Hodge vs Bartel

[finrod]

This is a follow up from the "best duo" poll. Most people of course rate Judd higher than Hodge, but who would you take out of Hodge and Bartel? I say Hodge by a whisker.

 

[tin can sam]

Clearance work - Bartel
Pace - Hodge
Ball Winning - Bartel
Disposal - Hodge
Hardness - Bartel
Marking - Bartel
Leadership - Hodge
Decision Making - even

I can't think of other stuff to rank them on.

 

[BedlamHawk]

Bartel has crept up really fast and is becoming one of the best picks from the 2001 draft and thats saying something. I would pick Hodge just because I have seen more of him thus I am biased. But I would tend to think that the best of the 2001 draft looks like
1 Judd
2 Hodge
3 Bartel at this stage
Dal Santo would probably slip in at 4.

 

[H2F]

It really annoys me when a player in RED HOT form is compared to another and the results become so skewed.

Hodge >>> DAYLIGHT >>> Bartel

If Bartel continues to perform like he has for another couple of years, then it is worth a poll.

It's like saying Polak >>> Scarlet because Polak has had a great season ...

 

[greenlight]

hodge...sign him up at bomber land....

 

[crosby123]

It's like saying Polak >>> Scarlet because Polak has had a great season ...

Even though Scarlett is having a better season than Polak?

 

[oscarheel]

Bartel is the complete package. Seriously though I'd rather Mitchell over Hodge.

 

[mightymightyblues]

Both in my fantasy squad so dnt wanna compare! There both champs

 

[jazz]

Clearance work - Bartel
Pace - Hodge
Ball Winning - Bartel
Disposal - Hodge
Hardness - Bartel
Marking - Bartel
Leadership - Hodge
Decision Making - even

I can't think of other stuff to rank them on.

I wouldn't put Bartell ahead of Hodge for hardness. Hodge is very hard at the ball.

 

[Big Nasty]

It really annoys me when a player in RED HOT form is compared to another and the results become so skewed.

Hodge >>> DAYLIGHT >>> Bartel

If Bartel continues to perform like he has for another couple of years, then it is worth a poll.

It's like saying Polak >>> Scarlett because Polak has had a great season ...

Comparing Scarlett to Polak is like comparing Franklin to Judd... The comparison looks promising, except...? Well at least Polak is consistant.
I was gonna call Franklin a front runner, but he cant even play a decent match when the Tassie Hawks are having a day out.

 

[jazz]

Comparing Scarlett to Polak is like comparing Franklin to Judd... The comparison looks promising, except...? Well at least Polak is consistant.
I was gonna call Franklin a front runner, but he cant even play a decent match when the Tassie Hawks are having a day out.

Even on a slow day he managed a top shelf running goal.

Give him some time - let him have his 21st birthday at least....

 

[trueblue_91]

I wouldn't put Bartell ahead of Hodge for hardness. Hodge is very hard at the ball.

Bartel throws his body around like a rag doll. He goes in very very hard.

Hosge also does but no were near as hard as Bartel

 

[MinerBoy]

It really annoys me when a player in RED HOT form is compared to another and the results become so skewed.

Hodge >>> DAYLIGHT >>> Bartel

If Bartel continues to perform like he has for another couple of years, then it is worth a poll.

It's like saying Polak >>> Scarlet because Polak has had a great season ...

Exact a mundo

 

[SomeBodyStopMe]

I have not voted for obvious reasons, but i would like to say that Hodge should be way mor ein front.....
bartel = very good footballer
hodge = GUN footballer
i am only going to say this coz i believe bartel goes missing when his team isnt travelling all the best, i honestly believe Chapman is a better footballer than bartel and thats becoz he is always performing, regardless of the scoreboard

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Jimmy!!!!!!!

and fairle easily too.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

It really annoys me when a player in RED HOT form is compared to another and the results become so skewed.

Hodge >>> DAYLIGHT >>> Bartel

If Bartel continues to perform like he has for another couple of years, then it is worth a poll.

It's like saying Polak >>> Scarlet because Polak has had a great season ...

Hodge has had 1 elite season (2005). Bartel has had 2 elite seasons (2006 and now 2007)

 

[Philhawk]

Hodge has had 1 elite season (2005). Bartel has had 2 elite seasons (2006 and now 2007)

Oh dear.

Hodge has been instrumental in our season this year and will appear in the Top 5 in the Brownlow.

Bookmark it if you like.

 

[MinerBoy]

Oh dear.

Hodge has been instrumental in our season this year and will appear in the Top 5 in the Brownlow.

Bookmark it if you like.

Not to mention he was R-up in our 2006 B&F playing the entire season under duress from injury.

He has been elite from 2005-current. Pre-2005 he was still establishing himself, however he still had Bartel comfortably covered during those years.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Oh dear.

Hodge has been instrumental in our season this year and will appear in the Top 5 in the Brownlow.

Bookmark it if you like.

Hahaha top 5?

Bwahahahaha

more like top 50.

Why be so biased?

 

[MinerBoy]

Hahaha top 5?

Bwahahahaha

more like top 50.

Why be so biased?

Would have between 6-8 votes already and is only starting to hit absolute top form the past 2-3 weeks. Most certainly a chance of coming top 5 Brownlow.

 

[HBK619]

Depends.

This year - Bartel.

Over Carrer So Far - Hodge.

Future On Current Form - Bartel.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Hodge by a mile

so much more damaging with his disposal

 

[cats2rise]

If Bartel continues to perform like he has for another couple of years, then it is worth a poll.

13 votes from 12 or so games in 2004 isnt good enough? How about where he finished in the B&F last year? Is that not good enough?

 

[H2F]

13 votes from 12 or so games in 2004 isnt good enough? How about where he finished in the B&F last year? Is that not good enough?

No one is questioning that he is a great player, but if you watch Hodge a little more you would agree also that it's comparing a Ferrari to a worked Skyline.

 

[Big Nasty]

deleted thread