Preview Hawks vs Swans - Changes and Discussion

[grizzlym]

Who should come in? Who goes out? Etc etc.

 

[Yaelius]

Out: Rioli
In: Hooper

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Rioli, Whitecross def. out.

Hooper and Shoey in

 

[Cynic]

Whitecross was better than Roughead. Don't care if neither of them are playing well in the VFL but give Lisle or Dowler a chance over Roughead.

Also please be ready to play Taylor as Mumford will flog our rucks, Renouf learn to hit to advantage more than taking irrelevant marks you simply turn over anyway.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Whitecross was not at the standard we should accept.

 

[buddy hell]

this is a big call, but the two kicks which whitecross butchered at half back with no pressure when we were 18 points up went a long way to costing us the game. his disposal is not up to afl standard. players like muston, peterson, shiels (all who arent great kicks themselves) offer way more to this team.

 

[Rudi Gilham]

Worst game I've seen Roughead play. Still, I don' think we can drop him! We just play well interstate (accept Tassie!)

 

[Cynic]

Worst game I've seen Roughead play. Still, I don' think we can drop him! We just play well interstate (accept Tassie!)

Honestly I think Roughead needs it, he's really doesn't look like he thinks he belongs out there at the moment.

Give him a break and on the chance we make the finals, bring him back.

 

[TheWiseOne]

What i want

In: Muston Hooper Dowler/Lisle
Out: Rioli Whitecross Roughead

What will happen

In: Hooper
Out: Rioli

 

[Glebehawk]

whitecross is a weak link, but 12 or so players were extremely poor today.

We seem to be specialists at leaving the door open and letting teams back into the game.

Don't think there's anyone at Box Hill who can make an immediate difference to the side right now. Hooper should come in if fit...maybe Muston?

Can see a very similar game coming up against the Swans...hopefully one of hodge, mitchell, franklin, Roughy Rioli (if playing) can fire, otherwise Melbourne and Freo become massive tests.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

**** OFF WHITECROSS .. he is s**t and a liability that is yet to offer anything.

He's a HBFer playing a role not suited to him.

 

[IBleedBrownNGold]

OUT: Ellis, Whitecross, Rioli (if rubbed out)
IN: Hooper, Muston, Savage

The rest of them need to ship up. Roughy must be VERY close to being dropped.

 

[Baz_hawk]

Out: WhiteX, Rioli, Roughead

In: Hooper, Peterson, Lisle

 

[Hawksgirl4eva]

OUTS:

Roughead- seriously how many chances can one guy get. he couldnt kick a goal to save himself. (if sewlle and Lewis were drop worthy than he is)
WX- doesnt do anything really.
Rioli- well obviously

INS
Lisle- please i want to see if the kid can play
Hooper-
Peterson-

if Brown had only got the one week i would have siad goo for brown.

 

[Dewwwww]

Out - Roughead

In - The Chief!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Mervyn Beasley]

It blows my mind that the name Dowler is even thought of, let alone mentioned in any post here.
Lucky to be in BH ones, so how could he be even thought of in HFC ones

Whitecross out.

 

[Sir Jeffrey]

OUT: Ladson (soft as) Whitecross (had his 3 weeks shown zilch) Murphy (been better but hopeless today)
IN: Hooper Muston Peterson

Could have dropped the whole back six today, terrible, how Schulz the shite-truck continually marked 1 on 3 staggered me!!!

So frustrating to watch

 

[Dewwwww]

OUT: Ladson (soft as) Whitecross (had his 3 weeks shown zilch) Murphy (been better but hopeless today)
IN: Hooper Muston Peterson

Could have dropped the whole back six today, terrible, how Schulz the shite-truck continually marked 1 on 3 staggered me!!!

So frustrating to watch

complain about the back six, then you want to drop 3 of them and replace them with forwards???

 

[go hawks!!!]

Will we consider dropping Lewis?

 

[Brant]

Simply naming people that frustrated you today & suggesting that they be dropped is rarely productive. If that were the case 15 guys wouldn't play next week.

 

[Sir Jeffrey]

complain about the back six, then you want to drop 3 of them and replace them with forwards???

Is muston a forward? Half back flank his best position, despite playing as a stop fwd recently.

Whitex play in the back six today? No he played predominantly forward!

Muston for ladson, hooper for whitex, Peterson off the bench.

I'm speaking to queens English are your ears painted on or what?

 

[Hawkforce]

I don't get it. I didn't think Roughy was too bad today. Took some nice grabs on the very few times it was kicked to a 50/50 contest involving him.

Missed a couple and gave away one to Franko which he shoulda taken responsibility for - but he kicked a clutch goal which should have steadied us in the last.

Hodge, Mitchell, Burgers, Youngy, Lewis - these are the guys who got thrashed today not Roughead.

Rioli and Whitecross out. Maybe Skipper.

Hooper Schoey IN. Taylor maybe.

 

[Hawkforce]

OUT: Ladson (soft as) Whitecross (had his 3 weeks shown zilch) Murphy (been better but hopeless today)
IN: Hooper Muston Peterson

Could have dropped the whole back six today, terrible, how Schulz the shite-truck continually marked 1 on 3 staggered me!!!

So frustrating to watch

Okay... Had enough.

There shoud be an instant red card for anyone calling for Tom Murphy to be dropped.

This rule to be enforced until such a time as Murphy plays a bad game - something which hasn't happened for almost 3 months.

Just FRAKKING ridiculous.

 

[mrcurly]

Throw them all to the lions.

We lost one game to an average team on their home ground in a swirling breeze - after looking invincible for 10 weeks and mixing it with the best.

Get some perspective people.

Rioli (susp) and Whitex out
Hooper and Peterson in.

 

[Steven Tyler]

Okay... Had enough.

There shoud be an instant red card for anyone calling for Tom Murphy to be dropped.

This rule to be enforced until such a time as Murphy plays a bad game - something which hasn't happened for almost 3 months.

Just FRAKKING ridiculous.

Add an instant red card for anyone who calls for Dowler to be given a game. FFS