top 10 players since 1990?

[The Nostradamus]

Rough list

carey
Ablett
Ablett
Lockett
Silvagni
Scarlett
Judd
Voss
Williams
Goodes or Cox maybe

Think I’m position bias and that while silvagni and Scarlett are good full backs I’m taking other players ahead of them

I’d have buddy sneaking in the 10 along with Goodes and Aker

I also think the games record holder boomer is still widely underrated

 

[Seeds]

ablett
carey
ablett
williams
voss
franklin
scarlett
judd
lockett
hird

just falling short: dunstall, mcleod, cox.

players who when their career is done may make it in: martin, fyfe, dangerfield.

 

[Seeds]

Think I’m position bias and that while silvagni and Scarlett are good full backs I’m taking other players ahead of them

I’d have buddy sneaking in the 10 along with Goodes and Aker

I also think the games record holder boomer is still widely underrated

Missing from that list is Hird, martin, fyfe, mcleod, buckley, robert harvey. Are you seriously rating boomer better then all those players?

there is another 20 i would put in ahead of boomer.

 

[PhatBoy]

You also forgot Hird

No I didn’t.

 

[PhatBoy]

Think I’m position bias and that while silvagni and Scarlett are good full backs I’m taking other players ahead of them

I’d have buddy sneaking in the 10 along with Goodes and Aker

I also think the games record holder boomer is still widely underrated

that’s fair, in general if someone offers me a good mid or forward or ruck over a good fullback i take them, I just think those two in particular were so good at their role, that they’re worthy of the spot