Which would you rather on your sides list: Murphy vs Thomas

[socrates]

until u hear collingwood fans raving and ranting about penders on how brilliant he is, i sugguest u shut up about walker until he delivers.
also i would be hugely disspoined if my club picked up a number 2 draft pick and he turned out to be a tagger. the top 20 picks are usually reserved for future stars, not solid taggers. so dont kid urself by saying he did great jobs on stars of the game, that doesnt represent any ability of him being a future star what so ever.

back to the topic... both players look like they will have a very successful career ahead. i must admitt i was suprised that collingwood opted for thomas at #2, but now that initial worry has turned into great optimism for young daisy thomas. looks to be a good catch. murphy aswell will be a very solid contributor to a struggling midfield.

 

[Grimreepah]

What you basing that on?

How can you tell Thomas is going to be inconsistent?

Because he capable of doing brilliant things?

That doesn't make him inconsistent.

Dude. It was just his opinion. At this stage all you can do is guess.

 

[Silvagnis]

until u hear collingwood fans raving and ranting about penders on how brilliant he is, i sugguest u shut up about walker until he delivers.

Pendlebury is an athlete/former basketballer picked at 5 in an evenly weak draft unlike the strong 2003 draft, so I know who I have my money on to be the better player. If you want raving have a look at the Collingwood board where Pendlebury handpasses once in this video or any of Zeke's crap threads about Thomas, etc.

Scott Pendlebury.

also i would be hugely disspoined if my club picked up a number 2 draft pick and he turned out to be a tagger. the top 20 picks are usually reserved for future stars, not solid taggers. so dont kid urself by saying he did great jobs on stars of the game, that doesnt represent any ability of him being a future star what so ever.

Walker isn't a tagger and your football knowledge is very limited to that mob you call a football team. A better footballer is one that stops his man and still gets the ball, something you can't say about Chris Egan who is a downhill skier and unaccountable.

back to the topic... both players look like they will have a very successful career ahead. i must admitt i was suprised that collingwood opted for thomas at #2, but now that initial worry has turned into great optimism for young daisy thomas. looks to be a good catch. murphy aswell will be a very solid contributor to a struggling midfield.

I'd be more worried about your midfield and it's future after our onballers pantsed your midfield in round 20. Buckley, Holland, Burns, Licuria, etc. are ageing like the rest of Collingwood senior players and will hit the wall in 2-3 years, if not this year.

I wouldn't be putting my money on Didak, Thomas and Pendelbury to replace them as inside players and ballwinners.

 

[Jean Claude Vas Deferens]

You've gotta be kidding with this question... ask me again in two to three years time.

 

[socrates]

The Blues R In Huge Financial Debt And Have The Worst Team In The Afl. Suck On That!
Id Take Collingwoods Midifeld Over Urz Anyday.

 

[celtic_pride]

The Blues R In Huge Financial Debt And Have The Worst Team In The Afl. Suck On That!
Id Take Collingwoods Midifeld Over Urz Anyday.

carlton have won more flags than Collingwood and have a much richer modern history. How many collingwood players made the official team of the century anyway ?

 

[Silvagnis]

Murphy>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Thomas.

 

[F/D]

Would still rather Thommo


Walker 17 possies, I am amazed

 

[Silvagnis]

Would still rather Thommo


Walker 17 possies, I am amazed

Murphy has class and poise when he wins his own ball and as for those who query his kicking!

 

[Flag Man]

Thomas might turn into a handy flanker.

Murphy won't make it.

Thomas by default.

 

[Silvagnis]

Thomas might turn into a handy flanker.

Murphy won't make it.

Thomas by default.

Maybe Brady Rawlings should win our B & F!

 

[Flag Man]

Maybe Brady Rawlings should win our B & F!

He would have bagged 3 or 4 by now.

 

[F/D]

He would have bagged 3 or 4 by now.

Oh god, how true

 

[Silvagnis]

He would have bagged 3 or 4 by now.

You must be so proud of the Roos that a dirty tagger like Rawlings is winning your B & F!

Road to nowhere/Gold Coast.

 

[F/D]

You must be so proud of the Roos that a dirty tagger like Rawlings is winning your B & F!

Road to nowhere/Gold Coast.

How in gods name did Teague win a B&F?



Oh well, just shows our duds are your guns