Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[Fadge]

I like how you keep bowling long hops and when you get hit for six ( very time) you come back - with another long hop.

The Collingwood posters have schooled the Carlton folk in every way imaginable in this thread.

The knot tying from the desperate Carlton posters has been astounding to watch, and has almost been as pathetic as their team's on field performance since the turn of the century.

Just to remind you ( again) the earth isn't flat, your abacus is broken and you couldn't use one anyway and the world didn't start 21 years ago....ask google if you need verification.

Oh, I'm fully aware the world didn't start 21 years ago, but the 'New Carlton' did.

Desperate.

Mediocre.

Spoon collecting.

And it's been glorious to watch.

 

[Worm4]

Oh I am not bantering, just giving my unbiased views on two also ran teams.

The Pies have injuries to significant players, so have an excuse. The squib effort the Blues put up against my battling mob was dire and a reflection of the weak soul-less core of that Club. I see little future relevance, beyond ignominy for them.

Sydney beat up on our 2nds. Congrats on the double standards comment. Really well thought out

 

[Cyclops]

Sydney beat up on our 2nds. Congrats on the double standards comment. Really well thought out

You're not special, they beat up our firsts!

Collingwood in front again!

 

[Fadge]

You all reckon Cripps is shit, I will ask the question for the 3rd time and maybe one of you gutless turds will have a good answer - why does your coach continue to tag, and double tag Cripps every time they play against Carlton ?

Who is Collingwood's go to tagger for Cripps?

Let alone having multiple players tag him...

If you mean 'accountability at stoppages', I think you'll find all the good teams do that.

Otherwise you risk finding yourself in the situation where the best player in the competition is given the time and space at a stoppage 20 metres from goal, with about a minute to go in a tight game, and that player kicks the sealer.....

 

[Fadge]

I'm actually feeling very confident about the Cats game.

We are a bit stronger compared to the last time we played them, and quite frankly we have no reason to fear any team at this stage.

Leave the other teams do the worrying about us. As long as we don't have to travel interstate in the finals, then there is a serious chance of a Blues flag this year.

Given we're seeing Carlton's best team in over two decades coming up against a Geelong team that is somewhere in the vicinity of their 18th to 20th best team since the turn of the decade, you'd hope Carlton would go into the game with a fair degree of confidence...

 

[doppleganger]

You all reckon Cripps is shit, I will ask the question for the 3rd time and maybe one of you gutless turds will have a good answer - why does your coach continue to tag, and double tag Cripps every time they play against Carlton ?

Nobody said Cripps was shit.

It was your nonsense about him dominating Collingwood that people are laughing at.

The mighty Crippa doesn't even avg 10 kicks against the Pies and has only won 3 of 15 games against Collingwood.

You think that is a domination.

But there was one game...

Cripps has dominated Collingwood more than any other player in the league in recent memory.

It is you who is doing doing all of your own heavy lifting and getting no results (bit like Crippa in a way) whilst the "gutless turds" watch on in amazement.

No idea why you continue to double down on your ridiculous claim...sometimes you gotta know when to fold em.

 

[Fadge]

But there was one game...

That Carlton not only lost, but meant they weren't going to be playing finals for the 9th season running...

 

[Arr0w]

Pie supporters schooled us?

 

[doppleganger]

That Carlton not only lost, but meant they weren't going to be playing finals for the 9th season running...

Should keep it current Fadge, it is meant to be a 2024 thread after all.

In 2024 GOATcos dominated Carlton, gets 10 votes from coaches, and kicks the sealer.

Crippa had 11 kicks (above avg for him) and walked off as a loser again (normal for him against the Pies).

 

[Worm4]

Nobody said Cripps was shit.

It was your nonsense about him dominating Collingwood that people are laughing at.

The mighty Crippa doesn't even avg 10 kicks against the Pies and has only won 3 of 15 games against Collingwood.

You think that is a domination.

But there was one game...

It is you who is doing doing all of your own heavy lifting and getting no results (bit like Crippa in a way) whilst the "gutless turds" watch on in amazement.

No idea why you continue to double down on your ridiculous claim...sometimes you gotta know when to fold em.

Greg Williams only averaged 12 kicks a game as well. I suppose he never dominated either. Go figure

 

[doppleganger]

Greg Williams only averaged 12 kicks a game as well. I suppose he never dominated either. Go figure

The Bagger default post about the 20th century.

Rinse and repeat.

 

[Worm4]

The Bagger default post about the 20th century.

Rinse and repeat.

You think your win a debate about how many kicks a player averages in a game ? Oh dear

 

[doppleganger]

You think your win a debate about how many kicks a player averages in a game ? Oh dear

The "debate" (that you started) was whether Crippa had dominated Collingwood more than any other player in the league in recent memory.

It seems your recent memory is failing you and you are now getting agitated as a result.

Good to know your long term memory is sound though, hence the want to talk 20th century stuff again.

 

[The Fantom]

That is 2,000,000 + entitled Bloods supporters and growing Ozwide. It is fun watching shrivelled vic bias clubs struggle for oxygen.

You’re so irrelevant that you have to come into a Carlton Collingwood banter thread to get attention.

Just start one for your own club and your greatest rival GWS and see if you can fill a page.

Not sure what planet you live on but is that way >

 

[Worm4]

The "debate" (that you started) was whether Crippa had dominated Collingwood more than any other player in the league in recent memory.

It seems your recent memory is failing you and you are now getting agitated as a result.

Good to know your long term memory is sound though, hence the want to talk 20th century stuff again.

I'll concede my flippant remark , however 26 possies on average over a 10 year stretch is pretty bloody good in my opinion. The win/loss ratio is irrelevant.
And yes, he does get tagged by Collingwood because they know how damaging he can be with feeding the ball out of packs. If you can't concede that, then you aren't a true footy follower

 

[Fadge]

You’re so irrelevant that you have to come into a Carlton Collingwood banter thread to get attention.

Just start one for your own club and your greatest rival GWS and see if you can fill a page.

Not sure what planet you live on but is that way >

More than happy to hear the thoughts of neutrals, particularly those who support a team that is clearly currently head and shoulders ahead of every other team in the competition.

We Collingwood supporters aren't as precious as other supporter groups...

 

[Fadge]

I'll concede my flippant remark , however 26 possies on average over a 10 year stretch is pretty bloody good in my opinion. The win/loss ratio is irrelevant.
And yes, he does get tagged by Collingwood because they know how damaging he can be with feeding the ball out of packs. If you can't concede that, then you aren't a true footy follower

So who from Collingwood has tagged Cripps over the journey?

 

[Worm4]

So who from Collingwood has tagged Cripps over the journey?

2024 - pendlebury, plus the use of lipinski as a blocker as well.

 

[doppleganger]

I'll concede my flippant remark , however 26 possies on average over a 10 year stretch is pretty bloody good in my opinion.

Cripps is a great player, but he hasnt dominated Collingwood.

The win/loss ratio is irrelevant.

Please.

And yes, he does get tagged by Collingwood because they know how damaging he can be with feeding the ball out of packs. If you can't concede that, then you aren't a true footy follower

Most good players cop some heat at stoppage.
Cripps has been a standout contest and clearance player for a while now, but in 2024 GOATcos has gone past him.

 

[doppleganger]

2024 - pendlebury, plus the use of lipinski as a blocker as well.

You claim "tagged" all we did was get Pendles to play on Cripps, and Pendles beat him.

Pendles had a bigger influence on the game than Crippa. Tis good when a couple of quality mids go at it.

 

[Worm4]

Cripps has been a standout contest and clearance player for a while now, but in 2024 GOATcos has gone past him.

1 player is in his prime, the other is a few years past his prime. Standard banter for dopes

 

[doppleganger]

1 player is in his prime, the other is a few years past his prime. Standard banter for dopes

Yeah it is unfair to compare a 28-29 year old Crippa with a 21 year old....because it is the 21 year old who is in their prime!!

That is why we put a 36 year old Pendles on Cripps, and poor old Crippa couldn't go with Sir Scott

 

[Worm4]

Yeah it is unfair to compare a 28-29 year old Crippa with a 21 year old....because it is the 21 year old who is in their prime!!

That is why we put a 36 year old Pendles on Cripps, and poor old Crippa couldn't go with Sir Scott

He is 29. Not sure why you would type 28-29. Is odd

 

[Scritchyscroony]

1 player is in his prime, the other is a few years past his prime. Standard banter for dopes

I'm feeling a bit sorry for you worm. You are copping an absolute hiding in this back and forth.
I'll try and help you out by changing the line of discussion....
Huge game against the cats. Should be a cracker. Walsh to get lots of uncontested possessions.
I reckon you guys should get it done and maintain thread title bragging rights for this week at least.

 

[doppleganger]

He is 29. Not sure why you would type 28-29. Is odd

He was 28 at the start of the season, and had a bday to turn 29, so 28-29.

The Deep Dive: When do AFL players reach their peak performance?

It's a general belief that if you're in your late 20s, you're in your athletic peak, so we've put it to the test and measured the output of every 100-game AFL player since 2001 to determine when the 'peak' age really is.

www.espn.com.au

Midfielders

Optimal range: 23-29 (average rating points: 12.63)

Peak year: 26 (13.07)

LoL at you thinking it is unfair on Cripps to compare him to a 21 year old Nick!!?

Just wait til Nick gets to his prime years!!