How do you fix Melbourne?

[RogersResults]

A small irony:

• 255.08: Essendon's highest percentage after 2 matches. Previous: 245.45% in 1898.
• 255.08: 12th highest percentage after 2 matches and the highest since Melbourne's 264.71% in 1994.
  
  
  More facts will here: RogersResults - as usual after the round has completed.

 

[RUNVS]

Here is a random question for Collingwood fans really. If Melbourne offered this trade

Pick 1 for Fasolo, Keeffe and Sinclair

would you go for it?

I ask because Melbourne need experienced proven AFL players now and lots of them and I was wondering what Pick 1 would be worth for fringe players at other clubs.

 

[Shane_Mag]

Garry Lyon.

Nah seriously Paul Roos.

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

Jock Mchale

 

[caterina]

Neeld

Edit: Sorry, misread the thread title, I thought it said

Is There Actually A Coach Who Could F*** Melbourne?

 

[Galileo9]

one solution is total clearout of everyone. CEO down. you have to. how can you not after dishing this out. clearly neeld has no idea. clear as day.

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

Any coach would need a few years to slowly replace the large portion of the list not up too it

PS - Colin Sylvia is a disgrace

 

[Galileo9]

Kim-Jong-un.

I mean perhaps the threat of working in some North Korean slave camps will do the trick?

hahahaha like it.

 

[Fear Boner]

so sydney before eade and roos wernt a rabble ?

brisbane had very little success without leigh matthews

a coach can bring a change in culture and structure , clubs can be turned around it just needs the right people

hawthorn were not far away from being merged with the demons now they are one of melbournes biggest clubs member wise and finacially things can turn around

 

[Blue1980]

Terry Wallace

End thread

 

[Flameboy]

Here is a random question for Collingwood fans really. If Melbourne offered this trade

Pick 1 for Fasolo, Keeffe and Sinclair

would you go for it?

I ask because Melbourne need experienced proven AFL players now and lots of them and I was wondering what Pick 1 would be worth for fringe players at other clubs.

Buckley should be shot if he agreed to that.

 

[Blue1980]

Not really, because none of them have a magic wand.

It is going to take time & meticulous planning to get it right.

Like with Carlton

 

[RUNVS]

Buckley should be shot if he agreed to that.

Possibly. I was just spitballing on the trade value of pick 1 as I really do think Melbourne should try and get as many experienced and proven AFL players by trading their first pick as possible.

 

[LeverPuller]

I see Roos mentioned alot on this forum as an option and posters saying that the Demons or even the AFL should get him in as the new coach.

Why on earth would he take the job?

Also feed his ego.

He'd go down as one of the best ever breaking the Swans' drought then the Norm Smith curse.

 

[Blue1980]

Buckley should be shot if he agreed to that.

The players themselves wouldn't want to go.

 

[LordLucifer]

All of the answers to the Dees woes are in this thread !!!

 

[PP34]

Nah **** the supporters.. Eat a dick MFC

Surely you've heard of the famous KFC boy?

 

[Blue1980]

Possibly. I was just spitballing on the trade value of pick 1 as I really do think Melbourne should try and get as many experienced and proven AFL players by trading their first pick as possible.

That can even end up being worse.

Chances are they wouldn't get Jack Watts mark II

 

[andrew99]

I see Roos mentioned alot on this forum as an option and posters saying that the Demons or even the AFL should get him in as the new coach.

Why on earth would he take the job?

Money.

A chance to stroke his ego.

The challenge.

 

[TP86]

Make Clarkson a godfather offer and stump up whatever fee it might cost to buy out his Hawthorn contract if he can't simply walk.

While it would throw my own club into temporary disarray, if the Dees wanted to dig their way out of this situation they should bring in a guy who has taken a club at the bottom and built them up.

 

[ManOfClay]

Neeld seems to be a lot of rhetoric, minimal results.

Hate to say it, but I was right.

 

[_Wang_]

Surely you've heard of the famous KFC boy?

Yes I have mate.. Dude if you were a tigers supporter and heard them cheer when McMahon kicked the goal that gave them pick 1 and 2, you would understand..

 

[zimma]

Terry Wallace

End thread

While I have no doubt he would stick his hand up if for no other reason than to support his tanning addiction, any club that lets him near their list almost deserves what they get...

 

[MeisterBot]

Here is a random question for Collingwood fans really. If Melbourne offered this trade

Pick 1 for Fasolo, Keeffe and Sinclair

would you go for it?

I ask because Melbourne need experienced proven AFL players now and lots of them and I was wondering what Pick 1 would be worth for fringe players at other clubs.

No way. Fasolo and Keeffe will be a big part of Collingwood for the next 10 years especially since Didak and Maxwell are near the end. Fasolo in particular is going to be a gun in the midfield in the next year or two (IMO).

That said, I'd definitely consider Sinkers for #1.

 

[se17enteen]

Stop hiring these untried assistant coaches, there is a reason why a Rolls Royce cost more then a Toyota. Throw all of your money at Paul Roos.