Oppo Camp James Aish, (Traded to Freo 2019)

[domus]

So my main hope is that they give him a run on the wing, with an eye to replacing our dear friend Mayne, who is still powering on but is still near the end.

Oh boy. Unbelievable.

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[Black_White]

2nd last on the ladder and Aish gets dropped.
Clubs decision justified right there.

 

[Sea fog]

I think you will find Aish is injured but he didn't seem to be playing that well.

 

[TradeDraft]

I think you will find Aish is injured but he didn't seem to be playing that well.

Concussion.

Guess no Worse then he was with us

 

[Black_White]

Concussion.

Guess no Worse then he was with us

Of course.... concussion...
The injury you have when the club doesn’t want to admit to screwing up.
I stand to be corrected when a video of the incident, or the medical staff examining him, is posted.
Wait, I found it myself...

Highlights: Aish concussed

James Aish's night is over after a nasty concussion.

www.collingwoodfc.com.au

 

[whiskeytown]

Solid B grade footballer. No loss. Except for the 2 x 2nd picks we paid for him... that was a loss.

But fortunately we’ve gotten some good value out of other players we paid 2nd picks for like Howe, Varcoe, Greenwood, Hoskin Elliot.

Of all the players to leave Collingwood since 2010... only Shaw and Seedsman have played very good footy elsewhere

We generally get it right when we move players on

 

[pablo disco bar]

Solid B grade footballer. No loss. Except for the 2 x 2nd picks we paid for him... that was a loss.

But fortunately we’ve gotten some good value out of other players we paid 2nd picks for like Howe, Varcoe, Greenwood, Hoskin Elliot.

Of all the players to leave Collingwood since 2010... only Shaw and Seedsman have played very good footy elsewhere

We generally get it right when we move players on

Seedsman been ok not outstanding

Could of used him recently

 

[showemhowtorock]

I think you will find Aish is injured but he didn't seem to be playing that well.

he's been awesome? a bit quieter since going back the last fortnight but he still nailed his role.
He's been in our top 3 players this season easily, not sure what you've been watching

 

[Quicky]

How many concussions has Aish had now? It's gotta be a concern.

 

[loki04]

Was always a bit one paced, not really slow but lacked that burst of breakaway speed.

Was a medium paced player but not slow like post injury.

 

[Horaceg]

Solid B grade footballer. No loss. Except for the 2 x 2nd picks we paid for him... that was a loss.

But fortunately we’ve gotten some good value out of other players we paid 2nd picks for like Howe, Varcoe, Greenwood, Hoskin Elliot.

Of all the players to leave Collingwood since 2010... only Shaw and Seedsman have played very good footy elsewhere

We generally get it right when we move players on

Big Witts, he goes OK

 

[mike123]

I wouldn’t play Aish over any of our small defenders or wingers.

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

Solid B grade footballer. No loss. Except for the 2 x 2nd picks we paid for him... that was a loss.

But fortunately we’ve gotten some good value out of other players we paid 2nd picks for like Howe, Varcoe, Greenwood, Hoskin Elliot.

Of all the players to leave Collingwood since 2010... only Shaw and Seedsman have played very good footy elsewhere

We generally get it right when we move players on

But they did choose Mason Cox over Witts

 

[mike123]

But they did choose Mason Cox over Witts

Mason Cox played better up forward than Witts ever did.

 

[Apex36]

Of course.... concussion...
The injury you have when the club doesn’t want to admit to screwing up.
I stand to be corrected when a video of the incident, or the medical staff examining him, is posted.
Wait, I found it myself...

Highlights: Aish concussed

James Aish's night is over after a nasty concussion.

www.collingwoodfc.com.au

He’s been one of their better players this year. Stop talking s**t.

 

[pablo disco bar]

Of course we had witts and grundy at same time

OF COURSE we did


Would witts actually be a better option as his a better rap ruckman

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Of course we had witts and grundy at same time

OF COURSE we did


Would witts actually be a better option as his a better rap ruckman

No.

 

[Horaceg]

Of course we had witts and grundy at same time

OF COURSE we did


Would witts actually be a better option as his a better rap ruckman

He’d need to be up there with Eminem being a white guy.

 

[mike123]

Of course we had witts and grundy at same time

OF COURSE we did


Would witts actually be a better option as his a better rap ruckman

Would probably command less salary too.

I just wish they both had forward boys so we could play them together, unfortunately it wasn’t meant to be.

 

[TradeDraft]

Still Sad he left but look like he done not much better at Freo. Just a Good Solid AFL Player/Foot Soilder.

Guess we could say that Nobel and IQ have been better and Offer More Offensively

 

[Black_White]

He’s been one of their better players this year. Stop talking sh*t.

14th team on the ladder. And I think that’s overrating them.
To be “one of their better players” shouldn’t be that hard.
To be the best or second best player would earn respect.
But being in that lower position in a team that low shows that he was surplus to requirements at CFC.

 

[stormskye]

Def not needed. We have plenty of good defenders. It’s our forwards we are lacking

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

14th team on the ladder. And I think that’s overrating them.
To be “one of their better players” shouldn’t be that hard.
To be the best or second best player would earn respect.
But being in that lower position in a team that low shows that he was surplus to requirements at CFC.

Given that Aish was forced from a club he never wished to leave (thanks to Beams) I would have thought you would have been more gracious in your assessment of him. There has even been a Fremantle supporter in the thread who said he has been in the best 3 players at the new club. But no you seem determined to belittle his performance - a 'best or second best player would earn respect' but not a possible 3rd best?!

 

[mike123]

Given that Aish was forced from a club he never wished to leave (thanks to Beams) I would have thought you would have been more gracious in your assessment of him. There has even been a Fremantle supporter in the thread who said he has been in the best 3 players at the new club. But no you seem determined to belittle his performance - a 'best or second best player would earn respect' but not a possible 3rd best?!

That’s a nice sentiment but it doesn’t really change his performances.