- Thread starter
- #76
I'd prefer Bode for 2 than Bode for 6!
The tough trades
- Thread starter master bate
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2006
- Posts
- 9,080
- Reaction score
- 664
- Location
- Best Young Side Land
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Miami Heat
If Green and or Bruce can net us a 1st round draft pick, seeyalater.
Just wanting to throw some trade ideas. These are only ideas for suggestions. Please feel free to comment and or add. Thank you.
Trade Plan 1
Jeff White and Pick 67 (5th rounder) to Carlton for 4th rounder (Pick 56) as upgrade.
Trade Plan 2
Jeff White and Pick 67 (5th rounder) to Carlton for 3rd rounder (Pick 40) as upgrade - If worth that high.
Trade Plan 3
Jeff White to Carlton for 3rd rounder (Pick 40).
Trade Plan 4
Jamar to Port Adelaide for 3rd rounder (Pick 38). Jamar is South Australian and Port may need an experience ruckman.
Trade Plan 5
Jamar to Port Adelaide Port Adelaide's 3rd rounder (Pick 38) to Geelong. Geelong's Prismall to Melbourne - 3 way deal. (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 6
Melbourne's 3rd rounder (Pick 35) to Geelong for Prismall. (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 7
Melbourne's 2nd rounder (Pick 19) to Geelong for Prismall and their 3rd rounder (Pick 34). (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 8
Bode to Essendon for 4th rounder (Pick 55)
Trade Plan 9
Bode to Essendon. Essendon 4th rounder (Pick 55) to Geelong. Geelong's Tenance to Melbourne. (3 way deal)
Would Tenace be handy in the midfield based on his pace? The reason for this is MFC need midfielders with pace especially playing on AAMI and Subiaco ground. To win games at AAMI and Subiaco, the club should consider to recruit and or draft midfielders with pace - an area that could be a solution to break the horrible record at AAMI and Subiaco, the ground MFC is sick of losing.
Trade Plan 10
Meeson to Richmond for fourth rounder (Pick 58). Richmond may need young ruckman to replace Simmonds.
Trade Plan 11
Meeson and Melboune's fifth rounder (Pick 67) to Richmond for 3rd rounder (Pick 42) as upgrade.
Trade Plan 12
Meeson to Richmond. Richmond's fourth rounder (Pick 58) to West Coast. West Coast's Matt Rosa to Melbourne - 3 way deal.
Is Matt Rosa a good fit in the MFC midfield?
Trade Plan 1
Jeff White and Pick 67 (5th rounder) to Carlton for 4th rounder (Pick 56) as upgrade.
Trade Plan 2
Jeff White and Pick 67 (5th rounder) to Carlton for 3rd rounder (Pick 40) as upgrade - If worth that high.
Trade Plan 3
Jeff White to Carlton for 3rd rounder (Pick 40).
Trade Plan 4
Jamar to Port Adelaide for 3rd rounder (Pick 38). Jamar is South Australian and Port may need an experience ruckman.
Trade Plan 5
Jamar to Port Adelaide Port Adelaide's 3rd rounder (Pick 38) to Geelong. Geelong's Prismall to Melbourne - 3 way deal. (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 6
Melbourne's 3rd rounder (Pick 35) to Geelong for Prismall. (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 7
Melbourne's 2nd rounder (Pick 19) to Geelong for Prismall and their 3rd rounder (Pick 34). (If Prismall is required)
Trade Plan 8
Bode to Essendon for 4th rounder (Pick 55)
Trade Plan 9
Bode to Essendon. Essendon 4th rounder (Pick 55) to Geelong. Geelong's Tenance to Melbourne. (3 way deal)
Would Tenace be handy in the midfield based on his pace? The reason for this is MFC need midfielders with pace especially playing on AAMI and Subiaco ground. To win games at AAMI and Subiaco, the club should consider to recruit and or draft midfielders with pace - an area that could be a solution to break the horrible record at AAMI and Subiaco, the ground MFC is sick of losing.
Trade Plan 10
Meeson to Richmond for fourth rounder (Pick 58). Richmond may need young ruckman to replace Simmonds.
Trade Plan 11
Meeson and Melboune's fifth rounder (Pick 67) to Richmond for 3rd rounder (Pick 42) as upgrade.
Trade Plan 12
Meeson to Richmond. Richmond's fourth rounder (Pick 58) to West Coast. West Coast's Matt Rosa to Melbourne - 3 way deal.
Is Matt Rosa a good fit in the MFC midfield?
My quick thoughts:
- White is out of contract next year, so could leave the club for nothing. Don't reckon he'd screw us around, so maybe a 4th or 5th round pick would arise.
- No one would be stilly enough to pick up Meesen - he has been at two clubs and shown f@ck all. Maybe he could try to qualify for the London Olympics as a decathlete or something.
- I don't think Bode's exactly on the top of every clubs wish list after struggling all year in a club that's won three games.
- Jamar is an interesting one and may be in demand from clubs with shite ruck stocks. Not sure what he'd be worth but might be a good trade if we can get a 3rd round pick (esp if we get Warnock in the PSD).
- Would be happy to pick up Primsall as long as we don't move the world to get him. (Trade plan 6 or 7 seem to be OK; not sure what the Cats would think).
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2008
- Posts
- 1,064
- Reaction score
- 247
- Location
- Melbourne
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Ivanhoe
Jeff White - If carlton pick him up they won't want to trade much for him, but after a quick look at their list I don't see them delisting/retiring to many players so they might just take the required minimum of three picks, so if they were to trade off say their 3rd rounder for our 4th and White, they wouldn't be losing out to much, eg, White + pick 51 for pick 40.
Jamar to port could happen, port will be looking at Seaby, however Jamar will have a lower asking price so if the eagles want port's second round we could give them Jamar for their 3rd, although we'd probably want more than around pick 37 for him.
Bode - Why would Essendon want him? If they did want him pick 55 would be about right.
We would not want tenace, he has pace yes, but running like lightning doesn't help if you can't hit a target at speed.
No one would want Meesen, However, we would definitely go for Rosa, however WC would want a pick in the 30's minimum...
Similar threads
