Which club lost the trade period?

[living_in_syd]

What a last day of trading that was and a lot of lopsided deals at the death. With the success of clubs in previous years improving their lists through trading, it appears there was a lot of pressure on some list managers to get 'something' done.

As the opposite of the other thread, who do you think paid overs or lost the trade period and why?



Adelaide Crows
In: Bryce Gibbs, Sam Gibson, pick 12, pick 39, pick 77, Melbourne’s 2018 first-round pick, Carlton’s 2018 second-round pick, Carlton’s 2018 third-round pick, Melbourne’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Out: Jake Lever, Charlie Cameron, Harrison Wigg, pick 16, pick 54, pick 73, pick 91, Adelaide’s 2018 second-round pick, Adelaide’s 2018 third-round pick, Adelaide’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Brisbane Lions
In: Charlie Cameron, Luke Hodge, pick 15, pick 18, pick 40, pick 44.

Out: Tom Rockliff, Josh Schache, pick 12, pick 20, pick 43, pick 75.

Carlton Blues
In: Matthew Kennedy, Darcy Lang, Matthew Lobbe, pick 10, pick 30, pick 73, Bulldogs’ 2018 second-round pick, Adelaide’s 2018 second-round pick, Geelong’s 2018 second-round pick.

Out: Bryce Gibbs, pick 40, pick 58, pick 95, Carlton’s 2018 second-round pick, Carlton’s 2018 third-round pick, Carlton’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Collingwood Magpies
In: Sam Murray, pick 70, Sydney’s 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Collingwood’s 2018 second-round pick.

Essendon Bombers
In: Jake Stringer, Devon Smith, Adam Saad, GWS’ 2018 second-round pick.

Out: Pick 11, pick 30, Essendon’s 2018 second-round pick, Essendon’s 2018 third-round pick.

Fremantle Dockers
In: Nathan Wilson, Brandon Matera, pick 2, pick 66, pick 71, pick 83.

Out: Lachie Weller, Harley Balic, Hayden Crozier, Fremantle’s 2018 second-round pick, Fremantle’s 2018 third-round pick, Fremantle’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Geelong Cats
In: Gary Ablett, pick 24, pick 58, Richmond’s 2018 third-round pick, Gold Coast’s 2018 fourth-round pick, Carlton’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Out: Steven Motlop, Darcy Lang, pick 53, Geelong’s 2018 second-round pick, Geelong’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Gold Coast Suns
In: Lachie Weller, Aaron Young, Harrison Wigg, pick 19, pick 41, pick 50, pick 54, West Coast’s 2018 first-round pick, Essendon’s 2018 second-round pick, Geelong’s 2018 second-round pick, Fremantle’s 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Gary Ablett, Adam Saad, Brandon Matera, pick 2, pick 21, pick 24, pick 26, pick 37, Gold Coast’s 2016 second-round pick.

GWS Giants
In: Pick 11, pick 28, pick 57, Fremantle’s 2018 second-round pick, Essendon’s 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Devon Smith, Nathan Wilson, Matthew Kennedy, pick 25, pick 71, GWS’ 2018 second-round pick.

Hawthorn Hawks
In: Jarman Impey, pick 43, pick 68, pick 75.

Out: Luke Hodge, pick 34, pick 44, pick 62, Hawthorn’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Melbourne Demons
In: Jake Lever, Harley Balic, pick 31, pick 36, Adelaide’s 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Jack Watts, pick 10, pick 66, Melbourne’s 2018 first-round pick, Melbourne’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

North Melbourne Kangaroos
In: Pick 91, St Kilda’s 2018 third-round pick, West Coasts’ 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Sam Gibson, pick 46, North Melbourne’s 2018 third-round pick.

Port Adelaide Power
In: Tom Rockliff, Steven Motlop, Jack Watts, pick 46, pick 59, pick 62, pick 63, pick 95, St Kilda’s 2018 second-round pick, North Melbourne’s 2018 third-round pick.

Out: Jackson Trengove, Jarman Impey, Brendon Ah Chee, Aaron Young, Logan Austin, Matthew Lobbe, pick 31, Porth Adelaide’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Richmond Tigers
In: Pick 20, pick 25, pick 53.

Out: Pick 15, Richmond’s 2018 third-round pick.

St Kilda Saints
In: Logan Austin, pick 34, Port Adelaide’s 2018 fourth-round pick, Adelaide’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Out: Pick 59, pick 63, St Kilda’s 2018 second-round pick, St Kilda’s 2018 third-round pick.

Sydney Swans
In: Collingwood’s 2018 second-round pick.

Out: Sam Murray, pick 70 and Sydney’s 2018 third-round pick.

West Coast Eagles
In: Brendon Ah Chee, pick 21, pick 26, pick 37, Gold Coast’s 2018 second-round pick, Hawthorn’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Out: Pick 50, West Coast’s 2018 first-round pick, West Coast’s 2018 third-round pick.

Western Bulldogs
In: Josh Schache, Jackson Trengove, Hayden Crozier, pick 16, Fremantle’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

Out: Jake Stringer, pick 28, pick 41, pick 83, Bulldogs’ 2018 second-round pick.

 

[SterlingArcher]

Any of them at this stage.

 

[JayJ20]

North I'd say. For a rebuilding side after failing to land Dusty and Kelly, they only have 1 pick in the top 20 without adding anything next year either.

 

[Scythe94]

Has to be Collingwood.

Regardless of how good next year’s draft is, spending a second round pick (likely to be around 22-25) on a rookie-listed player is absolutely bizarre.

 

[RUNVS]

Brisbane and Gold Coast did not really set the world on fire today.

 

[Lemma]

North I'd say. For a rebuilding side after failing to land Dusty and Kelly, they only have 1 pick in the top 20 without adding anything next year either.

We did add an extra pick next year but I agree. Not thrilled with us

 

[The Donners]

North I'd say. For a rebuilding side after failing to land Dusty and Kelly, they only have 1 pick in the top 20 without adding anything next year either.

I understand where you're coming from but they have few players on their list with high trade value other than Ziebell, possibly Goldstein and Higgins.

Right at this moment, they're in a difficult position. They didn't have their age spread at all right and now they're suffering. Brad Scott has remained as any new coach would be on a hiding to nothing.

 

[Jaeger]

I can't understand trading pick 2 for Weller.

 

[The Donners]

Has to be Collingwood.

Regardless of how good next year’s draft is, spending a second round pick (likely to be around 22-25) on a rookie-listed player is absolutely bizarre.

I think Brisbane spending big on a another club's second best goalsneak and despite not hitting his straps yet, losing a former pick no. 2 for a 2nd round and a 3rd round makes them the winner on this list.

 

[Malifice]

Gold coast and North. Reasons obvious. Collingwood right up there with a bizzare Boekhoest like trade.

Lions got ripped off with Schache and overpaid for Cameron, but have the currency to spare.

 

[doppleganger]

Hawthorn Hawks
In: Jarman Impey, pick 43, pick 68, pick 75.

Out: Luke Hodge, pick 34, pick 44, pick 62, Hawthorn’s 2018 fourth-round pick.

I thought the Pies, but then I saw Hawthorn!!

Hodge for Impey - a downgrade in playing talent
34 for 43 - a downgrade
44 for 68 - a downgrade
62 for 75 - a downgrade

To top it off also offloaded a 2018 pick!

Playing list weaker and made their drafting position worse off. What the feck is that??

 

[Bardo State]

I thought the Pies, but then I saw Hawthorn!!

Hodge for Impey - a downgrade in playing talent
34 for 43 - a downgrade
44 for 68 - a downgrade
62 for 75 - a downgrade

To top it off also offloaded a 2018 pick!

Playing list weaker and made their drafting position worse off. What the feck is that??

You realise Hodge was retiring, right?

 

[blitzer]

Hawks: Out Hodge In Impey. That's pretty sad.

Adelaide: Lost Lever and Cameron and gained Gibbs but at a massive cost of draft picks. That's a flag contender that at best is about equal list strength to 2018, probably a bit worse and lost a fair bit of draft currency.

North/Collingwood - Didn't do anything that will make them significantly better in the future. North getting rid of Gibson was interesting. Not good interesting - just interesting.

 

[doppleganger]

You realise Hodge was retiring, right?

He still came 3rd in your BnF, and a good chance of giving as good if not better output to Brisbane than what Impey gives to the Hawks.

Out Hodge In Impey....ouch

 

[Noobz0r]

I really don't think we should be counting Hodge in this discussion, he wasn't playing for Hawthorn next year anyway.

If that's the case, West Coast got reamed by not getting anything for Priddis and Mitchell.

 

[demondavey]

I can't understand trading pick 2 for Weller.

I didn't think he was that good? Is he worth that?

 

[Bardo State]

He still came 3rd in your BnF, and a good chance of giving as good if not better output to Brisbane than what Impey gives to the Hawks.

Out Hodge In Impey....ouch

If you want to play that game, we're also out Gibson. A multiple best and fairest winner. What a blunder.

Hodge was going to retire. Instead, he joined Brisbane for some junk picks. Seems pretty reasonable, eh? And the good thing about Impey is that he didn't already retire. In fact, he's 22. Might have something to do with his higher trade value. As opposed to, you know, a guy that wasn't going to be on the list anyway.

It's not like Hawthorn gave up an early second round pick in a good draft for a rookie that hasn't played above NEAFL level...

 

[demondavey]

Adelaide giving two first rounders for Gibbs is up there. The only justification is that they are a massive flag chance and don't need to stress on draft picks. Their time is now. Still, it's a big trade.

 

[living_in_syd]

I understand where you're coming from but they have few players on their list with high trade value other than Ziebell, possibly Goldstein and Higgins.

Right at this moment, they're in a difficult position. They didn't have their age spread at all right and now they're suffering. Brad Scott has remained as any new coach would be on a hiding to nothing.

Has to make a decision. Are they resetting or not? I would have traded out Golstein. They have Pruess and cant play both. Surely goldstein would have got a late first or a couple of second rounders. Unless they paying a mountain of cash and no one wanted him?

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Quite a few teams did next to nothing

 

[BEEG]

Has to be Collingwood.

Regardless of how good next year’s draft is, spending a second round pick (likely to be around 22-25) on a rookie-listed player is absolutely bizarre.

Will be good to bump when Crows get a top 5 pick from the future 1st you gave up for the back pocket.

 

[jwint43]

Depending on who the Saints manage to grab with 7/8, it could well be us. Collingwood and North probably right now though.

 

[ZEV]

I can't understand trading pick 2 for Weller.

Probably going to need a new captain at the end of next season and most of their good first round picks are at other clubs now

 

[Snake_Baker]

How do you turn a 3rd round pick in to 2 x 3rd round picks and lose?

 

[Deep]

Lang and Motlop out the door with two other B22 players retiring in Mackie and Lonergan only to bring in Ablett in the second coming of Jesus

Shitty trade period.

Only Port, Essendon, Freo and Dogs did well.