Aaron Davey or Andrew Walker

[willydave]

Who's the better footballer?
Aaron Davey

Who will be the better footballer?
Andrew Walker

Who do you like more?
Aaron Davey

Who do you think is the most likely to win the Rising Star?
Jared Rivers (easily)

 

[leonmagic]

Originally posted by Deestroy

Who do you like more?
Aaron Davey

WTF??


I like David King more than Aaron Davey AND Andrew Walker, that means nothing when comparing them though...

To be honest, it's 6 games V's 2 - so you have to go with Davey as he has runs on the board, in a better side.

Time will tell, but for what it's worth I can't see too many players being better than Walker in 4-6 years.

 

[still rocking]

im a melbourne fan...

but walker is and will be a far better player than davey!!

he will be able to kill the mid-field ina few years time, as where davey is just a small forward!!

davey is fantastic, dont get me wrong... but walker will be a superstar!!

btw, neither will win the rising star, thats jared rivers's trophy!!

 

[electricsix]

davey=poor mans cupido

walker= future champion

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by electricsix
davey=poor mans cupido

by saying that you are inferring that Cupido is a better footballe than Aaron Davey,

Surely you jest

 

[electricsix]

get back to me when davey kicks 5 in a game

cupido is twice the player of davey.

stronger a better mark and a much better kick on both feet.

get over davey mate his not in cupidos league

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by electricsix
get back to me when davey kicks 5 in a game

cupido is twice the player of davey.

stronger a better mark and a much better kick on both feet.

get over davey mate his not in cupidos league

Cupido = goal hungry, one dimensional, showpony, individual

Davey = smart, team player, hard worker, gets teammates involved


Electricsix - have you ever heard of one-percenters, ie. chasing,tackling, smothers.. Cos I know Cupido sure as hell hasnt.

Aaron Davey gets as excited whether its a smother, or kicking a freakish goal

 

[rORy=)]

Originally posted by electricsix
get back to me when davey kicks 5 in a game

Won't be long mate, if he'd kicked straight he'd have done it already.

Too early to tell, but I think Davey's gonna **** on Cupido in terms of talent.

 

[electricsix]

cupido lead essendon in goal assists last year

not a team player?

grow up guys.

 

[leonmagic]

Originally posted by electricsix
cupido lead essendon in goal assists last year

not a team player?

grow up guys.

Funny how people run when it's been proven that they have no idea....


Yze_Maigic???








Hello???

 

[TheHeatleyStand]

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
Cupido = goal hungry, one dimensional, showpony, individual

Davey = smart, team player, hard worker, gets teammates involved


Electricsix - have you ever heard of one-percenters, ie. chasing,tackling, smothers.. Cos I know Cupido sure as hell hasnt.

Aaron Davey gets as excited whether its a smother, or kicking a freakish goal

*LOL*

óut of interest Yze are you 12 yet?

Just to state some obvious differences in Walkers favour.
Davey cant mark.Walker can mark overhead
Davey cant kick with his right foot Walker kicks both
Davey cant play more than one position., Walker can play and has played everywhere.
Davey is not accountable. Walker is also a gun defender.
Davey no endurance. Walker won the draft camp distance trial. and was second in the beep test by a bees proverbial
Davey is 4 years older.

 

[lamby29]

Originally posted by TheHeatleyStand

Davey is not accountable.

You are an idiot.

 

[Demonheart]

Originally posted by TheHeatleyStand
[BJust to state some obvious differences in Walkers favour.
Davey cant mark.Walker can mark overhead
Davey cant kick with his right foot Walker kicks both
Davey cant play more than one position., Walker can play and has played everywhere.
Davey is not accountable. Walker is also a gun defender.
Davey no endurance. Walker won the draft camp distance trial. and was second in the beep test by a bees proverbial
Davey is 4 years older. [/B]

So you are saying that Davey can't mark, no right foot kicking ability, can only play one position, not accountable and has no endurance.

How Pagan would love to have such a crap player in his team considering some of the great players he picked up in the draft.

 

[flamethrower]

Davey or Walker? I'd take Walker.


But I prefer Cameron Faulkner over Davey (easily)

and Adam Cooney over Walker (just).

 

[marcuz]

Originally posted by rORy=)
Won't be long mate, if he'd kicked straight he'd have done it already.

Too early to tell, but I think Davey's gonna **** on Cupido in terms of talent.

Damian may lack a few things but he doesnt lack talent. Thats probably a reason he was pick 5 in the 99 draft.

Cupido is just as fast, stronger, better in the air and can actually use his opposite foot. Davey looks an exciting prospect but at the moment thats all he is.

 

[Stegelator]

Andrew Walker...just.

 

[Jimmae]

Originally posted by Yze_Magic
by saying that you are inferring that Cupido is a better footballe than Aaron Davey,

Surely you jest

Six games... settle.

 

[Yze_Magic]

Originally posted by leonmagic
Funny how people run when it's been proven that they have no idea....


Yze_Maigic???








Hello???

Uhh yes?

 

[TheHeatleyStand]

Originally posted by lamby29
You are an idiot.

i wonder if he will ever play in the back pocket.
Then we can see who the idiot is.

YEah, im saying all those things Yze, you didnt say how old you are.

Yeah Pagan needs a crumber thats for sure.Davey would be a handy player but you cant build a side around Davey now can you???

As for forward pockets many start off and fizzle out , we will have to see about his longevity.
Barring injury you can just see Walker will play 12 years at least cant you???

Ask any coach who they would prefer i doubt any would choose Davey over Walker.

 

[Destructive]

Aaron Davey.

 

[Dunstall_Jr]

walker by a country mile.