Draft Watcher Smythe's FINAL FIRST ROUND PHANTOM PAGE 11

[Smythe]

ROUND ONE - Smythe

1. WB - Jamara Ugle-Hagen - Bid matched
2. Adelaide - Riley Thilthorpe
3. North Melbourne - Elijah Hollands
4. Sydney - Denver Grainger-Barras
5. Hawthorn - Logan McDonald
6. Gold Coast - Will Phillips
7. Essendon - Zach Reid
8. Sydney - Braeden Campbell - Bid Matched
9. Essendon - Archie Perkins
10. Collingwood - Reef McInness - Bid Matched
11. Essendon - Tanner Bruhn
12. Port Adelaide - Lachlan Jones - Bid Matched
13. Adelaide - Tom Powell
14. GWS - Brayden Cook
15. North Melbourne - Nik Cox
16. Fremantle - Oliver Henry
17. GWS - Heath Chapman
18. GWS - Luke Pedlar
19. Collingwood - Bailey Laurie
20. Adelaide - Nathan O’Driscoll
21. Melbourne - Jack Carroll
22. Melbourne - Max Holmes
23. Sydney - Errol Gulden - Bid Matched
24. Brisbane - Blake Coleman - Bid matched
25. GWS - Finlay Macrae
26. Hawthorn - Connor Downie - Bid Matched
27. St Kilda - Conor Stone

Tigers and Crows to strike a deal on pick swaps late first round

 

[Smythe]

Can you really see them taking Kolar at 17, I can’t

There are a few ways to look at it;
At 17, maybe not - but outside of the top fwd prospects I see him as the next best fwd with the highest ceiling and potential, and is it something (an area) of fulfilment that Richmond need to invest in , yes.

Does the rumour that the Tigers are looking to package and change picks in order to facilitate such a pick come to fruition because they realise clubs may want other kids that have slid to that range before Kolar is in their consideration, quite possibly.

What are Richmonds needs: their list is pretty stacked of mids, wingers, half fwds, half backs, small fwds. Their backline will need an investment as does their fwd line. Their is no heir apparent to the almost ready to retire Riewoldt yet, Callum Coleman Jones is a fwd ruck prospect, chol is a depth fwd/ruck, lynch is the tall ff, Balta can be a swing man but is settling down back.
So, are they are a team that can afford an early pick on an investment, short answer, yes.

If I did a phantom draft with prospective pick swaps and/including 2021 pick exchanges then he probably would not be on here at 17, but I do very much believe the Tigers will look at a best value/high ceiling fwd first if possible then quite possibly a def with elite athletic traits, then if a Rioli bid comes in match it, but hold out in the hope he gets to the rookie draft.

Not every year goes right, not very draft haul is exactly what teams want, but I believe if any club is in a position to use their early pick for value in exchanges or pick for the future in a position of needed investment then it is Richmond.

Also, if there is a year to find a golden nugget amongst the field this is the year for it. Top 10 seem solid after that there are maybe another 10 that look promising but then it is, although everyone has put in a lot of work and know the prospects, a turkey shoot for talent and future worth.

 

[Joose]

Good effort Smythe.

However not sure about Freo's last pick of Lake - a mid.

With Freo's shortage or tall forwards I would be looking at Callow, Rosman and Allison who are still available.

 

[andleanback]

Cole,nelson,witherdon, they are looking at cox from brisbane too.either way you look at it our midfield depth sucks. If carruthers cant play midfield i wouldnt want to draft him

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

Nelson please, one of the worst decision makers in the afl.

 

[WWSD]

For those out there who live in WA and have seen Isiah Winder live. What are his greatest strengths?

 

[Smythe]

Good effort Smythe.

However not sure about Freo's last pick of Lake - a mid.

With Freo's shortage or tall forwards I would be looking at Callow, Rosman and Allison who are still available.

Fair point, I just couldn’t leave Lake on the board any longer, I’m also not as bullish as some on Callow, last year I thought so, but as the year went on, not so much, Allison would be a good one.

 

[Smythe]

For those out there who live in WA and have seen Isiah Winder live. What are his greatest strengths?

Ground level work, athleticism, bursts away from packs, use of the ball by hand, link up play, ferocity at the ball or man with the ball, and reading of play, X factor and leap. He is, in my eyes one of the best smalls this year with huge upside In the right environment at a professional level.

 

[Apex36]

FINAL PHANTOM DRAFT FOR 2020

ROUND 1

-1- Jamarra Ugle-Hagen - BID MATCHED
-2- Riley Thilthorpe
-3- Logan McDonald
-4- Elijah Hollands
-5- Denver Grainger-Barras
-6- Will Phillips
-7- Archie Perkins
-8- Lachlan Jones - BID MATCHED
-9- Nik Cox
-10- Braeden Campbell - BID MATCHED
-11- Oliver Henry
-12- Tanner Bruhn
-13- Zach Reid
-14- Nathan O'Driscoll
-15- Heath Chapman
-16- Finlay Macrae
-17- Tom Powell
-18- Brayden Cook
-19- Bailey Laurie
-20- Liam Kolar
-21- Reef McInness - BID MATCHED
-22- Caleb Poulter
-23- Errol Gulden - BID MATCHED
-24- Brandon Walker - BID MATCHED
-25- Jack Carroll
-26- Jack Ginnivan
-27- Eddie Ford

ROUND 2

-28- Zavier Maher
-29- Blake Coleman - BID MATCHED
-30- Sam Berry
-31- Connor Stone
-32- Max Heath
-33- Liam McMahon
-34- Jake Bowey
-35- Conner Downie - BID MATCHED
-36- Oliver Davis
-37- Isiah Winder
-38- Cody Brand - BID MATCHED
-39- Lachlan Carrigan
-40- Zane Trew
-41- Taj Schofield - BID MATCHED
-42- Joel Western - BID MATCHED
-43- Seamus Mitchell
-44- Henry Smith

Round 3

-45- Maurice Rioli Jnr - BID MATCHED
-46- Corey Durdin
-47- Shannon Neale
-48- Ryan Angwin
-49- Kalin Lane
-50- Brodie Lake

ROUND 4

-51-Malachy Carruthers
-52- Fraser Rosman
-53- Luke Pedlar
-54- Matt Allison
-55- Jackson Callow
-56- Sam Collins

ROUND 5

-57-Jaiden Hunter
-58-Nicholas Stevens
-59- Pheonix Spicer

ROUND 6

-60- Harry Sharp

Can’t see the Pies going for a KPD in Hunter and leaving Baldwin going undrafted if he’s on the board at 60. That’s the biggest risk/reward no brainer in draft history, especially for a club desperate for a key forward.

 

[Scham]

For those out there who live in WA and have seen Isiah Winder live. What are his greatest strengths?

X factor, ball handling and athleticism I’d say.

 

[snails13]

FINAL PHANTOM DRAFT FOR 2020

ROUND 1

-1- Jamarra Ugle-Hagen - BID MATCHED
-2- Riley Thilthorpe
-3- Logan McDonald
-4- Elijah Hollands
-5- Denver Grainger-Barras
-6- Will Phillips
-7- Archie Perkins
-8- Lachlan Jones - BID MATCHED
-9- Nik Cox
-10- Braeden Campbell - BID MATCHED
-11- Oliver Henry
-12- Tanner Bruhn
-13- Zach Reid
-14- Nathan O'Driscoll
-15- Heath Chapman
-16- Finlay Macrae
-17- Tom Powell
-18- Brayden Cook
-19- Bailey Laurie
-20- Liam Kolar
-21- Reef McInness - BID MATCHED
-22- Caleb Poulter
-23- Errol Gulden - BID MATCHED
-24- Brandon Walker - BID MATCHED
-25- Jack Carroll
-26- Jack Ginnivan
-27- Eddie Ford

ROUND 2

-28- Zavier Maher
-29- Blake Coleman - BID MATCHED
-30- Sam Berry
-31- Connor Stone
-32- Max Heath
-33- Liam McMahon
-34- Jake Bowey
-35- Conner Downie - BID MATCHED
-36- Oliver Davis
-37- Isiah Winder
-38- Cody Brand - BID MATCHED
-39- Lachlan Carrigan
-40- Zane Trew
-41- Taj Schofield - BID MATCHED
-42- Joel Western - BID MATCHED
-43- Seamus Mitchell
-44- Henry Smith

Round 3

-45- Maurice Rioli Jnr - BID MATCHED
-46- Corey Durdin
-47- Shannon Neale
-48- Ryan Angwin
-49- Kalin Lane
-50- Brodie Lake

ROUND 4

-51-Malachy Carruthers
-52- Fraser Rosman
-53- Luke Pedlar
-54- Matt Allison
-55- Jackson Callow
-56- Sam Collins

ROUND 5

-57-Jaiden Hunter
-58-Nicholas Stevens
-59- Pheonix Spicer

ROUND 6

-60- Harry Sharp

Luke Pedl

FINAL PHANTOM DRAFT FOR 2020

ROUND 1

-1- Jamarra Ugle-Hagen - BID MATCHED
-2- Riley Thilthorpe
-3- Logan McDonald
-4- Elijah Hollands
-5- Denver Grainger-Barras
-6- Will Phillips
-7- Archie Perkins
-8- Lachlan Jones - BID MATCHED
-9- Nik Cox
-10- Braeden Campbell - BID MATCHED
-11- Oliver Henry
-12- Tanner Bruhn
-13- Zach Reid
-14- Nathan O'Driscoll
-15- Heath Chapman
-16- Finlay Macrae
-17- Tom Powell
-18- Brayden Cook
-19- Bailey Laurie
-20- Liam Kolar
-21- Reef McInness - BID MATCHED
-22- Caleb Poulter
-23- Errol Gulden - BID MATCHED
-24- Brandon Walker - BID MATCHED
-25- Jack Carroll
-26- Jack Ginnivan
-27- Eddie Ford

ROUND 2

-28- Zavier Maher
-29- Blake Coleman - BID MATCHED
-30- Sam Berry
-31- Connor Stone
-32- Max Heath
-33- Liam McMahon
-34- Jake Bowey
-35- Conner Downie - BID MATCHED
-36- Oliver Davis
-37- Isiah Winder
-38- Cody Brand - BID MATCHED
-39- Lachlan Carrigan
-40- Zane Trew
-41- Taj Schofield - BID MATCHED
-42- Joel Western - BID MATCHED
-43- Seamus Mitchell
-44- Henry Smith

Round 3

-45- Maurice Rioli Jnr - BID MATCHED
-46- Corey Durdin
-47- Shannon Neale
-48- Ryan Angwin
-49- Kalin Lane
-50- Brodie Lake

ROUND 4

-51-Malachy Carruthers
-52- Fraser Rosman
-53- Luke Pedlar
-54- Matt Allison
-55- Jackson Callow
-56- Sam Collins

ROUND 5

-57-Jaiden Hunter
-58-Nicholas Stevens
-59- Pheonix Spicer

ROUND 6

-60- Harry Sharp

Would love Luke Pedlar at the Saints,talented player,but doubt he will be available as late as this Mock Draft suggests

 

[Dons4Life]

I think if the top 5 picks go as predicted, Perkins and Cox for the Bombers first 2 picks are no brainers only difference might be Reid if they prefer him (although I see him and Brand NGA) as playing the same role whereas Cox more likely CHB going forward. The final selection could go anyway.
Any reason you like Henry for us?? I worry about to many of the medium forward types ie: Langford, Laverde and would rather another pure mid or another tall.
My preference would be to trade down for a Carroll, O'Driscoll Poulter type.
Thoughts??

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Poulter

Too skinny for my liking.

Pass.

 

[Smythe]

Luke Pedl
Would love Luke Pedlar at the Saints,talented player,but doubt he will be available as late as this Mock Draft suggests

Agreed, he may not be and rumours suggest he won’t be. I hear Geelong has interest as well as Adelaide with one of their first 2 picks of second round.

 

[Smythe]

I think if the top 5 picks go as predicted, Perkins and Cox for the Bombers first 2 picks are no brainers only difference might be Reid if they prefer him (although I see him and Brand NGA) as playing the same role whereas Cox more likely CHB going forward. The final selection could go anyway.
Any reason you like Henry for us?? I worry about to many of the medium forward types ie: Langford, Laverde and would rather another pure mid or another tall.
My preference would be to trade down for a Carroll, O'Driscoll Poulter type.
Thoughts??

Dual capability fwd/def, excellent mark, big upside. All 3 are big chances at that last pick.

 

[Zavbla]

Luke Pedl
Would love Luke Pedlar at the Saints,talented player,but doubt he will be available as late as this Mock Draft suggests

Not sure Adelaide want that many mids

 

[scotteydog]

No Baldwin, do you think, he will be rookie'd instead?

 

[Smythe]

No Baldwin, do you think, he will be rookie'd instead?

Someone may take a risk on him but i think most would like to see how his body holds up against men, whether its in the reserves or seniors next year and for him to get some footy under his belt. He probably will get rookied, if not taken in the national draft, but i can see the point where most clubs may wait to see how he fares first then try to nab him in one of the mini drafts next year.

 

[bone2468]

Fremantle won’t select Henry, he’s already said after his contract is up he wants to head back to Geelong with his brother

 

[Smythe]

Thanks for a great year everyone, i was happy with my final first round phantom and with 46 points beat the likes of:
Herald Sun: 46 points
eDPS: 38 points
Draft Central: 37 points
Matt Balmer: 37 points
Knighta: 36 points
Cal Twomey: 36 points
Daniel Cherny: 35 points
It's not about that, but a little bragging rights is a good to put into the bank
It was a tough year and phantom to call and everyone did a great job. Looking forward to next year.
My 2021 top 20 kids will be posted in the coming days, there are a few already out on other threads so check them out.

 

[theGav56]

Thanks for a great year everyone, i was happy with my final first round phantom and with 46 points beat the likes of:
Herald Sun: 46 points
eDPS: 38 points
Draft Central: 37 points
Matt Balmer: 37 points
Knighta: 36 points
Cal Twomey: 36 points
Daniel Cherny: 35 points
It's not about that, but a little bragging rights is a good to put into the bank
It was a tough year and phantom to call and everyone did a great job. Looking forward to next year.
My 2021 top 20 kids will be posted in the coming days, there are a few already out on other threads so check them out.

Appreciated all the work you guys put in, and nothing wrong with a little bragging rights.