Banter Who will be Better in 2025, Collingwood or Carlton? Part 4

[adammania9]

How many brownlows has that little half back chipscab got?

How many fond memories on the last saturday in September does 37% have?

 

[Fadge]

How many brownlows has Daicos got?

As many as Cripps had after three seasons.

But two more top 3 finishes.

How many AFLCA Awards does Cripps have?

How many premierships does Cripps have?

 

[Fadge]

How many fond memories on the last saturday in September does 37% have?

That's a great new nickname - Mr 37%

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Cripps joined a team that finished 8th in 2013 and won a final, and took 10 years to win another final at the club.

Daicos joined a team that finished 17th in 2021, and were allegedly set for 5 to 10 years of Carlton type mediocrity. But then finished 4th on his first season (playing in a winning final, with narrow losses to the two 2022 Grand Finalists in the other final), and winning a premiership in his second season.

Cripps has no guile or initiative, predictable footballer, selfish player like Robert Harvey

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[carlton_99]

Hilarious all these Pies piling on just proving that they don't have the ability to even be a little bit objective about anything Carlton related.

 

[Fadge]

Sheezel has rabbit covered in coaches and brownlowv votes at the same age, but you already know that as fact

Wrong.

Again.

As usual.

Brownlow votes at 19 years 10 months:
Daicos - 11
Sheezel - 3

Brownlow votes at 20 years 10 months:
Daicos - 39
Sheezel - 18

Brownlow votes at 21 years 10 months:
Daicos - 77
Sheezel - ?

 

[kreuze_missile]

Hilarious all these Pies piling on just proving that they don't have the ability to even be a little bit objective about anything Carlton related.

Corn Cobbers is my favourite.

The ultimate Fadge fluffer.

 

[Fadge]

Hilarious all these Pies piling on just proving that they don't have the ability to even be a little bit objective about anything Carlton related.

We're just stating facts.

We're not the one who brought up Brownlow votes or used the term 'matchwinner' about a player that has won 37% of the games in which he's played....

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Wrong.

Again.

As usual.

Brownlow votes at 19 years 10 months:
Daicos - 11
Sheezel - 3

Brownlow votes at 20 years 10 months:
Daicos - 39
Sheezel - 18

Brownlow votes at 21 years 10 months:
Daicos - 77
Sheezel - ?

Beautiful young player Sheez but he'd be embarrassed being compared to Daics, unfair on the kid

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Still waiting for an explanation on Cox>Walsh...

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Still waiting for an explanation on Cox>Walsh...

Cox is a match-winner, Walsh another try-hard like Cripps

0-60 [emoji16]

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Cox is a match-winner, Walsh another try-hard like Cripps

0-60 [emoji16]

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Cox can barely keep his goggles on during games. Walsh a Gary Ayres medallist.

Says it all really.

 

[adammania9]

Cox can barely keep his goggles on during games. Walsh a Gary Ayres medallist.

Says it all really.

Only Carlton fans can tell you what Walsh has done in finals. Every footy fan for the next 50 years will remember Cox's September legacy. It's up to Walshy now to see if he can patch up the gap between the two.

 

[carlton_99]

We're just stating facts.

We're not the one who brought up Brownlow votes or used the term 'matchwinner' about a player that has won 37% of the games in which he's played....

So you think Patrick Cripps is not a matchwinner. And your evidence is team win%. As I said confirming my view that you do not have the ability to be objective about Carlton.

 

[Fadge]

So you think Patrick Cripps is not a matchwinner. And your evidence is team win%. As I said confirming my view that you do not have the ability to be objective about Carlton.

'Matchwinner' is not a term I'd choose to use about a player that has a 37% win percentage and has won two finals in his 12 year career...

Particularly when another poster uses it to differentiate between him and Daicos.

 

[BlueBalls#17]

Yeah nah, Cox is way better than Walsh.

Tell me you follow collingwood and not football with out saying you follow collingwood and not football.

We will remember Cox for his september efforts for the next 50 years.... I cant. I just cant.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

'Matchwinner' is not a term I'd choose to use about a player that has a 37% win percentage and has won two finals in his 12 year career...

Particularly when another poster uses it to differentiate between him and Daicos.

Do you think a single coach in the AFL would agree with you?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Do you think a single coach in the AFL would agree with you?

The match-winner at Carlton is CURNOW, if he gets enough supply Carlton win, Cripps as the chief inside mid is the main source of supply so that's why he gets tagged

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

Do you think a single coach in the AFL would agree with you?

OK, Let's do a little exercise on 'Matchwinners'....

I'll highlight a game where Daicos is considered a 'matchwinner', and you can respond in kind with a game where Cripps is considered a 'matchwinner'. We'll keep going until the 'matchwinning games' are exhausted for one player, remembering Cripps has had a 12 year career, compared to Daicos a 3 year career.





Your turn.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

OK, Let's do a little exercise on 'Matchwinners'....

I'll highlight a game where Daicos is considered a 'matchwinner', and you can respond in kind with a game where Cripps is considered a 'matchwinner'. We'll keep going until the 'matchwinning games' are exhausted for one player, remembering Cripps has had a 12 year career, compared to Daicos a 3 year career.

View attachment 2218062
View attachment 2218064
View attachment 2218065

Your turn.

Find me a single game Nicky has played better than this and I'll indulge in your pathetic game. 38 touches 4 goals.

 

[Fadge]

Find me a single game Nicky has played better than this and I'll indulge in your pathetic game. 38 touches 4 goals.

So that's your Exhibit A?

A game in 2019 where Carlton finished 16th, at Docklands against an interstate team?

Interesting.

My next example:




Back to you.

 

[Worm4]

0-60

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

5 - 1

 

[Worm4]

Every footy fan for the next 50 years will remember Cox's September legacy.

Well i don't remember any particular legacy so that statement is wrong

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

So that's your Exhibit A?

A game in 2019 where Carlton finished 16th, at Docklands against an interstate team?

Interesting.

My next example:
View attachment 2218073
View attachment 2218077
View attachment 2218080

Back to you.

Ehhh compare the stats Fudger. That was not better than Cripps game vs the Lions that year.

Less goals, clearances, contested possessions, score involvements...

Try again Fudger.

Or we could skip to the part where you admit Nicky has never had a better performance than that...

 

[Matrix10]

Only Carlton fans can tell you what Walsh has done in finals. Every footy fan for the next 50 years will remember Cox's September legacy. It's up to Walshy now to see if he can patch up the gap between the two.

He needs to try and make a contest in a last minute stoppage ball up with the scores been a few points the difference with the final siren seconds away when the little master is lurking , oh wait … he did, Like lightning.. swoops on the loose ball , onto his right he goes. BANG. Goal to the ltitle Master. Over to Walsh , crouched down , head in hands. WTF do I do