GreyCrow
TheBrownDog
- Mar 21, 2016
- 74,566
- 118,407
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, White Sox
Or KlugCan't select Romano Negri. Waste of time.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Or KlugCan't select Romano Negri. Waste of time.
Check Stevens' Best & Fairest ratingsI guess it's your list.
But for the record, Stevens' best two years (01-02) he kicked a combined 59 goals.
Tippett with 101 across 2009-10
Smart was a good player but Burton wasn't nearly consistent enough to make this teamWe don't have a lot of out and out wingmen. Plonked Sloane and Edwards there just to get them into the team but they hardly played there. Mattner 2005 and Tregenza 1993 our only proper ones? Seedsman 2021
No Caven or Bock made CHB difficult. Made the Talia vs Rutten call easier though.
Second ruck tricky but Pitiful Pittman's versatility won me over
F Betts Modra Walker
HF D Jarman M Stevens Burton
C Edwards Dangerfield Sloane
HB McLeod Talia Smart
B Hart Rutten Johncock
1R Rehn Ricciuto Goodwin
INT Thompson Porplyzia Bassett Pittman
Looking at a few line ups has Birdbrain & Notso's admin careers affected their standing as players?
Over who as a genuine forward or half forward?Smart was a good player but Burton wasn't nearly consistent enough to make this team
Over who as a genuine forward or half forward?
I've picked most of those guysJarman, Modra, Betts, Walker, Tippett, Welsh all ahead, there's probably a few others.
He's more in the Jenkins, Porplyzia, Lynch tier
Dangerfield would get a game on half forward as well in this team given the strength of the midfield options
No current season stats available
Scott Camporeale likes this
No current season stats available
Jenkins and Porps do not fit in a tier together.He's more in the Jenkins, Porplyzia, Lynch tier
Jenkins and Porps do not fit in a tier together.
In terms of talent, Porplyzia was the better player, but he really only had a couple of good seasons (08-09), beyond that he was inconsistent and struggled with injury.
Jenkins was less talented but surprisingly consistent. People sh*t on his Joe the Goose goals but he managed five 40 goal seasons in a row all averaging 2 goals a game.
Personally I would have them both in a reserves best 22
TBH I find it a little surprising that so many people instinctively put Andrew McLeod on the HBF, when he clearly played his best footy in the middle.
I take nothing away from his time as an Elite HBFer, but if I am choosing the best ever Crows team, A. McLeod is my starting Rover every day of the fricken week!
I have no problem saying he was an elite HBFer, I just think he was an even better midfielder. To put it in perspective if I could choose 1 player to insert into our team today of prime Danger, Roo or Bunji I would take Bunji alllllllll day long!He won his first B&F playing off half back in 1997. As a HBF, he defended like a glove as well as being a wonderful rebounder. He was just elite in any role.
No current season stats available
Would have been an all time great midfielder if not for the bone-on-bone knee issue. His finals cameos were unrivalledTBH I find it a little surprising that so many people instinctively put Andrew McLeod on the HBF, when he clearly played his best footy in the middle.
I take nothing away from his time as an Elite HBFer, but if I am choosing the best ever Crows team, A. McLeod is my starting Rover every day of the fricken week!
Anyone that doesn't have Nigel Smart in their team is bringing personalities into it.
He was our go-to forward line wildcard in finals100% this - watching him stream off the half-back line was a joy to behold. Pretty impressive goalscoring record as well for a guy that played mostly in defence.