List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2020

[nahnah]

Worth more then 1 1st Rounder Though

more than pick 5? think its about right, especially considering we are the ones wanting to trade him out

 

[Matt_352]

more than pick 5? think its about right, especially considering we are the ones wanting to trade him out

Worth atleast 5 + Wright/Brodie

 

[nahnah]

Worth atleast 5 + Wright/Brodie

well yes because they have no value

 

[Matt_352]

well yes because they have no value

Wright be a slight upgrade on Cox

 

[partypie]

I don't think they can trade next years first

The one pick they can't trade away at this point is the supplementary beginning of second round pick in next year's draft, as this pick is subject to AFL house review prior to the 2021 trade period.

Their 2021 pick is definitely in play even if they also trade out pick 5 this year, as they obviously used first round picks in 2018 and 2019, meaning that the "two first round picks used in the current 4 year window" requirement will automatically be met for both this year and next year.

 

[partypie]

we need someone to replace varcoe..

A cooked 31 year old former lockdown small defender who can't defend anymore isn't what we need.

 

[Apex36]

I don't think they can trade next years first

Yes they can, they can’t trade the end of first round priority pick they have.

 

[stormskye]

A cooked 31 year old former lockdown small defender who can't defend anymore isn't what we need.

That’s his point

 

[gouki88]

Worth more then 1 1st Rounder Though

Yeah, I think 5 plus Brodie or Wright is worth looking at in a vacuum. Don't view this deal in a vacuum though, given all that's going on. Wright and Brodie do have some value

 

[JB007]

You should avoid it then.

 

[unplugged]

3-way

Pies gain: Pick 4, Pick 5, GCS Future Second
Pies lose: Treloar, Phillips, Pick 14, Future First, Future Third

Hawks gain: Phillips, Pick 14, Pies' Future First
Hawks lose: Pick 4

Gold Coast gain: Treloar, Pies Future Third
Gold Coast lose: Pick 5, Future Second

Who loses

 

[AndrewShawble]

Geel helping our Cameron case

 

[Matt_352]

Geelong better fooking win next week

 

[Vicky Park]

Re Treloar, I haven’t been convinced of his worth, but he played some good games in the back half of this season. The West Coast final stands out.

But we have to get ruthless. Keeping him because he’s a good bloke, in a difficult situation with his partner, needs our support, etc? No. It’s not enough. We’ve kept too many on our list in the past for the wrong reasons. Being nice will not win us a flag. We are treading water and we have to make some changes that will hurt. Tough love.

 

[stormskye]

Re Treloar, I haven’t been convinced of his worth, but he played some good games in the back half of this season. The West Coast final stands out.

But we have to get ruthless. Keeping him because he’s a good bloke, in a difficult situation with his partner, needs our support, etc? No. It’s not enough. We’ve kept too many on our list in the past for the wrong reasons. Being nice will not win us a flag. We are treading water and we have to make some changes that will hurt. Tough love.

100%. We haven’t been good enough, we need to make some changes to become the best. not tread water “thereabouts”

 

[mike123]

That’s his point

It’s more annoying then funny at this point

 

[Jafo]

Geel helping our Cameron case

After we bailed out last week, I couldn’t pick a sentimental winner of the flag. Maybe Port very slightly if I had to. Tigers because they’ve become too smug, Cats coz I still remember 2011/last week and so much more, Lions for 2002/2003. I honestly can’t barrack for either Tigers or Cats next week and not want to vomit.

 

[stormskye]

After we bailed out last week, I couldn’t pick a sentimental winner of the flag. Maybe Port very slightly if I had to. Tigers because they’ve become too smug, Cats coz I still remember 2011/last week and so much more, Lions for 2002/2003. So it’s hard to barrack for either Tigers or Cats next week.

I’ll take geel over rich winning a 3rd any day. Rich supporters are something else

 

[Matt_352]

After we bailed out last week, I couldn’t pick a sentimental winner of the flag. Maybe Port very slightly if I had to. Tigers because they’ve become too smug, Cats coz I still remember 2011/last week and so much more, Lions for 2002/2003. So it’s hard to barrack for either Tigers or Cats next week.

Richmond are ****ING SCUM. GO CATS!!!

 

[left at home]

We were told all year we'd try to trade into the first round. Did people just think we were going to bunch together a group of C graders?

Way some on here do trade mock ups, yes they do

 

[Daniel J]

Vale, guy with 28 posts. Your contributions will be missed.

Vale, guy with 28 posts. Your contributions will be missed.

Well enjoy paying membership to a club who will just top up the list to make sure they make finals so everyone can keep there jobs. God help the next coach when he takes over the most unbalanced, oldest, and worst list in the league.

 

[bunter]

Well enjoy paying membership to a club who will just top up the list to make sure they make finals so everyone can keep there jobs. God help the next coach when he takes over the most unbalanced, oldest, and worst list in the league.

29 posts now

 

[AndrewShawble]

Well enjoy paying membership to a club who will just top up the list to make sure they make finals so everyone can keep there jobs. God help the next coach when he takes over the most unbalanced, oldest, and worst list in the league.

 

[Hong Kong Pie]

I am far from happy about it, but i will certainly be supporting Geelong to win the GF, because there is no effing way on God's green earth that i will support Richmond.

 

[Markfs]

A cooked 31 year old former lockdown small defender who can't defend anymore isn't what we need.

but we need someone indigenous to replace varcoe..