Changes v Richmond Rd11

[Dudley Leopard]

Gonna get smashed next weekbut I say we start using this season to develop the kids.

Out:
Anthony (aint gonna cut it ),
Duffield (picks up swags of junk possessions,nothing else)
Mundy(needs a rocket ),
Pearce (made too many errors today )

In :
Morabito ( dont care if he is not fully fit)
Sheridan ( put games into him )
Lower (honest goer)
Silvagni

 

[Clay Davis]

Can I say 'none'? That team is as good as we're going to get.

 

[YelloMit]

IN: Silvagni, Walters, Lower
OUT: Anthony, Mundy, Duffield

 

[Seppo]

Can I say 'none'? That team is as good as we're going to get.

Agreed.

But would love to see Lower or McPhee into the side for some hardness.

Anthony really struggled to make a claim to stay in the side.

 

[Clay Davis]

Agreed.

But would love to see Lower or McPhee into the side for some hardness.

Anthony really struggled to make a claim to stay in the side.

Yeah, maybe McPhee for one of Duffield or Ibbotson.

Still, don't expect improvement. So long as our 'best' midfielder stinks, we'll be rubbish.

 

[stormee]

Out: Anthony, Duffield

In: Sheridan (deserves reward for excellent WAFL form), Lower/McPhee/Walters (pick one)

 

[Outshined]

Sheridan for Mzungu and Walters for Anthony if he has another good one tomorrow.

 

[freocuz]

Out: Duffield, Anthony.
In: Any two others on our list.

 

[Wharf]

Not confident but will be going with some hope

 

[ImperialPurple]

Can I say 'none'? That team is as good as we're going to get.

Anthony at the very least has to go out, surely. Adds nothing, does nothing.

Some who could come in: McPhee, Lower, Silvagni, Walters.

Duffield is unbelievably soft, Mundy was less than useless. Either one (or both) of them need a stint in the WAFL.

Exactly who goes out and who goes in... dunno. Deck chairs, Titanic, all that stuff.

 

[DockerLand1]

Changes for Round 11 Freo V Richmond

Well it is time to start to make the hard decisions on some players careers at this point in the year. We are now playing the 3 form teams in the competition and will struggle to win one of these games let alone drag ourselves back into finals contention.

Out- Anthony ( Never EVER, EVER again! ), Mzungu ( love the guy but hopelessly out of form ), Duffield ( just not hard enough to deliver what is needed does not stop his opponents when needed )

In- Walters ( We need goal kickers with finishing skills- BADLY ) , Lower ( We just need strength and tough inside players in the midfield ), Suban/Menegola ( I would prefer Menegola but if he is not going to be elevated go with Suban )

It is going to be an ugly month and the break cant come soon enough. Fingers crossed Morabito is going to be ready soon and we can add some muscle and skill into the team. The season is going backwards fast so it is time to find out who can add to the squad and who needs to make way.

Very disappointing, especially when you consider the list is getting towards the fitter side of the injury list. Our best players are coming towards the end of their careers and we have a severe lack of quality replacements.

 

[DockerLand1]

Anthony at the very least has to go out, surely. Adds nothing, does nothing.

Some who could come in: McPhee, Lower, Silvagni, Walters.

Duffield is unbelievably soft, Mundy was less than useless. Either one (or both) of them need a stint in the WAFL.

Exactly who goes out and who goes in... dunno. Deck chairs, Titanic, all that stuff.

Well it is time to start to make the hard decisions on some players careers at this point in the year. We are now playing the 3 form teams in the competition and will struggle to win one of these games let alone drag ourselves back into finals contention.

Out- Anthony ( Never EVER, EVER again! ), Mzungu ( love the guy but hopelessly out of form ), Duffield ( just not hard enough to deliver what is needed does not stop his opponents when needed )

In- Walters ( We need goal kickers with finishing skills- BADLY ) , Lower ( We just need strength and tough inside players in the midfield ), Suban/Menegola ( I would prefer Menegola but if he is not going to be elevated go with Suban )

It is going to be an ugly month and the break cant come soon enough. Fingers crossed Morabito is going to be ready soon and we can add some muscle and skill into the team. The season is going backwards fast so it is time to find out who can add to the squad and who needs to make way.

Very disappointing, especially when you consider the list is getting towards the fitter side of the injury list. Our best players are coming towards the end of their careers and we have a severe lack of quality replacements.

 

[DockerLand1]

Re: Changes for Round 11 Freo V Richmond

I was just beaten to the punch, please delete thread.

 

[Latro]

Why not Sheridan? last 2 games around 35 possessions and 2 goals. He would be infront of Menegola.

 

[se17enteen]

OUT: Anthony
IN: Walters

 

[DockerLand1]

Why not Sheridan? last 2 games around 35 possessions and 2 goals. He would be infront of Menegola.

The kid looks good Latro, we need all the talent that we can get. He may well get his chance this week. I like Menegola because he kicks goals and runds all day. We need as many of these kinds of players as we can get!

 

[Bradesmaen]

Sheridan for Pearce, Pitt for Mzungu. That is all for me.

 

[stormee]

We need Kepler back

 

[free at last]

Out:duff & Anthony

In: Sherro (BOG for peel today 25 dis. 2.2 gls, gotta love goal kicking mids)
Spurr or skeletor.

 

[Lach72]

In the gun: Anthony, Mundy, Duffield, Mzungu, Broughton.

 

[Schauermann]

We need Kepler back

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Andy Brennan]

B: Ibbotson Dawson Broughton
HB: McPhee McPharlin Johnson
C: Crichton Crowley Sheridan
HF: De Boer Mayne Ballantyne
F: Clarke Pavlich Walters
R: Sandilands Lower Barlow

I: Spurr Neale Pearce Sub: Crozier

 

[Righteo]

OUT: Crichton Mzungu Duffield Anthony
IN: Sutcliffe Lower Walters Silvagni

Chuck Silvagni up forward, Anthony won't ever make, Clarke isn't really cutting it as a forward yet and whilst Keplar is injured we have no other suitable forward options. May as well experiment and give Silver a crack.

Crozier to be retained, McPhee if fit comes straight back. De boer, Neale and Lower full time inside midfielders, Pav, Ballantyne, Mayne, Silvagni, Crozier and Walters up forward.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Anthony for Morabito, to play as a leading forward with Clarke.
Sheridan for Duffield, starting as Sub.
Walters in for Mzungu, Didnt do enough and got smashed by Sloane,


B: Ibbotson Dawson Broughton
HB: Crichton McPharlin Johnson
C: Crozier Crowley Mundy
HF: Mayne Pavlich Ballantyne
F: Clarke Morabito Walters
R: Sandilands Lower Barlow

I: De Boer Neale Pearce Sub: Sheridan

McPhee - needs one game in the WAFL, has been out for too many.

Crozier was good and should start on the ground.

 

[muzzington]

I know people don't like Duff but they won't drop him.