Media Transparency in BEEZ Voting.

[WaynesWorld19]

Engagement comes in more forms than spamming the board with gifs

Clever gif's ok though .......gotta do something to "wake the dead" in some match threads

 

[Yakker]

So Barry, you decided to change the criteria behind the voting system did you ?

This was the official guidelines: ....the keyword is "engagement" ....that's two way engagement

.

Engagement comes in more forms than spamming the board with gifs

"As someone who has been nominated by your committee representative as someone who has been actively engaged in various aspects of the league on a consistent basis over the course of this season. You have been given the opportunity to vote on the MVP award for Season 26 to determine who has been the best posting contributor to the Sweet FA forum.

The process is simple:

• list in this PM 20 posters whom in your opinion to be the best posters to the Sweet FA - Ranked 1st to 20th (1st will be allocated 40 votes, 2nd = 37 votes, 3rd = 35 votes ... until 20th = 1 vote).
• For clarity this list should be who you objectively believe to be the best contributors to the Sweet FA for Season 26, not simply a list of who you 'like' the most, it's not a popularity contest.
• For this season we are not taking self votes.

"


Now if the voting parameters change to those that "contribute" to the league then maybe some lists might change

 

[Barrybran]

"As someone who has been nominated by your committee representative as someone who has been actively engaged in various aspects of the league on a consistent basis over the course of this season. You have been given the opportunity to vote on the MVP award for Season 26 to determine who has been the best posting contributor to the Sweet FA forum.

The process is simple:

• list in this PM 20 posters whom in your opinion to be the best posters to the Sweet FA - Ranked 1st to 20th (1st will be allocated 40 votes, 2nd = 37 votes, 3rd = 35 votes ... until 20th = 1 vote).
• For clarity this list should be who you objectively believe to be the best contributors to the Sweet FA for Season 26, not simply a list of who you 'like' the most, it's not a popularity contest.
• For this season we are not taking self votes.

"


Now if the voting parameters change to those that "contribute" to the league then maybe some lists might change

That's fairly likely

 

[WaynesWorld19]

"As someone who has been nominated by your committee representative as someone who has been actively engaged in various aspects of the league on a consistent basis over the course of this season. You have been given the opportunity to vote on the MVP award for Season 26 to determine who has been the best posting contributor to the Sweet FA forum.

The process is simple:

• list in this PM 20 posters whom in your opinion to be the best posters to the Sweet FA - Ranked 1st to 20th (1st will be allocated 40 votes, 2nd = 37 votes, 3rd = 35 votes ... until 20th = 1 vote).
• For clarity this list should be who you objectively believe to be the best contributors to the Sweet FA for Season 26, not simply a list of who you 'like' the most, it's not a popularity contest.
• For this season we are not taking self votes.

"


Now if the voting parameters change to those that "contribute" to the league then maybe some lists might change

Thanks ....I should have said Posting Engagement, but you've clarified my point to Barrybran

 

[WaynesWorld19]

That's fairly likely

What do you mean by fairly likely? .....they were the guidelines, which you strayed from

 

[Barrybran]

What do you mean by fairly likely? .....they were the guidelines, which you strayed from

Auditioning for a gig on 60 Minutes, huh?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Auditioning for a gig on 60 Minutes, huh?

Yeah, it's fun ......someone's gotta keep the plebs honest

 

[Ant Bear]

Extra 20 votes up for grabs

Cost myself 2nd place, if disclosed votes are anything to go by

 

[Fizzler]

All of my beez voting next season will be based purely on those that multi-quote, so far Agent93 is the only one getting votes.

THB Leaked Beez list S27
1. Agent93
2. Fizzler

You’re my new hero.

Thanks Halfie #beezhunt

 

[U2tigers]

"As someone who has been nominated by your committee representative as someone who has been actively engaged in various aspects of the league on a consistent basis over the course of this season. You have been given the opportunity to vote on the MVP award for Season 26 to determine who has been the best posting contributor to the Sweet FA forum.

The process is simple:

• list in this PM 20 posters whom in your opinion to be the best posters to the Sweet FA - Ranked 1st to 20th (1st will be allocated 40 votes, 2nd = 37 votes, 3rd = 35 votes ... until 20th = 1 vote).
• For clarity this list should be who you objectively believe to be the best contributors to the Sweet FA for Season 26, not simply a list of who you 'like' the most, it's not a popularity contest.
• For this season we are not taking self votes.

"


Now if the voting parameters change to those that "contribute" to the league then maybe some lists might change

If only people read that properly, I could have come 19th

 

[Broken]

I think I'll pimp out my votes for next seasons medal. Might turn it in to a game.

 

[This Is Anfield]

I think I'll pimp out my votes for next seasons medal. Might turn it in to a game.

You want to use my wrinkly old bum in exchange for votes?

 

[Broken]

You want to use my wrinkly old bum in exchange for votes?

Sounds like a deal.

 

[manangatang]

Sounds like a deal.

You obviously need a new pencil case.

 

[TedDougChris]

I think I'll pimp out my votes for next seasons medal. Might turn it in to a game.

Make it a media piece for next season. Each week people via for a spot on your Beez list, then a last minute/finals theme where the places are decided in order from 1 to 20......

 

[Broken]

Make it a media piece for next season. Each week people via for a spot on your Beez list, then a last minute/finals theme where the places are decided in order from 1 to 20......

Sounds like a plan. Might call it Who wants to be a beez medallist?

 

[TedDougChris]

Sounds like a plan. Might call it Who wants to be a beez medallist?

Subtitled ‘Selling my soul to the Broken man’.......

 

[WaynesWorld19]

If only people read that properly, I could have come 19th

Given many decided to "reward" posters, rather than vote on posting merit .......you have a strong case of injustice having been done to you !

 

[Ned_Flanders]

"As someone who has been nominated by your committee representative as someone who has been actively engaged in various aspects of the league on a consistent basis over the course of this season. You have been given the opportunity to vote on the MVP award for Season 26 to determine who has been the best posting contributor to the Sweet FA forum.

The process is simple:

• list in this PM 20 posters whom in your opinion to be the best posters to the Sweet FA - Ranked 1st to 20th (1st will be allocated 40 votes, 2nd = 37 votes, 3rd = 35 votes ... until 20th = 1 vote).
• For clarity this list should be who you objectively believe to be the best contributors to the Sweet FA for Season 26, not simply a list of who you 'like' the most, it's not a popularity contest.
• For this season we are not taking self votes.

"


Now if the voting parameters change to those that "contribute" to the league then maybe some lists might change

Good post, and it highlights one important point - we all differ on what we consider "good posting"

That's cool though, because if it was narrower we would exclude some potential valued contributors to the league

Only change I would possibly make is opening up the voter base, so as to ensure the sampling is genuinely representative (rather than relying on capts to do this). Something like anyone who posted in 12 games gets a vote

 

[JT_the_Man]

Good post, and it highlights one important point - we all differ on what we consider "good posting"

That's cool though, because if it was narrower we would exclude some potential valued contributors to the league

Only change I would possibly make is opening up the voter base, so as to ensure the sampling is genuinely representative (rather than relying on capts to do this). Something like anyone who posted in 12 games gets a vote

Voting was open to everyone a few seasons ago, and tbh I preferred it that way.

 

[Yakker]

Good post, and it highlights one important point - we all differ on what we consider "good posting"

That's cool though, because if it was narrower we would exclude some potential valued contributors to the league

Only change I would possibly make is opening up the voter base, so as to ensure the sampling is genuinely representative (rather than relying on capts to do this). Something like anyone who posted in 12 games gets a vote

It's not only the captains who vote. The captain from each club gets to nominate 5 players from their club to vote. 12 teams of 5 voters means 60 different points of view. Given most teams don't have too many more than 5 fully "immersed" players I think it is a reasonable cross section. But hey, I'm a not so humble fisherman and it's only my opinion.

 

[Ned_Flanders]

It's not only the captains who vote. The captain from each club gets to nominate 5 players from their club to vote. 12 teams of 5 voters means 60 different points of view. Given most teams don't have too many more than 5 fully "immersed" players I think it is a reasonable cross section. But hey, I'm a not so humble fisherman and it's only my opinion.

I know, I was one of the furies five

Reality is the criteria each capt uses to pick their five will differ, and may skew the sample pool from being genuinely representative of the total SFA population

Esp if the captain is a s**t truck like NaturalDisaster !!!!

 

[NaturalDisaster]

I know, I was one of the furies five

Reality is the criteria each capt uses to pick their five will differ, and may skew the sample pool from being genuinely representative of the total SFA population

Esp if the captain is a s**t truck like NaturalDisaster !!!!

You make a good point.

I should never have picked you.

 

[Dav]

I would be wary of making it everyone as that will obviously skew the votes towards older and more experienced players. I like the 12 thread suggestion.

 

[JT_the_Man]

I would be wary of making it everyone as that will obviously skew the votes towards older and more experienced players. I like the 12 thread suggestion.

It worked last time.