood should suffice. Something similar to the Dan Hannerbry trade from a few years ago.
In terms of the contract, lets not give him something long term on big money, would put others offside, particularly the likes of Jed (who still hasn't signed, any updates???) and the young guys coming out of contract in the near future.

He may be a bust, he could also be a steal, thus we should pay and compensate Collingwood accordingly. Remember, we are still in a rebuild!!!!

I'm not sold on Stephenson either. The point about his salary is a valid one, I'm always a little nervous bringing players in on big $ when our existing group are trying to squeeze out (and deserving of) a better deal. The problem is, he has the contract at Collingwood so he's not going to take a pay cut to leave.

It means that either:

(1) we take him off their hands and pay him similar (so, the $500k / 5 years looks in the ball park). This should be for a 3rd round pick at best, as taking his contract out is doing them a big favour and helping them dig out of the mess. Why should we do that for them?

(2) the alternative is to contract him for less and make Collingwood pay the difference. This is attractive, but for the downside of having to use a higher pick to get the deal done.

Not sure I'd be pushing hard to do either of these deals, tbh.

 

[WD Roo]

Hightower might take a few years to develop but well worth the investment.

Bit hard when he has been dead for nearly ten years.