As a Melbourne supporter Ray has shown alot more. I would still take Sylvia though simply because he has been hampered by injuries. But...Sylvia is bloody frustrating to watch...he doesnt try and get the ball. He turns his back on the ball..runs in the opposite directions. It looks like he is trying to miss out on the play to avoid stuffing it up. I just feel like giving him a smack on the chops and tell him the start having a bloody crack. He has shown as many bad signs as Brock Mclean has shown good. And Sylvia is in a sling at the moment and doesnt even look like getting better.

