Review Tayte Pears or Cale Hooker

[The Prosecutor]

On actual output: Hooker > Pears > Carlisle
On potential: Carlisle > Pears > Hooker

Order I would take them: Carlisle > Hooker > Pears

The problem for Pears is that has shown anything for two odd years. Potential is all well and good, actual output wins you games however.

 

[Vtorians]

Not really sold on either, would trade if the right deal was on the table.

 

[Essendonia]

Time to get all the KPP on the park.

Hooker, Pears, Hurley and Gumbleton. These guys at 100% will dominate.

When you start adding Carlisle, Crameri, Daniher and remember Fletcher, there are no issues.

Get their bodies right, get their heads right. If Pears can regain his best and Carlisle develops, Hurley won't need to go back.

EDIT: Voted for Hooker, based on current output. He has done some good jobs, but feel he might eventually fall behind Pears and Carlisle, if the three are at the club in a couple of seasons' time.