Preview Changes Round 3 vs. Hawthorn

[DylanW]

Thought I'd start this up, curious as to what people are thinking.

For me I'd probably keep it simple and go:

Out: Cordy

In: Campbell/Redpath (depending on VFL form)

Nobody else deserves to be dropped in my opinion, but Hunter/Hrovat/Stevens would have to be close to getting a game.

 

[fargy]

Tough one, think we have to give either Cordy or Redpath a run at it.

If Goodes plays, he can't be sub, would prefer someone quick and manic to play that role.

So I'll say Goodes out/Hrovat in.

 

[Dogsman16]

Thought I'd start this up, curious as to what people are thinking.

For me I'd probably keep it simple and go:

Out: Cordy

In: Campbell/Redpath (depending on VFL form)

Nobody else deserves to be dropped in my opinion, but Hunter/Hrovat/Stevens would have to be close to getting a game.

Out: Cordy

In: Redpath

Tom Boyd's a pretty handy 2nd ruck already and we need to move him around the ground a bit more so I think we strength our structure with Redpath who shouldn't have been dropped in the first place.

 

[Hrovat24]

Out Cordy goodes and grant
In redpath Webb hrovat

 

[Libba39]

Could probably drop Cordy, T.Boyd and Grant but got a feeling there will be no change.

 

[DylanW]

Could probably drop Cordy, T.Boyd and Grant but got a feeling there will be no change.

I was of the same mind about T Boyd, but he got involved a bit more later in the game in the Ruck which impressed me and is deserving of another week imo. You weren't pleased with Grants game? I have only seen the second half. Didn't accumulate but did well off the ball to my viewing.

 

[Dav1d]

Webb &/or Hrovat in

 

[Max Force]

Can't wait to see the doggies play us next week, good luck & congrats on a fine win today.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

OUT: Cordy, Goodes
IN: Redpath, Webb/Hrovat

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Out: Cordy, Goodes
In: Webb, Hrovat

Smaller forward setup until one of Cordy/Campbell/Redpath stand up in the VFL. More numbers through the middle and a greater number of players that can move around at ground level and lay tackles suits our game style more, particularly given that our other tall options just aren't up to it. Webb deserves an opportunity.

Grant holds his spot very barely - another average performance, and another good performance by Dale in the VFL, and he's out.

 

[Doggies_13]

Think Crameri would be close to his last chance was extremely ordinary today yes kicked 2 goals but overall was ordinary.

Out: Cordy Goodes
In: Redpath Webb

 

[cleveland]

Think Crameri would be close to his last chance was extremely ordinary today yes kicked 2 goals but overall was ordinary.

Out: Cordy Goodes
In: Redpath Webb

Probably needed the run the last 2 weeks

 

[Hrovat24]

Can't believe people want grant in next week , he played horrific today

 

[dergert]

Probably on my own here but I'd be dropping Crameri.

 

[Doggies_13]

Probably needed the run the last 2 weeks

Yea that's why I said probably on his last chance another similar game Id expect to see him out

 

[fronkalicious]

Probably on my own here but I'd be dropping Crameri.

Kicked 2 today and had 22 touches last week. He'll get better each week and has an important role in the team. He stays

 

[Libba39]

Probably on my own here but I'd be dropping Crameri.

No, you are not on your own, however I thought he showed a few signs in the second half.

 

[dogzrule]

Out - Cordy, 7th season sorry he wont make it on what i saw today

In - Redpath, shouldnt have been dropped in the first place

Lucky, Grant

 

[cleveland]

How did redpath play today

 

[BorisDawg]

It's hard to make any changes to a winning team but lawd, I'd love to see Hrovat/Hunter/Webb come in.

Agree that Cordy needs to come out, could we swap him for a small and leave Toyd to be the second ruck?

 

[House_of_Dahl]

Possible ins: Redpath, Hrovat, Hunter, Stevens

Possible outs: Cordy, Goodes, Grant

I'd be happy enough with any or all of them next week.

 

[fargy]

I want Hamling to play on Suckling, because when Hamling is finished with Suckling he will be ham

 

[Dav1d]

I want Hamling to play on Suckling, because when Hamling is finished with Suckling he will be ham

uggggggh

what was that

How did redpath play today

apparently poorly/average

 

[fargy]

uggggggh

what was that


apparently poorly/average

Leave me alone I'm drunk

 

[NthBondiDoggies]

Redpath for Ayce - though a shame Redpath did not play well in the practice match

Hrovat for Goodes / just too good to leave out.

Hunter for ????? grant? Thought he was Ok. Probably needs to be Honey even though I don't think Honey Deserves to be dropped - has was very good.

Looking forward to cement playing but not sure who he replaces? We should not forget how good he is.

And then we have Fletch - this guy has something special / a bit more size and watch out.

Then we have the kids coming through - they look great

Questions over Ayce, Stevens ???Puddin, Pearce, And Fuller. At this stage - I think Darley still has it.

All in all some good pressure