Pick one midfield, one backline, one forwardline, one ruck combo

[Jcpdragonx]

Anyone that says WCE ruck hasn't watched them play this year.

 

[madman]

Back - Geelong

FB: Rivers - Lonergan - Enright
HB: Bartel - Taylor - Mackie

Mids - Port / Ruck - Freo

C: Hartlett - Ebert - Polec
R: Sandilands - Wines - Boak

Forward - Sydney

HF: Jetta - Franklin - Mitchell
FF: Goodes - Tippett - Reid

 

[MiloStedman]

Backline: GWS - Tight unit, unstoppable one on one

???

 

[eth-dog]

???

extracting the urine

 

[Sydney Bloods]

Backs: geelong
Mids: Sydney
Rucks: dockers
Fwds: Sydney

 

[lmach]

Anyone that says WCE ruck hasn't watched them play this year.

WCE ruck

 

[Seeds]

Past midfield

Cox, Judd Kerr cousins, Embley.

Keeting, voss, black, Akers and lappin

both inferior to Ottens, Ablett, Bartel and Selwood.

 

[Premiers04]

Backs - Eagles
Mids - Port
Forwards - Swans
Rucks - Freo

Coach - Hinkley

 

[lmach]

both inferior to Ottens, Ablett, Bartel and Selwood.

Nope.

 

[eth-dog]

Nope.

Yep.

Ottens<Cox
Ablett>Judd
Bartel>Cousins
Selwood>Kerr

 

[lmach]

Yep.

Ottens<Cox
Ablett>Judd
Bartel>Cousins
Selwood>Kerr

Nope.

Cox>Ottens
Judd<Ablett
Cousins>Bartel
Kerr>Selwood

 

[eth-dog]

Nope.

Cox>Ottens
Judd<Ablett
Cousins>Bartel
Kerr>Selwood

You're biased, I'm not

 

[lmach]

You're biased, I'm not

Oh, you must be right then. Anyone who's biased is wrong.

 

[Chaisa]

Discounting my own side here:

Defenders: Geelong
Midfielders: Collingwood
Forwards: Hawthorn
Rucks: West Coast

Would think we're up there in terms of forwards and mids.

 

[Scotland]

Yep.

Ottens<Cox
Ablett>Judd
Bartel>Cousins
Selwood>Kerr

WC Judd > Geelong Ablett

Ablett only passed Judd around 2008/9.

 

[eth-dog]

WC Judd > Geelong Ablett

Ablett only passed Judd around 2008/9.

Nope.

 

[Scotland]

Nope.

Excellent retort.

Judd's WC career:

1 x AFL MVP
1 x Brownlow Medal
2 x All Australian
2 x Best and Fairest
1 x Premiership captain

Ablett in the same period:

1 x Best and Fairest (2007)
1 x Leading goalkicker (with 35 goals)
1 x All Australian (2007)
1 x AFL MVP (2007)

People have such short memories. 'Is Judd the GOAT' threads used to pop up on BigFooty with annoying frequency while Ablett was still a son of a gun forward pocket that people were waiting to see break out and fulfil his potential.

 

[Seeds]

Nope.

Yep.

 

[Seeds]

Excellent retort.

Judd's WC career:

1 x AFL MVP
1 x Brownlow Medal
2 x All Australian
2 x Best and Fairest
1 x Premiership captain

Ablett in the same period:

1 x Best and Fairest (2007)
1 x Leading goalkicker (with 35 goals)
1 x All Australian (2007)
1 x AFL MVP (2007)

People have such short memories. 'Is Judd the GOAT' threads used to pop up on BigFooty with annoying frequency while Ablett was still a son of a gun forward pocket that people were waiting to see break out and fulfil his potential.

why are you leaving out what Ablett did in 2008 to 2011? is it because it ruins your argument?

 

[Seeds]

WC Judd > Geelong Ablett

Ablett only passed Judd around 2008/9.

and crapped all over what Judd achieved.

 

[Seeds]

Nope.

Cox>Ottens
Judd<Ablett
Cousins>Bartel
Kerr>Selwood

in what universe is Kerr greater than Selwood?

 

[lmach]

in what universe is Kerr greater than Selwood?

This one.

 

[Scotland]

why are you leaving out what Ablett did in 2008 to 2011? is it because it ruins your argument?

Well in 2011 he played for Gold Coast, but anyway...

and crapped all over what Judd achieved.

Crapped all over? Clueless.

 

[Tippett2Goal]

both inferior to Ottens, Ablett, Bartel and Selwood.

Nope, but for the other comparison

Ottens > Keating
Ablett > Voss
Bartel < Black
Selwood < Akermanis
* < Lappin
* < Power

People seem to forget just how good a player Aker was...

 

[Scotland]

People seem to forget just how good a player Aker was...

Fair bit of that going on in this thread.