List Mgmt. Trade and F/A 2020 Cont’d

[No SPIN]

A contract is a contract, and the days he is rumoured to have requested to live in Qld, he still is an employee of the footy club, and gets paid. He still will be training and playing, so why wouldn't he be paid for the contract he signed?

You're correct a contract is a contract, but 2-3 days away from the club is a MAJOR variation to the contract.
Such a variation would void a contract normally, and/or at least be the subject of re-negotiation, hence my question on why AFLPA/AFL would not allow renegotiation.

 

[manicpie]

Standby Treloar +16 + Phillips for 4 + 24 + Breust.

Going to make me vomit seeing Adz in that jumper.

Is that fact? Because I would take that

 

[Apex36]

Is that fact? Because I would take that

Definitely not fact. Just another Matt_352 fantasy. No way they’d throw in Breust in that deal under the circumstances.

 

[TradeDraft]

 

[left at home]

I would be expecting her to play for the Firebirds, at least 2 years.

That’s the clubs and her hope, she did say she could have three yrs left at the top competition. She wants to play again for Australia, so she is not moving here for one season

 

[10571z]

Standby Treloar +16 + Phillips for 4 + 24 + Breust.

Going to make me vomit seeing Adz in that jumper.

Would take that in a second. Surely Hawks wouldn’t

 

[Da Main Man]

Standby Treloar +16 + Phillips for 4 + 24 + Breust.

breaking it down it it could be seen as

Philips for 24

Treloar + 16 for 4 + Breust

 

[Matt_352]

breaking it down it it could be seen as

Philips for 24

Treloar + 16 for 4 + Breust

Yeah a bit one sided :/ How about Treloar + 16 + Phillips for 4 + 24

 

[Da Main Man]

Yeah a bit one sided :/ How about Treloar + 16 + Phillips for 4 + 24

hawks get their 1st rounder (mandatory), winger and outside mid.

we get salary respite, pick 4 and a 2nd rounder to help with reef.

 

[Matthew_13]

Won’t I don’t understand is if Collingwood knew there where going to have such issues with there salary gap, why did we bring back Cox to play footy in 2020 to allow him to reach triggers for a 550k 2021 contract? Surely would have ensured he didn’t play again to free up that coin

 

[TradeDraft]

Won’t I don’t understand is if Collingwood knew there where going to have such issues with there salary gap, why did we bring back Cox to play footy in 2020 to allow him to reach triggers for a 550k 2021 contract? Surely would have ensured he didn’t play again to free up that coin

God Know and I don't think our List Mangement team don't either

 

[AndrewShawble]

Strangely enough I think Treloars best shot at a flag is GC over Hawks/Dogs.

Gold Coast have some pieces coming together, albeit a few years away.

 

[Matt_352]

Strangely enough I think Treloars best shot at a flag is GC over Hawks/Dogs.

Gold Coast have some pieces coming together, albeit a few years away.

Doesn't want QLD tho

 

[Matt_352]

Won’t I don’t understand is if Collingwood knew there where going to have such issues with there salary gap, why did we bring back Cox to play footy in 2020 to allow him to reach triggers for a 550k 2021 contract? Surely would have ensured he didn’t play again to free up that coin

That would require a footy dept with brains

 

[Thefly38]

breaking it down it it could be seen as

Philips for 24

Treloar + 16 for 4 + Breust

Make the 2nd round a Future 2nd

then trade 2021 first to the highest bidder.

 

[frizzle]

Make the 2nd round a Future 2nd

then trade 2021 first to the highest bidder.

It's possible we may hang on to our 2021 first rounder for next year. Clubs may pay more for it before next years draft?

 

[Matt_352]

It's possible we may hang on to our 2021 first rounder for next year. Clubs may pay more for it before next years draft?

I think I would to be honest because I think it will be a single digit pick.

 

[mike123]

The lack of exposed form, will be a true test of Hine and the quality of our scouting pre COVID.

Hine loves lack of exposed form

 

[Soups]

Won’t I don’t understand is if Collingwood knew there where going to have such issues with there salary gap, why did we bring back Cox to play footy in 2020 to allow him to reach triggers for a 550k 2021 contract? Surely would have ensured he didn’t play again to free up that coin

Or you know, don’t believe everything you read in the papers...

 

[Da Main Man]

would love to see picks 1 - 18 become untouchable/unmovable/untradeable i.e. cant be moved by free agency or priority picks or anything. every club must make a first round draft selection based on ladder position. Trading future first rounders seems to mess us around more than most clubs in terms of we overpay. almost like we get overly excited when we find an extra 50 in our wallet.

Beams - Pick No. 18, 56 and a future first-round pick
Adz - Pick no. 7, 65 and future first-rounder in 2016

 

[mike123]

What’s wrong with this 22

Madgen Roughead Noble
Crisp Moore Howe
Daicos Maynard Quaynor
Elliot Mihocek de Goey
Sidebottom Cox WHE
Grundy Adams Pendlebury

extended interchange to round out a core 25 or so players for 2021:
Greenwood, Keane, Kelly, Mayne, Murphy, Cameron, Sier, C Brown, T Brown.

How long do we have?

 

[TradeDraft]

Doesn't want QLD tho

Then I guess its his Salary why we want to Trade Him OFF as with that Stance you think we would Keep Treloar

 

[Aishole]

would love to see picks 1 - 18 become untouchable/unmovable/untradeable i.e. cant be moved by free agency or priority picks or anything. every club must make a first round draft selection based on ladder position. Trading future first rounders seems to mess us around more than most clubs in terms of we overpay. almost like we get overly excited when we find an extra 50 in our wallet.

Beams - Pick No. 18, 56 and a future first-round pick
Adz - Pick no. 7, 65 and future first-rounder in 2016

Wait, You’d like to see them change the rules because 1 club out of 18 has had 2 trades where they’ve ended up trading fairly high future high picks?

 

[Da Main Man]

Wait, You’d like to see them change the rules because 1 club out of 18 has had 2 trades where they’ve ended up trading fairly high future high picks?

no I don't like the idea of every team having to wait on every other team to see what picks they have based on free agency, ladder position (for future picks), and trades. its crap. i just used two relevant examples that are currently causing our salary cap issues.

locking in the first round makes each team accountable for scouting and puts the onus back on the coaches developing talent as opposed to waiting on other teams players to start breaking out.

 

[partypie]

Read Hawks have to use their 1st round pick this year.
Trelaor & Phillips as a package? For what in return....?

The upshot is that we can't do any trade with the Hawks directly unless they obtain another first round pick from somewhere.

We need a pick inside the top 5 if we're to snag one of the top group of draft prospects in this year's draft, so the Hawks would have to give us pick 4 or we're just wasting our time.

Our best hope for a decent return is still the Suns with pick 5, but Adam has to want to go there for that to happen.