Scott Pendlebury is one of the greatest AFL players of the modern era, with exceptional skills, leadership, and consistency. However, whether he would make every club's best 22 depends on several factors:
Elite Skills & Decision-Making – One of the best users of the ball under pressure.
Leadership & Experience – Premiership captain, multiple-time All-Australian, and record-breaking games played.
Versatility – Can play in the midfield or off half-back.
Consistency – Still performing at a high level even in the latter stages of his career.
While he would improve nearly every team, some clubs with incredibly deep midfields (e.g., Collingwood, Melbourne, Brisbane) might need to balance team structure. However, given his ability to play in multiple roles, he’d almost certainly find a spot.
Yes, he’d almost certainly be in every club’s best 22, even if his role varied based on team needs.
Why He Would Be in Every Team’s Best 22:




Possible Exceptions:
While he would improve nearly every team, some clubs with incredibly deep midfields (e.g., Collingwood, Melbourne, Brisbane) might need to balance team structure. However, given his ability to play in multiple roles, he’d almost certainly find a spot.
Verdict:
Yes, he’d almost certainly be in every club’s best 22, even if his role varied based on team needs.